| 21/04/2015 | [print] | 
| Members participating in the vote on : | Mass surveillance  (Doc. 13734) Amendment 11 | 
| In favour | 17 | 
| Against | 113 | 
| Abstention | 11 | 
| Mme Meritxell  MATEU | AD | ALDE | Against | 
| Ms Judith  PALLARÉS | AD | ALDE | Against | 
| Ms Valentina  LESKAJ | AL | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Petrit  VASILI | AL | SOC | Against | 
| M. Namik  DOKLE | AL | SOC | Against | 
| Mme Naira  ZOHRABYAN | AM | EC | Against | 
| Mr Stefan  SCHENNACH | AT | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Werner  AMON | AT | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Nikolaus  SCHERAK | AT | ALDE | Against | 
| Ms Alev  KORUN | AT | SOC | Against | 
| M. Damien  THIÉRY | BE | ALDE | Against | 
| Ms Petra De SUTTER | BE | SOC | Against | 
| M. Philippe  MAHOUX | BE | SOC | Against | 
| M. Stefaan  VERCAMER | BE | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Dirk Van der MAELEN | BE | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Yanaki  STOILOV | BG | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Hamid  HAMID | BG | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Alfred  HEER | CH | ALDE | Abstention | 
| Mr Andreas  GROSS | CH | SOC | Against | 
| Mme Elisabeth  SCHNEIDER-SCHNEITER | CH | EPP/CD | Against | 
| M. Luc  RECORDON | CH | SOC | Against | 
| M. André  BUGNON | CH | ALDE | Against | 
| Mme Doris  FIALA | CH | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr George  LOUCAIDES | CY | UEL | Against | 
| Mr Nicos  NICOLAIDES | CY | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Gabriela  PECKOVÁ | CZ | EPP/CD | In favour | 
| Mr Miroslav  NENUTIL | CZ | SOC | Abstention | 
| Mr Pavel  HOLÍK | CZ | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Dana  VÁHALOVÁ | CZ | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Anette  HÜBINGER | DE | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Andrej  HUNKO | DE | UEL | Against | 
| Ms Annette  GROTH | DE | UEL | Against | 
| Ms Doris  BARNETT | DE | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Rait  MARUSTE | EE | ALDE | Abstention | 
| Ms Ana  MATO | ES | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr José Ignacio  PALACIOS | ES | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Ŕlex  SÁEZ | ES | SOC | In favour | 
| Mme Carmen  QUINTANILLA | ES | EPP/CD | In favour | 
| Mr Kimmo  SASI | FI | EPP/CD | In favour | 
| Mr Antti  KAIKKONEN | FI | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Mika  RAATIKAINEN | FI | NR | Against | 
| M. Gérard  BAPT | FR | SOC | Against | 
| M. Jean-Yves  LE DÉAUT | FR | SOC | Against | 
| M. Pierre-Yves  LE BORGN' | FR | SOC | Against | 
| M. Yves  POZZO DI BORGO | FR | EPP/CD | Against | 
| M. Jacques  LEGENDRE | FR | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mme Josette  DURRIEU | FR | SOC | Against | 
| M. Jean-Claude  MIGNON | FR | EPP/CD | Against | 
| M. Bernard  FOURNIER | FR | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mme Maryvonne  BLONDIN | FR | SOC | Against | 
| Mme Maryvonne  BLONDIN | FR | SOC | Against | 
| Mme Marie-Jo  ZIMMERMANN | FR | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Ms Guguli  MAGRADZE | GE | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Zviad  KVATCHANTIRADZE | GE | EC | Against | 
| Mr Igor  KOLMAN | HR | ALDE | Against | 
| Ms Melita  MULIC | HR | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Ingrid  ANTICEVIC MARINOVIC | HR | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Frano  MATUIC | HR | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Gvozden Srecko  FLEGO | HR | SOC | In favour | 
| Mr Gábor  HARANGOZÓ | HU | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Terry  LEYDEN | IE | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Karl  GARĐARSSON | IS | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Ögmundur  JÓNASSON | IS | UEL | Against | 
| Mr Manlio  DI STEFANO | IT | NR | Against | 
| Mr Michele  NICOLETTI | IT | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Ferdinando  AIELLO | IT | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Maria Edera  SPADONI | IT | NR | Against | 
| Mr Francesco Maria  GIRO | IT | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Ms Adele  GAMBARO | IT | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Carlo  LUCHERINI | IT | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Claudio  FAZZONE | IT | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Sergio  DIVINA | IT | NR | In favour | 
| Mr Andrea  RIGONI | IT | ALDE | In favour | 
| Mr Giuseppe  GALATI | IT | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Vannino  CHITI | IT | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Judith  OEHRI | LI | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Gerold  BÜCHEL | LI | ALDE | Abstention | 
| Mr Arturas  SKARDIUS | LT | SOC | Against | 
| M. Gediminas  JAKAVONIS | LT | ALDE | Against | 
| M. Yves  CRUCHTEN | LU | SOC | Against | 
| M. Marcel  OBERWEIS | LU | EPP/CD | Against | 
| M. Marc  SPAUTZ | LU | EPP/CD | Against | 
| M. Andris  BERZIN | LV | ALDE | Against | 
| M. Andrei  NEGUTA | MD | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Valeriu  GHILETCHI | MD | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Igor  CORMAN | MD | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Liliana  PALIHOVICI | MD | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Aleksandar  NIKOLOSKI | MK | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Joseph Beppe  FENECH ADAMI | MT | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Pieter  OMTZIGT | NL | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Hans  FRANKEN | NL | EPP/CD | Abstention | 
| Mr Morten  WOLD | NO | EC | Against | 
| Ms Kristin Řrmen  JOHNSEN | NO | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Hans Fredrik  GRŘVAN | NO | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Ms Ingjerd Schie  SCHOU | NO | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Ms Lise  CHRISTOFFERSEN | NO | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Jagna  MARCZULAJTIS-WALCZAK | PL | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Bogdan  KLICH | PL | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Marek  BOROWSKI | PL | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Piotr  WACH | PL | EPP/CD | In favour | 
| Mr Henryk  CIOCH | PL | EC | Against | 
| Mr Maciej  WYDRZYNSKI | PL | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Killion  MUNYAMA | PL | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Joăo Bosco  MOTA AMARAL | PT | EPP/CD | Abstention | 
| Mme Maria de Belém  ROSEIRA | PT | SOC | Against | 
| M. Carlos Alberto  GONÇALVES | PT | EPP/CD | Against | 
| M. Telmo  CORREIA | PT | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Ben-Oni  ARDELEAN | RO | EPP/CD | In favour | 
| Mr Ionu?-Marian  STROE | RO | EPP/CD | Abstention | 
| Mr Corneliu-Mugurel  COZMANCIUC | RO | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Ms Marija  OBRADOVIC | RS | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Aleksandar  SENIC | RS | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Stefana  MILADINOVIC | RS | SOC | Abstention | 
| Mr arko  OBRADOVIC | RS | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Nataa  VUCKOVIC | RS | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Elvira  KOVÁCS | RS | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Niklas  KARLSSON | SE | SOC | In favour | 
| Ms Carina  OHLSSON | SE | SOC | Against | 
| Ms Tina  GHASEMI | SE | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Ms Lotta  JOHNSSON FORNARVE | SE | UEL | Against | 
| Mr Olof  LAVESSON | SE | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Ms Ksenija  KORENJAK KRAMAR | SI | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Andrej  IRCELJ | SI | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mme Lorella  STEFANELLI | SM | EPP/CD | Against | 
| M. Paride  ANDREOLI | SM | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Saban  DISLI | TR | EPP/CD | In favour | 
| Mme Tülin  ERKAL KARA | TR | EC | In favour | 
| Mr Deniz  BAYKAL | TR | SOC | Against | 
| Mr Nazmi  GÜR | TR | UEL | Against | 
| Mme Gülsün  BILGEHAN | TR | SOC | Abstention | 
| Mr Egemen  BAGIS | TR | EC | Abstention | 
| Mr Ömer  SELVI | TR | EC | Abstention | 
| Ms Olena  SOTNYK | UA | ALDE | Against | 
| Mr Vladyslav  GOLUB | UA | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Boryslav  BEREZA | UA | NR | Against | 
| Mr Sergiy  VLASENKO | UA | EPP/CD | Against | 
| Mr Volodymyr  ARIEV | UA | EPP/CD | In favour | 
| Mr Serhii  SOBOLIEV | UA | EPP/CD | In favour | 
| Mr Viktor  VOVK | UA | EC | In favour | 
| Lord John E.  TOMLINSON | UK | SOC | In favour | 
| Lady Diana  ECCLES | UK | EC | In favour | 
| Mr James  CLAPPISON | UK | EC | Against |