06/10/2011 [print]
Members participating in the vote on : Abuse of state secrecy and national security: obstacles to parliamentary and judicial scrutiny of human rights violations (Doc. 12714)
Amendment  4
In favour 31
Against 74
Abstention 11


Member
Country
Political group
Choice
Mme Meritxell MATEU
AD
ALDE
Against
M. Gerard BARCIA DUEDRA
AD
SOC
Against
Mr Kastriot ISLAMI
AL
SOC
Against
Mr Gagik BAGHDASARYAN
AM
ALDE
Against
Ms Zaruhi POSTANJYAN
AM
EPP/CD
Abstention
Ms Gisela WURM
AT
SOC
Against
Mr Christoph HAGEN
AT
NR
In favour
Mr Dirk Van der MAELEN
BE
SOC
Against
M. Philippe MAHOUX
BE
SOC
Against
Mr Latchezar TOSHEV
BG
EPP/CD
In favour
Mr Andreas GROSS
CH
SOC
Against
M. Theo MAISSEN
CH
EPP/CD
Against
M. Dick MARTY
CH
ALDE
Against
M. André BUGNON
CH
ALDE
Against
Mr Christos POURGOURIDES
CY
EPP/CD
Against
Mr TomᚠÚLEHLA
CZ
EDG
In favour
Ms Jana FISCHEROVÁ
CZ
EDG
Abstention
Mr Ladislav SKOPAL
CZ
SOC
Abstention
Mr Otto CHALOUPKA
CZ
EDG
Abstention
Ms Anette HÜBINGER
DE
EPP/CD
Against
Ms Sylvia CANEL
DE
ALDE
Against
Ms Marieluise BECK
DE
ALDE
Against
Mr Axel FISCHER
DE
EPP/CD
Against
Ms Pernille FRAHM
DK
UEL
Against
Mr Andres HERKEL
EE
EPP/CD
In favour
Mr Paul-Eerik RUMMO
EE
ALDE
In favour
Mr Margus HANSON
EE
ALDE
Against
Mr Alejandro MUŃOZ-ALONSO
ES
EPP/CD
Against
Mr Arcadio DÍAZ TEJERA
ES
SOC
Against
M. Pedro AGRAMUNT
ES
EPP/CD
In favour
Mr Kimmo SASI
FI
EPP/CD
In favour
Ms Anne-Mari VIROLAINEN
FI
EPP/CD
In favour
Ms Susanna HUOVINEN
FI
SOC
Against
Mme Marie-Jo ZIMMERMANN
FR
EPP/CD
Against
Mme Christine MARIN
FR
EPP/CD
Against
M. Jean-Claude MIGNON
FR
EPP/CD
Against
M. Armand JUNG
FR
SOC
Against
M. Alain COUSIN
FR
EPP/CD
Against
M. Rudy SALLES
FR
EPP/CD
Against
Mme Arlette GROSSKOST
FR
EPP/CD
Against
M. René ROUQUET
FR
SOC
Against
M. Frédéric REISS
FR
EPP/CD
Against
Mme Chiora TAKTAKISHVILI
GE
ALDE
In favour
Mr David DARCHIASHVILI
GE
EPP/CD
In favour
Mr Giorgi KANDELAKI
GE
EPP/CD
In favour
Mr Gvozden Srecko FLEGO
HR
SOC
Against
Mr Tamás GAUDI NAGY
HU
NR
Against
Mr Ferenc KALMÁR
HU
EPP/CD
In favour
Ms Giuliana CARLINO
IT
ALDE
In favour
Mr Luca VOLONTČ
IT
EPP/CD
In favour
Mr Paolo GIARETTA
IT
ALDE
Against
Ms Patrizia BUGNANO
IT
ALDE
Against
Mr Giacomo SANTINI
IT
EPP/CD
Abstention
Mr Gebhard NEGELE
LI
EPP/CD
In favour
Ms Renate WOHLWEND
LI
EPP/CD
Against
Mr Egidijus VAREIKIS
LT
EPP/CD
In favour
Mr Emanuelis ZINGERIS
LT
EPP/CD
In favour
Mme Lydie ERR
LU
SOC
Against
Mme Anne BRASSEUR
LU
ALDE
Against
M. Norbert HAUPERT
LU
EPP/CD
Against
Ms Ingrida CIRCENE
LV
EPP/CD
Abstention
Mr Igor CORMAN
MD
SOC
In favour
Ms Liliana PALIHOVICI
MD
EPP/CD
In favour
Mr Valeriu MUNTEANU
MD
ALDE
In favour
Mr Ervin SPAHIC
ME
SOC
Abstention
Mr Francis AGIUS
MT
EPP/CD
Against
Mr Joseph FALZON
MT
EPP/CD
Against
Ms Lise CHRISTOFFERSEN
NO
SOC
Against
Ms Karin ANDERSEN
NO
UEL
Against
Ms Sylvi GRAHAM
NO
EPP/CD
Against
Ms Ingjerd Schie SCHOU
NO
EPP/CD
Against
Ms Anette TRETTEBERGSTUEN
NO
SOC
Against
Mr Carlos COSTA NEVES
PT
EPP/CD
Abstention
Mr Joăo Bosco MOTA AMARAL
PT
EPP/CD
Against
M. Florin IORDACHE
RO
SOC
In favour
Mr Cristian DAVID
RO
ALDE
In favour
Mr Viorel-Riceard BADEA
RO
EPP/CD
In favour
Mr Titus CORLATEAN
RO
SOC
In favour
Ms Maria STAVROSITU
RO
EPP/CD
In favour
Mr Ionu?-Marian STROE
RO
ALDE
In favour
Mr Tudor PANTIRU
RO
SOC
Against
Mr Dmitry VYATKIN
RU
EDG
Against
Mr Valery PARFENOV
RU
EDG
Against
Mr Nikolay FEDOROV
RU
EDG
Against
Mr Viacheslav TIMCHENKO
RU
EDG
Abstention
Mr Valeriy FEDOROV
RU
EDG
Against
Mr Konstantin KOSACHEV
RU
EDG
Against
Ms Carina HÄGG
SE
SOC
Against
Ms Carina OHLSSON
SE
SOC
Against
Mr Björn von SYDOW
SE
SOC
Against
Ms Kerstin LUNDGREN
SE
ALDE
Against
Ms Tina ACKETOFT
SE
ALDE
Against
Ms Darja LAVTIŽAR-BEBLER
SI
SOC
Against
Mr Jakob PRESECNIK
SI
EPP/CD
Against
Mr Pavol KUBOVIC
SK
EPP/CD
In favour
Mr Stanislav FORT
SK
ALDE
Abstention
Ms Nursuna MEMECAN
TR
ALDE
Abstention
Ms Pelin GÜNDES BAKIR
TR
Against
Mr Saban DISLI
TR
EPP/CD
Against
Mr Ahmet Berat ÇONKAR
TR
EDG
Against
Mr Deniz BAYKAL
TR
SOC
In favour
M. Haluk KOÇ
TR
SOC
Against
Mr Yildirim Tugrul TÜRKES
TR
EDG
Against
Mme Gülsün BILGEHAN
TR
SOC
Against
Mr Serhiy HOLOVATY
UA
ALDE
Against
Ms Olena BONDARENKO
UA
EPP/CD
In favour
M. Ivan POPESCU
UA
SOC
In favour
Mr Yevgeniy SUSLOV
UA
EPP/CD
In favour
Mr Mike HANCOCK
UK
ALDE
Against
Sir Christopher CHOPE
UK
EDG
Against
Lord John E. TOMLINSON
UK
SOC
Against
Sir Alan MEALE
UK
SOC
Against
Ms Sandra OSBORNE
UK
SOC
Against
Mr Jim SHERIDAN
UK
SOC
Against
Lord Donald ANDERSON
UK
SOC
Against
Mr Oliver HEALD
UK
EDG
Against