| 04/10/2011 | [print] | 
| Members participating in the vote on : | National sovereignty and statehood in contemporary international law: the need for clarification (Doc. 12689) Amendment 22 | 
| In favour | 14 | 
| Against | 81 | 
| Abstention | 2 | 
| Ms Karin  ANDERSEN | NO | UEL | Against | 
| Mme Magdalina  ANIKASHVILI | GE | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Mörđur  ÁRNASON | IS | SOC | Against | 
| M. Gerard  BARCIA DUEDRA | AD | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Doris  BARNETT | DE | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Deniz  BAYKAL | TR | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Marieluise  BECK | DE | ALDE | Against | 
| M. Laurent  BÉTEILLE | FR | EPP/CD | Abstention | 
| Mme Gülsün  BILGEHAN | TR | SOC | In favour | 
| Mme Anne  BRASSEUR | LU | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Márton  BRAUN | HU | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Ms Sylvia  CANEL | DE | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Mikael  CEDERBRATT | SE | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Ms Lise  CHRISTOFFERSEN | NO | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Boriss  CILEVICS | LV | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Ahmet Berat  ÇONKAR | TR | EDG | Against | 
| Mr Igor  CORMAN | MD | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Arcadio  DÍAZ TEJERA | ES | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Saban  DISLI | TR | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Ms Daphné  DUMERY | BE | NR | Against | 
| Mme Tülin  ERKAL KARA | TR | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Joseph  FALZON | MT | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Ms Sevinj  FATALIYEVA | AZ | EDG | Against | 
| Mr György  FRUNDA | RO | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Giorgi  GABASHVILI | GE | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Valeriu  GHILETCHI | MD | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Andreas  GROSS | CH | SOC | In favour | 
| Ms Annette  GROTH | DE | UEL | Against | 
| Ms Pelin  GÜNDES BAKIR | TR | Against | |
| Ms Carina  HÄGG | SE | SOC | Against | 
| M. Sabir  HAJIYEV | AZ | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Margus  HANSON | EE | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Davit  HARUTYUNYAN | AM | EDG | In favour | 
| Mr Andres  HERKEL | EE | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Serhiy  HOLOVATY | UA | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Jim  HOOD | UK | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Péter  HOPPÁL | HU | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Joachim  HÖRSTER | DE | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Andrej  HUNKO | DE | UEL | Against | 
| Mr Rafael  HUSEYNOV | AZ | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Mats  JOHANSSON | SE | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Ferenc  KALMÁR | HU | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Burhan  KAYATÜRK | TR | EPP/CD | Against | 
| M. Haluk  KOÇ | TR | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Konstantin  KOSACHEV | RU | EDG | In favour | 
| Mme Athina  KYRIAKIDOU | CY | SOC | Against | 
| M. Philippe  MAHOUX | BE | SOC | Against | 
| M. Theo  MAISSEN | CH | EPP/CD | In favour | 
| Mme Christine  MARIN | FR | EPP/CD | Against | 
| M. Dick  MARTY | CH | ALDE | In favour | 
| Mme Meritxell  MATEU | AD | ALDE | Against | 
| Sir Alan  MEALE | UK | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Nursuna  MEMECAN | TR | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Akaki  MINASHVILI | GE | ALDE | Against | 
| M. Patrick  MORIAU | BE | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Joăo Bosco  MOTA AMARAL | PT | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Pier Marino  MULARONI | SM | ALDE | Against | 
| M. Felix  MÜRI | CH | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Gebhard  NEGELE | LI | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Ms Carina  OHLSSON | SE | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Sandra  OSBORNE | UK | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Liliana  PALIHOVICI | MD | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Valery  PARFENOV | RU | EDG | In favour | 
| Mr Alexander  POCHINOK | RU | EDG | In favour | 
| Mr Geir  POLLESTAD | NO | ALDE | Against | 
| Ms Zaruhi  POSTANJYAN | AM | EPP/CD | In favour | 
| Ms Marietta de POURBAIX-LUNDIN | SE | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Christos  POURGOURIDES | CY | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Jakob  PRESECNIK | SI | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Ms Andreja  RIHTER | SI | SOC | In favour | 
| M. René  ROUQUET | FR | SOC | In favour | 
| M. Armen  RUSTAMYAN | AM | SOC | In favour | 
| Mr Indrek  SAAR | EE | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Ingjerd Schie  SCHOU | NO | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Ms Marina  SCHUSTER | DE | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Jim  SHERIDAN | UK | SOC | In favour | 
| Mr Yanaki  STOILOV | BG | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Christoph  STRÄSSER | DE | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Doris  STUMP | CH | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Björn von SYDOW | SE | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Vilmos  SZABÓ | HU | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Melinda  SZÉKYNÉ SZTRÉMI | HU | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mme Chiora  TAKTAKISHVILI | GE | ALDE | Against | 
| Lord John E.  TOMLINSON | UK | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Anette  TRETTEBERGSTUEN | NO | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Petré  TSISKARISHVILI | GE | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Ahmet Kutalmis  TÜRKES | TR | EDG | Against | 
| Mr Yildirim Tugrul  TÜRKES | TR | EDG | Against | 
| Ms Dana  VÁHALOVÁ | CZ | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Egidijus  VAREIKIS | LT | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Luca  VOLONTČ | IT | EPP/CD | Against | 
| M. Hansjörg  WALTER | CH | ALDE | Against | 
| Ms Gisela  WURM | AT | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Karl  ZELLER | IT | EPP/CD | Abstention | 
| Mme Marie-Jo  ZIMMERMANN | FR | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Emanuelis  ZINGERIS | LT | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mme Naira  ZOHRABYAN | AM | ALDE | In favour |