| 21/04/2015 | [print] | 
| Members participating in the vote on : | Mass surveillance  (Doc. 13734) Amendment 11  | 
    
| In favour | 17 | 
| Against | 113 | 
| Abstention | 11 | 
Mr Ferdinando  AIELLO  | 
          IT  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Werner  AMON  | 
          AT  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Paride  ANDREOLI  | 
          SM  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Ingrid  ANTICEVIC MARINOVIC  | 
          HR  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Ben-Oni  ARDELEAN  | 
          RO  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          In favour  | 
        
Mr Volodymyr  ARIEV  | 
          UA  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          In favour  | 
        
Mr Egemen  BAGIS  | 
          TR  | 
          EC  | 
          Abstention  | 
        
M. Gérard  BAPT  | 
          FR  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Doris  BARNETT  | 
          DE  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Deniz  BAYKAL  | 
          TR  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Boryslav  BEREZA  | 
          UA  | 
          NR  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Andris  BERZIN  | 
          LV  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mme Gülsün  BILGEHAN  | 
          TR  | 
          SOC  | 
          Abstention  | 
        
Mme Maryvonne  BLONDIN  | 
          FR  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mme Maryvonne  BLONDIN  | 
          FR  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Marek  BOROWSKI  | 
          PL  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Gerold  BÜCHEL  | 
          LI  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Abstention  | 
        
M. André  BUGNON  | 
          CH  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Vannino  CHITI  | 
          IT  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Lise  CHRISTOFFERSEN  | 
          NO  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Henryk  CIOCH  | 
          PL  | 
          EC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr James  CLAPPISON  | 
          UK  | 
          EC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Igor  CORMAN  | 
          MD  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Telmo  CORREIA  | 
          PT  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Corneliu-Mugurel  COZMANCIUC  | 
          RO  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Yves  CRUCHTEN  | 
          LU  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Manlio  DI STEFANO  | 
          IT  | 
          NR  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Saban  DISLI  | 
          TR  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          In favour  | 
        
Mr Sergio  DIVINA  | 
          IT  | 
          NR  | 
          In favour  | 
        
M. Namik  DOKLE  | 
          AL  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mme Josette  DURRIEU  | 
          FR  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Lady Diana  ECCLES  | 
          UK  | 
          EC  | 
          In favour  | 
        
Mme Tülin  ERKAL KARA  | 
          TR  | 
          EC  | 
          In favour  | 
        
Mr Claudio  FAZZONE  | 
          IT  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Joseph Beppe  FENECH ADAMI  | 
          MT  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mme Doris  FIALA  | 
          CH  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Gvozden Srecko  FLEGO  | 
          HR  | 
          SOC  | 
          In favour  | 
        
M. Bernard  FOURNIER  | 
          FR  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Hans  FRANKEN  | 
          NL  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Abstention  | 
        
Mr Giuseppe  GALATI  | 
          IT  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Adele  GAMBARO  | 
          IT  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Karl  GARĐARSSON  | 
          IS  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Tina  GHASEMI  | 
          SE  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Valeriu  GHILETCHI  | 
          MD  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Francesco Maria  GIRO  | 
          IT  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Vladyslav  GOLUB  | 
          UA  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Carlos Alberto  GONÇALVES  | 
          PT  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Andreas  GROSS  | 
          CH  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Annette  GROTH  | 
          DE  | 
          UEL  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Hans Fredrik  GRŘVAN  | 
          NO  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Nazmi  GÜR  | 
          TR  | 
          UEL  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Hamid  HAMID  | 
          BG  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Gábor  HARANGOZÓ  | 
          HU  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Alfred  HEER  | 
          CH  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Abstention  | 
        
Mr Pavel  HOLÍK  | 
          CZ  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Anette  HÜBINGER  | 
          DE  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Andrej  HUNKO  | 
          DE  | 
          UEL  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Gediminas  JAKAVONIS  | 
          LT  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Kristin Řrmen  JOHNSEN  | 
          NO  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Lotta  JOHNSSON FORNARVE  | 
          SE  | 
          UEL  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Ögmundur  JÓNASSON  | 
          IS  | 
          UEL  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Antti  KAIKKONEN  | 
          FI  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Niklas  KARLSSON  | 
          SE  | 
          SOC  | 
          In favour  | 
        
Mr Bogdan  KLICH  | 
          PL  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Igor  KOLMAN  | 
          HR  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Ksenija  KORENJAK KRAMAR  | 
          SI  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Alev  KORUN  | 
          AT  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Elvira  KOVÁCS  | 
          RS  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Zviad  KVATCHANTIRADZE  | 
          GE  | 
          EC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Olof  LAVESSON  | 
          SE  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Pierre-Yves  LE BORGN'  | 
          FR  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Jean-Yves  LE DÉAUT  | 
          FR  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Jacques  LEGENDRE  | 
          FR  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Valentina  LESKAJ  | 
          AL  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Terry  LEYDEN  | 
          IE  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr George  LOUCAIDES  | 
          CY  | 
          UEL  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Carlo  LUCHERINI  | 
          IT  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Dirk Van der MAELEN  | 
          BE  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Guguli  MAGRADZE  | 
          GE  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Philippe  MAHOUX  | 
          BE  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Jagna  MARCZULAJTIS-WALCZAK  | 
          PL  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Rait  MARUSTE  | 
          EE  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Abstention  | 
        
Mme Meritxell  MATEU  | 
          AD  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Ana  MATO  | 
          ES  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Frano  MATUIC  | 
          HR  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Jean-Claude  MIGNON  | 
          FR  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Stefana  MILADINOVIC  | 
          RS  | 
          SOC  | 
          Abstention  | 
        
Mr Joăo Bosco  MOTA AMARAL  | 
          PT  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Abstention  | 
        
Ms Melita  MULIC  | 
          HR  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Killion  MUNYAMA  | 
          PL  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Andrei  NEGUTA  | 
          MD  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Miroslav  NENUTIL  | 
          CZ  | 
          SOC  | 
          Abstention  | 
        
Mr Nicos  NICOLAIDES  | 
          CY  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Michele  NICOLETTI  | 
          IT  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Aleksandar  NIKOLOSKI  | 
          MK  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Marcel  OBERWEIS  | 
          LU  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Marija  OBRADOVIC  | 
          RS  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr arko  OBRADOVIC  | 
          RS  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Judith  OEHRI  | 
          LI  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Carina  OHLSSON  | 
          SE  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Pieter  OMTZIGT  | 
          NL  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr José Ignacio  PALACIOS  | 
          ES  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Liliana  PALIHOVICI  | 
          MD  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Judith  PALLARÉS  | 
          AD  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Gabriela  PECKOVÁ  | 
          CZ  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          In favour  | 
        
M. Yves  POZZO DI BORGO  | 
          FR  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mme Carmen  QUINTANILLA  | 
          ES  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          In favour  | 
        
Mr Mika  RAATIKAINEN  | 
          FI  | 
          NR  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Luc  RECORDON  | 
          CH  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Andrea  RIGONI  | 
          IT  | 
          ALDE  | 
          In favour  | 
        
Mme Maria de Belém  ROSEIRA  | 
          PT  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Ŕlex  SÁEZ  | 
          ES  | 
          SOC  | 
          In favour  | 
        
Mr Kimmo  SASI  | 
          FI  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          In favour  | 
        
Mr Stefan  SCHENNACH  | 
          AT  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Nikolaus  SCHERAK  | 
          AT  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mme Elisabeth  SCHNEIDER-SCHNEITER  | 
          CH  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Ingjerd Schie  SCHOU  | 
          NO  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Ömer  SELVI  | 
          TR  | 
          EC  | 
          Abstention  | 
        
Mr Aleksandar  SENIC  | 
          RS  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Andrej  IRCELJ  | 
          SI  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Arturas  SKARDIUS  | 
          LT  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Serhii  SOBOLIEV  | 
          UA  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          In favour  | 
        
Ms Olena  SOTNYK  | 
          UA  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Ms Maria Edera  SPADONI  | 
          IT  | 
          NR  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Marc  SPAUTZ  | 
          LU  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mme Lorella  STEFANELLI  | 
          SM  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Yanaki  STOILOV  | 
          BG  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Ionu?-Marian  STROE  | 
          RO  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Abstention  | 
        
Ms Petra De SUTTER  | 
          BE  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Damien  THIÉRY  | 
          BE  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Lord John E.  TOMLINSON  | 
          UK  | 
          SOC  | 
          In favour  | 
        
Ms Dana  VÁHALOVÁ  | 
          CZ  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Petrit  VASILI  | 
          AL  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
M. Stefaan  VERCAMER  | 
          BE  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Sergiy  VLASENKO  | 
          UA  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Viktor  VOVK  | 
          UA  | 
          EC  | 
          In favour  | 
        
Ms Nataa  VUCKOVIC  | 
          RS  | 
          SOC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Piotr  WACH  | 
          PL  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          In favour  | 
        
Mr Morten  WOLD  | 
          NO  | 
          EC  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mr Maciej  WYDRZYNSKI  | 
          PL  | 
          ALDE  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mme Marie-Jo  ZIMMERMANN  | 
          FR  | 
          EPP/CD  | 
          Against  | 
        
Mme Naira  ZOHRABYAN  | 
          AM  | 
          EC  | 
          Against  |