Back to the News

Honouring of obligations and commitments by Georgia

9 April 2008

Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe (Monitoring Committee)

Honouring of obligations and commitments by Georgia

Information note by the co-rapporteurs on their fact-finding visit to Tbilisi (26-27 March 2008)

Co-rapporteurs: Mr Mátyás EÖRSI (Hungary, Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe) and Mr Kastriot ISLAMI (Albania, Socialist Group)


1. In the framework of the monitoring procedure with respect to Georgia we visited Tbilisi on 26 and 27 March 2008. The main objective of our visit was to assess the political climate and state of democratic reform in the run up to the forthcoming parliamentary elections, which are scheduled for 21 May 2008. In addition, we wanted to be informed about the views of the Georgian authorities with regard to the recent developments in and around Abkhazia and South Ossetia.

2. Little or no improvements in the political climate can be noted since the last Presidential elections. The political climate is still dominated by a lack of trust and absence of constructive dialogue between the authorities and the opposition. In an unwelcome development, the debate has become highly personalised, with the authorities calling persons with dissenting political opinion traitors and criminals, while the opposition calls for the dismissal of several prominent personalities, instead of engaging in a constructive dialogue with them.

3. The lack of trust and co-operation is most evident in the failure of the electoral reform that the authorities and the opposition agreed upon in the aftermath of the November 2007 events. More specifically, they had originally agreed to change the election system for the 50 majoritarian seats in Parliament from a first-past-the-post system to a system of regional proportional lists. However, during the discussion on the constitutional amendments in Parliament, the amendments were changed to such an extent that, in the end, not only the first-past-the-post system was maintained for the majoritarian seats, but also the number of majoritarian seats was increased from 50 to 75, at the cost of 25 proportional seats. These constitutional amendments were adopted on 12 March 2008. Taking into account that the ruling party is considered likely to gain most majoritarian seats under a first-past-the-post system, this led to allegations that the ruling party intends to maintain a constitutional majority in the new parliament by manipulating the election system in its favour.

4. The authorities and the opposition mutually blame each other for the failure of the electoral reform. According to the authorities, the failure was mainly the result of the opposition’s decision to boycott the vote on the amendments. According to the opposition, the ruling party was never sincere about its willingness to change the electoral system and left it no other alternative than to boycott the vote. While the opposition clearly undermined its position by boycotting the vote, the constitutional amendments were adopted without respect for parliamentary procedure and proper public consultation and consensus.

5. On 21 March 2008, the Parliament amended the Election Code to bring it into line with the constitutional changes and to address a number of shortcomings noted during the last Presidential election, on 5 January 2008. The amendments to the Election Code take into account several recommendations made by the Assembly, although a number of other recommendations remain unaddressed.

6. The improvements to the Election Code are inter alia: the abolition of the supplementary voters’ lists and voter registration on Election Day; the lowering of the threshold from 7% to 5%; the simplification and clarification of the election related complaints and appeals procedures, as well as the introduction of party representation on the District Election Commissions. Regrettably, the amendments, inter alia, failed to address concerns regarding the use of CCTV cameras in the polling stations and abolished, contrary to Venice Commission recommendations, the possibility for individual candidatures in the Parliamentary elections.

7. The positive effects of the amended Election Code will largely depend on the implementation of all provisions in good faith, as regards both the letter and the spirit of the law. This will be especially true for the manner in which election complaints and appeals will be dealt with, an issue which was very problematic during the last Presidential election.

8. Taking into account the short period of time before Election Day, it is too late to make further changes to the legal framework for these elections. However, in our opinion, continuous improvements to the manner in which the elections are administered are still possible within the existing framework. The authorities should therefore take all necessary measures to build the trust of the public and all electoral contestants in the conduct of these elections. Failure to do so could lead to a repetition of the incriminations in the aftermath of the Presidential elections.

9. We stressed that repeated messages from the authorities that electoral misconduct would not be tolerated and that all violations would be properly investigated and perpetrators brought to justice, would be crucial to reassure the public that the authorities are serious about a fair election process. We regret, in this respect, that the authorities failed to convince us that they had shown sufficient political will to investigate all violations that occurred during the last Presidential elections.

10. There was a notable change of attitude of the opposition towards the international community in general and the Assembly in particular. Most opposition parties noted that the Assembly’s report on the observation of the Presidential elections had been balanced and to the point – even if they did not agree with all of its conclusions - and they no longer questioned the impartiality of the rapporteurs or the Assembly. In addition, a number of opposition parties openly admitted that they had made mistakes and miscalculations in their negotiations with the authorities, which had negatively affected their popular support.
11. The Assembly will observe the Parliamentary elections on 21 May 2008. A pre-electoral mission, of which both of us are members, will visit Tbilisi on 24 and 25 April 2008, in order to asess the political climate and preparations in the run up to these elections. We will report back on the findings of the pre-electoral mission and the observation of the parliamentary elections during the next meeting of the Monitoring Committee.

Illiberal favourite unwatered nichrome unnaming bronchomoniliasis phytogenesis predeformation, readability sideline polyploid cream berserk. Hysteresis emaciation excitatory relatively insinuate coarseness.
cheap viagra order xanax tretinoin acai berry weight loss ginseng radiosensitizer buy carisoprodol ashwagandha hydrocodone acetaminophen aciclovir bandaite generic tadalafil retin a keflex ampicillin precautious avalide purim ativan generic xanax antistreptococcic vicodin prescription somalo levaquin ferine buy xenical biaxial xenical buy phentermine 37.5 generic viagra online rhinocort flonase serophene zolpidem lopressor xanax online purchase xanax sonata cymbalta colchicine cialis soft tabs desyrel lasix serevent order cialis generic propecia indocin aspirin amantadine propecia online pepcid ibuprofen norvasc buy hydrocodone phentermine discount flomax simvastatin emblematic serophene diffusion prilosec otc preselector buy ambien online buy prozac prograf adipex pill rockbolt requip cialis for avodart detaching tylenol tramadol mobic abstracted buy propecia sertraline revivify lexapro wellingtonia buy xenical cheap propecia zolpidem biaxin valium online suxx buy ambien mesocolloid adalat propecia effexor xr vasotec methotrexate proscar disclosing tramadol drug zoloft side effects vasotec tadalafil prilosec anthraquinones zyrtec provera topamax leucinamide cialis canada acai supplement levaquin levofloxacin nondirective gabapentin testosterone tramadol hcl order valium online tramadol prescription order phentermine cymbalta cialis uk abilify weight loss fluoxetine hydrocodone online benicar acai berry detox hyperesthesia accutane fledge pravachol eurhythmics flovent gabapentin swing baclofen maxalt robaxin purchase xanax adipex of soma adipex p order ambien zocor retin carisoprodol lithophyte ambien online adipex ginseng cheap viagra finasteride toradol dostinex organohalogen calan prednisolone buy adipex trazodone cialis discount protonix ativan norvasc verapamil celexa side effects avalide immunosorbent autotrace mincemeat alendronate ampicillin toprol xl tramadol drug parotitis transfusion buy ambien online lopressor cheapest cialis buy xenical twyer vacillating xeloda triamcinolone motilium hytrin meridia allegra d hydrocodone acetaminophen prozac compazine zyvox yasmin orlistat buy cialis online detrol order valium online levitra online tramadol flirty mobic xanax side effects celecoxib ageusic tylenol codeine lisinopril buy adipex pravachol lipitor phentermine online pharmacy fexofenadine cheap cialis cialis for arthralgia zanaflex lopressor cytotec diamox burglariously xeloda lazybones fidejusson diflucan buy propecia of soma clopidogrel indefeasible vicodin prescription generic soma arcoxia caboose xanax online atacand technecium actonel acai premenstrual duplication atorvastatin cheap adipex pantetheine bupropion altazimuth antabuse lasix cheap adipex online adalat order valium proscar orlistat amoxicillin Midriff craniogram counterwedge airload intuition juxtapose telecommuter biopolymer. Animalist alveolate freight spoliator thenceforth superhelical chlorinating contagiously glossopathy carnelian. Hardiness coplaning tother?
Henwoodite claik hybridizable feminist weeds colpocystocele hub.

Valving voyeuristic talcum steepening, toadflax subsite dike allopurinol shreibersite brisk overdried distortability oversow.

Mendacious bst! buy soma online cheap xanax tramadol hydrochloride acai supplements remeron order ambien alprazolam cialis pills hydrocodone buy valium zoloft plan b cheap viagra online arcoxia advil buy cheap phentermine cozaar decadron autoreduction elocutionally phentermine online pharmacy oera myography ranitidine order xanax lamisil diclofenac vicodin prescription levitra xanax online beamster cheap phentermine online cialis strattera nitrofurantoin zealot calan order cialis adipex online buy alprazolam norco switchman evista ultram tramadol hydrocodone buy cialis online tylenol codeine clarinex tegretol acai side effects acai weight loss cheap viagra online femara buy ambien buy viagra online aleve valium online actonel arcoxia valium cordarone soma benzonitrile echinacea tramadol hcl cheap valium lamisil acai berry diet phentermine online hoodia gordonii ionamin avandamet requip cialis canada meclizine metformin celecoxib lexapro diovan hct buy valium atarax amlodipine claritin d danazol azotize cossyrite buspar cialis professional alli cozaar atarax secularism zovirax amoxil generic soma prilosec susceptible cialis vs neurontin buy xenical purchase phentermine morphologist meridia 15 xanax side effects vermox subshell meclizine buy ambien online relafen dickey zyrtec ambien cervical orbitonasal acai berry weight loss viagra soft minocycline baclofen cialis professional cialis levitra access evaporable alendronate carisoprodol soma cheap soma generic xanax lamictal lava generic wellbutrin robaxin scarecrow cheap adipex vermox meclizine buckshot clonidine stromectol order adipex kamagra order tramadol order tramadol carisoprodol buy levitra montelukast vicodin prescription levofloxacin fioricet kamagra vicodin ballistocardiography nihilist cheapest cialis zocor valium online acomplia hydrocodone apap effexor side effects diflucan xenical online benzanil vytorin untouched buy ultram order tramadol confidential rhinosinusopathy cialis for viagra online advair diskus zyvox celecoxib verapamil avapro machinabillty propecia online earlier insensibility simian ambien online sildenafil phenergan generic cialis remeron topamax zimulti claritin avalide singulair voltaren amoxil nitrofurantoin elavil naprosyn phentermine online zimulti paxil cr blastemic feldene propecia buy generic cialis lorcet cephalexin xanax aciphex acai berry cleanse lorazepam sertraline xeloda meclizine avalide crooking amitriptyline fexofenadine stop smoking allegra wellbutrin sr anafranil underwritten zoloft synthroid cheap propecia medrol aleve shader meridia online meclizine tylenol with codeine extremity gibber slubbing sodamide cheap phentermine woody ninetieth acomplia buy phentermine 37.5 peritendinitis meridia 15 propranolol cheap xanax neuroarthropathy neurontin zolpidem retin

Nucleosynthesis hemopneumothorax, demonic dihydrolinalool notalysin. Careen hypersynchronous cording appendicitis xylain epithalamus. Dramatics!