<html>
<head>
<meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=iso-8859-1">
<title>Human Stem Cell Research</title>
<meta name="GENERATOR" content="HTML Transit 7.0 by Stellent (tm), Inc. www.stellent.com">
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="/PortailStyle.css">
</head>
<body bgcolor="#ffffff"><a name="TopOfPage"> </a>
<!-- TRANSIT - INFOBEFORE -->
<table width="100%" border="0" cellpadding="4" cellspacing="0">
  <tr>
    <td><div align="left"><img src="/Documents/LogoText.jpg" width="218" height="48"></div>
    </td>
    <td><div align="right"><img border="0" SRC="/images/logos/Logo130X120.jpg" width="130" height="120"></div>
    </td>
  </tr>
</table>
<hr size="1">

<p align="justify"><b>Doc. 9816 rev.</b></p>

<p align="justify">10 June 2003</p>

<p><b>Human Stem Cell Research</b></p>

<p align="justify">Report </p>

<p align="justify">Committee on Culture, Science and Education</p>

<p align="justify">Rapporteur: Mr Michael ASCIAK, Malta, Group of the European People&#8217;s Party</p>

<p align="justify"><i>Summary</i></p>

<p align="justify">The report reviews development in research on human stem cells and examines related scientific and ethical arguments. While confirming the Assembly&#8217;s previous stands on bioethics issues, the draft resolution encourages research on human stem cells, as it believes that such research can lead to important developments in the treatment of serious diseases.</p>

<p align="justify">The aim of stem cell research is the understanding of the mechanisms of proliferation and differentiation of these cells and their control in order to be able to use them in tissue repair. Controversy surrounds the reliability of embryonic stem cells. Some also oppose the use of embryonic stem cells and the techniques of cloning on ethical grounds.</p>

<p align="justify">Ethical aspects, however, should be given priority over those of a utilitarian and financial nature.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>I.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Draft resolution </b></p>

<p align="justify">1.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Assembly recalls its previous work on bioethics and in particular its Opinions N° 198 (1996) on the draft Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine and N° 202 (1997) on the draft additional Protocol to the Convention on the Prohibition of Cloning Human Beings.</p>

<p align="justify">2.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It considers that stem cell research can lead to important developments in the treatment of several diseases that are now incurable or not effectively curable.</p>

<p align="justify">3.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The technique of human cloning seems to open up new possibilities when combined with stem cells harvested from a human clone, and is therefore very attractive to scientific researchers, even though recent research advances on the growth limitation of embryonic stem cells has been found to render this research route less viable.</p>

<p align="justify">4.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The availability of human stem cells is not limited to embryonic sources alone but may be derived from adult human sources such as blood, bone marrow and other tissues. New techniques for using the pluripotency of tissues are now available from adult stem cell cultures of different origins.</p>

<p align="justify">5.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Assembly also recalls that Article 18 of the Council of Europe Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine explicitly states that &#8220;Where the law allows research on embryos <i>in vitro</i>, it shall ensure adequate protection of the embryo&#8221;. The same Article expressly prohibits the creation of human embryos for research purposes.</p>

<p align="justify">6.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Therefore the Assembly calls on European governments to:</p>

  <ul><p align="justify">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;i. promote human stem cell research of adult provenance, as long as it respects the life of human beings;</p>

    <ul><p align="justify">ii. promote alternative scientific techniques to promote cell pluripotency;</p>

  </ul><p align="justify">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;iii. publicly discuss and optimise national regulations as a basis to sign and ratify the Council of Europe Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine and its Protocol on the Prohibition of Cloning Human Beings if they have not yet done so; </p>

  <p align="justify">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;iv. give priority to the ethical aspects of research over those of a purely utilitarian and financial nature.</p>

</ul><p align="justify"><b>II.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Explanatory memorandum</b></p>

<p align="justify"><b>by Mr Asciak</b></p>

<p align="justify"><b>A. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; General considerations</b></p>

<p align="justify">1.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The use of human stem cells for research purposes has been going on for some time now. It is important to state that there is nothing intrinsically wrong with stem cell research as such. New opportunities in transplanting tissue that is histocompatible and not subject to rejection, is an exiting field, which can lead to substantially reducing much suffering and avoid immuno-suppressive treatment that is currently sustained by patients needing a transplant. In this regard adult stem cell research, which uses pluripotent stem cells (immature cells which are capable of transformation into any specific cells of the body under the right chemical and physical conditions of growth) which are derived from adult human sources of so called haemopoetic tissue (bone marrow, spleen, lymph nodes &#8211; tissue which produces blood cells) and blood itself, does not offer any ethical difficulties. Research in this area is developing at a fast pace.</p>

<p align="justify">2.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The ethical problems with stem cell research are reserved for so-called embryonic stem cell research. There are sources of stem cells that are available from cord blood (collected from a cut umbilical cord just after delivery) which do not present any problems. The problem arises, because stem cells are also available as tissue found in the embryo in the first few days of development. Certain researchers are harvesting stem cells by the destruction of the human embryo. In fact, these cells may only be obtained by the destruction of the embryo itself. Some justify this as a necessary price to pay for research to proceed, others argue that spare embryos left over from &#8216;in vitro&#8217;, fertilization would die anyway, so it would be better to get some positive benefit out of them, before they become worthless. Whichever way one looks at this, two facts are indisputable. The first is, that human life is being used for research purposes and destroyed in the process. The second is, that human beings are being commodified on an increased scale and being rendered an object of financial and economic gain, the demand will increase the supply!</p>

<p align="justify">3.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The ethical problems associated with the destruction of human embryos, are not the only ones. Some countries had started the procedure of cloning human embryos first, so that iso-immune cells can be obtained which can be used in transplantation. That is an individual&#8217;s cells are first cloned by nuclear transfer (transferring the cell nucleus as happens in reproductive cloning), and the resulting embryo is then destroyed to obtain cells that are histo-compatible with the cells of the donor, thereby obtaining good tissue for transplantation. Here the ethical and legal problems mentioned in the 1<sup>st</sup> Protocol on Human Cloning of the Bioethics Convention of the Council of Europe are still inherent. That is, there is a breach of the principles of Liberty, Individuality and Equality mentioned in the European Convention of Human Rights of the same Council of Europe. Reproductive and therapeutic cloning both breach these principles, and the Bioethics Convention considers both in the same light, without even referring to the word cloning, but to the voluntary reproduction of an individual with the same genetic material.</p>

<p align="justify">4.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Recent scientific evidence shows that there is some difficulty in using stem cells from human therapeutic clones, as there is no limitation in tissue growth in these types of organs for transplantation, obtained from embryonic stem cells. There does not seem to be a problem with organs obtained from adult stem cells. Nonetheless, this may be a temporary technical setback which may be resolved in the near future and which does not alter the ethical, legal and philosophical safeguards that need to be put in place.</p>

<p align="justify">5.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Other ethical problems that are encountered in human stem cell research are surely those of patenting and ownership. Do the harvested cells belong to the donors or to the researchers? Should they be patented at all? What about the rights of the sacrificed embryo, which is the human being from which the cells originally emanated? These considerations require profound and deep analysis.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>B.</b> <b>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Status of the Human Embryo</b></p>

<p align="justify"><i>Let storm clouds come: better an hour, and leave to weep and fight, </i></p>

<p align="justify"><i>than all the ages I have ruled the empires of the night.</i></p>

<p align="justify"><i>I think that if they gave me leave within the world to stand,</i></p>

<p align="justify"><i>I would be good through all the day I spent in fairyland</i><sup><a href="#P74_7465" name="P74_7466">1</a></sup><i>.</i></p>

<p align="justify"><i>G. K. Chesterton</i></p>

<p align="justify"><i><b>Issues</b></i></p>

<p align="justify">6.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Objectively speaking, the contention here is clear cut, for if one had to consider the human personality as existing from the moment of conception, then certain positions would become consequential, while if this hypothesis is not acceptable, then obviously, different conclusions become logically evident with the added problem of determining the exact point in time when this actually occurs.</p>

<p align="justify"> </p>

<p align="justify">7.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Legally, up to this time, the definition of the exact moment when the human embryo assumes personality and dignity because of its being, not its potential to be, has been left to each country&#8217;s different religious, legal and expedient perspectives, although expediency is not often quoted <i>per se,</i> but painted in the livery of some other perceived rights, such as the <u>right to enjoy a good quality of life</u>. In fact, the Oviedo Convention explicitly avoids this issue in attempting to reach a consensual compromise, stressing only certain baseline principles on which the majority have agreed, and leaving this issue to the different countries in the Council of Europe. This is further compounded by the fact, that even on the religious scene, differences abound, and they are rife even between different Christian denominations, and within the same denomination.</p>

<p align="justify">8.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; From the standpoint of international law, the only accepted position is that no medical act may be performed without the patients&#8217; freely given and informed consent. There is the same outlook from the ethical standpoint, where the WMA established in Lisbon in 1981, that an abortion could in no way be performed without the mother&#8217;s consent<sup><a href="#P84_9183" name="P84_9184">2</a></sup>. </p>

<p align="justify">9.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Objectively, there are several reasons why one should consider the embryo as a human person from the moment of conception, and no reasons scientifically why one should not<sup><a href="#P87_9556" name="P87_9557">3</a></sup>. From the moment of conception, the two haploid gametes, male and female, unite to form a <u>unique</u> diploid set of chromosomes, under which the process of development and growth is initiated under the control of the said aforementioned genes. This process is continuous, with no separate phase, evident from the rest, but occurs as one contiguous growth process, much like the process of growth from after birth, till natural death. This process also occurs independent of the mother, as has been so obviously proven by the processes of <i>in vitro </i>fertilization, where once gamete nuclei union occurs in favourable environmental circumstances, then embryo division and growth occurs spontaneously and under the control of the genes in the same embryo<sup><a href="#P88_10478" name="P88_10479">4</a></sup>. Current scientific knowledge is thus sufficient to lead one to conclude that the human embryo has a distinct ontological personality from its very beginning. </p>

<p align="justify"><b><i>The Concept of Ontological Development </i></b></p>

<p align="justify">10.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Occasionally the position is clouded by declarations by writers such as Norman Ford, an Australian Catholic theologian, who by using the correct philosophical arguments down through from Aristotle and St. Thomas Aquinas to the present day, unfortunately comes to the incorrect conclusion, due to the lack of understanding or knowledge at the time of writing, of certain scientific facts in the fields of genetic and molecular biology, embryology and cell histology. In his book<sup><a href="#P93_11309" name="P93_11310">5</a></sup>, Ford correctly states, <i>&#8220;a person is a living individual with a truly human nature&#8221;</i>. He then goes on to explain that a born infant, although not able to reason, is already a person because its very nature allows it to develop to the age of reason, without loosing its ontological identity. </p>

<p align="justify">11.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The concept of ontological identity is central to the understanding of personhood, because once ontological continuity is proven in the developing foetus, then the point at which this ontological development commences, is the point of the commencement of personhood. Since the Catholic Church in the Council of Vienna from 1311-1312, ruled out any dualism between the body and the soul in human nature, that is, there is no pre-existence of the soul before the body, both constitute one human being, with the soul being the life-principle of the body. This Council did not however specify at what point of human development, this union of soul with body occurred. The point of commencement of personhood must therefore also be the point of ensoulment of the human body! Ontological continuity can be defined as the development of the body in a coordinated, continuous manner, lending that particular body singular individuality. </p>

<p align="justify">12.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The concept of the continuum of the human person described by Ford, in fact overcomes the hurdle of several philosophical problems concerned with human personhood. What is a human person? Most of us know the answer to this question by relying on our daily experience and perceptions of meeting other rational human people, who can communicate with us and express their rationality, but we have difficulty in defining it. Does the faculty of conscious reasoning (consciousness)<sup><a href="#P98_13093" name="P98_13094">6</a></sup> and the capacity to value one&#8217;s own existence<sup><a href="#P99_13581" name="P99_13582">7</a></sup>, which imparts to man his singular position amongst all creatures, have to be constantly present during man&#8217;s existence, for him to be considered a person? The answer Ford gives, is in the negative. There may be times, such as in early childhood or close to late adulthood, where this function cannot be expressed. Either because the communicative faculties have not yet been developed or have been lost, or because the function itself has not yet developed or has been lost. Therefore, are young children or newborn babies or senile adults any less human than mature and rational individuals, who have developed this rationality and are in a position to express it? The answer is obviously no. Babies and senile adults are fully human. What connects the rational individual to the non-rational stages of his existence is his ontological development or developmental continuum. The individual, who was a baby and then grew into a mature adult and became degenerately senile, is the same human individual passing through different stages of the same personhood. Therefore human personhood must be accepted to be present in a particular individual, through all stages of human development, as long as there is proof that the development of the particular individual is deemed to be physically connected and unique to that person. </p>

<p align="justify">13.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Therefore if the ontological development of the person may be traced down to embryological development, the first basic living cellular component giving rise to the continuous and connected development of the same human person, must be the point where human personhood begins. This philosophical reasoning is correct. In his book however, Ford erroneously concludes, that since in the <u>first fourteen days</u> of development up to implantation, there is no unifying physical and physiological connection between the different cells of the blastula and the morula, the human individual may not be present from the moment of conception. He cites as proof the fact, that the blastocyst layer, with differentiation within the embryo into embryoblastic cells proper, that eventually produce the actual foetus, undergoes separate development from the trophoblastic cells which eventually produce the membranes and placenta. </p>

<p align="justify">14.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The human person would rather occur actually, from the moment of formation of the primitive streak on the embryonic plate around the fourteenth day after fertilization, around the time of implantation into the walls of the uterus. This is the stage when the third layer of the embryo responsible for the development of the internal human musculature, called the mesodermal layer, is laid down together with the previously formed ectoderm and the endoderm layers. This is the stage, Ford concludes, that the human body plan is complete in its three layers and axis orientation, and therefore this must be the point of commencement of ontological development and therefore as a result of the commencement of personhood, the point of ensoulment. After this stage, there could no longer be the formation of genetically identical twins, and therefore this supports the fact, that that was the moment of ensoulment and &#8216;humanization&#8217;. That this statement is simply untrue can be attested by the detailed evaluation of cell histology and the processes of early embryology, which particulars, to be fair, may not have been available to Ford at the time.</p>

<p align="justify"><b><i>Conception as the Earliest Moment of Ontological Continuity</i></b></p>

<p align="justify"><i> </i></p>

<p align="justify">15.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; I would like to briefly mention some scientific facts that bring down Ford&#8217;s hypothesis. Recent elementary cell histology<sup><a href="#P108_17343" name="P108_17344">8</a></sup> shows without doubt, that cells close to each other, such as those found in the early blastomere surrounded by the <i>Zona Pellucida</i>, are not developing in splendid isolation, but continually exchange information which limits or controls each other&#8217;s growth extent and pattern. On close study of the complex cell plasma membrane, which is a semi-permeable membrane, and already by its very nature allows the passive selective diffusion of water molecules and certain simple fat soluble (hydrophobic or lipophilic) signalling molecules in and out of cells, one can observe several mechanisms by which other molecules or ions, such as mineral ions and simple proteins or lipoproteins (usually hydrophilic or lipophobic), may actively pass into the cell through the membrane. Simple ions such as those of Sodium, Potassium and Calcium are actively transported through cell membranes using an active pump mechanism. </p>

<p align="justify">16.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Mass transport of larger molecules into the cell occurs in a process called endocytosis, while transport of molecules out of the cell through the cell membrane, is correspondingly called exocytosis. There are several forms how this can take place. The first form is called pinocytosis, whereby relatively large amounts of extracellular fluid and all the molecules in solution in it, are entrapped by invaginations of the cell membrane, transported into the cell, and then released inside the cell matrix. The second mechanism is receptor mediated endocytosis, where receptors on the surface of cell membranes specific for several lipoproteins and proteins, bind to the latter selectively, and are then invaginated into the cell and finally pinch off inside the cell membrane into the cell matrix. It is important to realize that several simple proteins are the constituents of hormones, which control cell function and growth. The third type of endocytosis is called phagocytosis, where the extracellular solid material is literally engulfed by cellular extrusions of the cytoplasm and cell membrane, and brought <i>in toto,</i> into the cell matrix. </p>

<p align="justify">17.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Not all cells may exhibit the three forms of endocytosis at any one time. Through the second mechanism alone, cells can communicate by secreting chemicals such as hormones or other transmitters, that signal to cells some distance away, or they may contain plasma-bound signalling protein molecules, which communicate with other interlocking plasma-bound membrane molecules of neighbour cells in direct physical contact. These signalling molecules, then activate messenger (G-Proteins) molecules, which diffuse throughout the cell matrix and set off enzyme cascades that bring about a particular cellular response and behaviour, thereby regulating important cell functions. Lipid soluble hormones called steroids, are also able to diffuse from extracellular fluid across the cell membrane and cause a cellular response through binding to specific DNA sequences causing transcription<sup><a href="#P113_20404" name="P113_20405">9</a></sup> enhancement or delay.</p>

<p align="justify">18.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Another way that adjacent cells may communicate with each other is through the establishment of small open communicating junctions between them. These gap junctions or connexons, allow the exchange of informational substances directly through them, which then regulate the tissue development in a coordinated manner. It is proven that even where protein synthesis is not yet operational, these connexons may form from the existing protein subunits in the existing cell membrane! Connexons have been demonstrated to form in the human embryo around the <u>fourth day of development</u> when the morula consists of about thirty cells. Together with the formation of gap junctions, one also finds tight junctions, which principally contribute to the anchoring of the cells to one another<sup><a href="#P116_21485" name="P116_21486">10</a></sup>. </p>

<p align="justify">19.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; As one can easily tell from the above synopsis, the human cell contains a substantial number of mechanisms by which it can communicate with neighbouring cells, and therefore it is difficult to imagine that there is no communication in the embryo, even at the two cell stage, and that cells are not already developing as an ontological unit, as Ford ascertained! It is practically impossible for cells to be so closely bound next to each other within the <i>Zona Pellucida</i>, and not be sharing developmental information. There is however another reason that also compromises Ford&#8217;s hypothesis and that is the activated functioning of the cell genome from the moment of conception.</p>

<p align="justify">20. Once fertilization has taken place, and a new set of chromosomes has been formed by the single strands from the mother and the father, the new and unique genome immediately starts to control the growth and development, not only of the particular individual blastomeres, but also of the neighbouring ones. This control of cell growth is carried out by the genetic information encoded within the 23 pairs of chromosomes themselves. Genes called operons<sup><a href="#P121_22703" name="P121_22704">11</a></sup>, decide which characteristics are translated by the RNA (ribonucleic acid responsible for the reading and transfer of the DNA code into protein synthesis) into the building block or messenger proteins. Control by these operons may be positive, that is they stimulate protein synthesis, or negative, that is they inhibit it.</p>

<p align="justify">21.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; A regulator gene, codes for a regulator protein that activates or deactivates protein synthesis by binding to a particular site on the gene, thereby deciding which are the segments of DNA expressed in protein synthesis and cell development. These regulator genes, which can be further subdivided as to exact function (coordinate, selector and realizator)<sup><a href="#P124_23459" name="P124_23460">12</a></sup>, do not only regulate what occurs within their own particular cell. Due to the production of morphogenetic proteins or morphogens<sup><a href="#P125_23761" name="P125_23762">13</a></sup>, which are released by the cell into the extracellular spaces, they also regulate the growth and development of neighbouring cells, depending on the relative concentrations of these proteins eliciting a set of unique cellular responses, which are different from one another, according to the different cascading concentrations<sup><a href="#P126_24249" name="P126_24250">14</a></sup>. Axial orientation as well as embryo segmentation and tissue differentiation is mediated by these genes. </p>

<p align="justify">22.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Induction<sup><a href="#P129_24386" name="P129_24387">15</a></sup> is the process, whereby one cell population influences the development of neighbouring cells. Now it has been proven that inducing signals are either tethered to the cell membrane surface thereby affecting only neighbouring cells, or else can diffuse in the extra cellular matrix by morphogens, and act at a distance. Therefore, the control of cell development can occur by the diffusion of morphogens to other cells in the vicinity, such as in the early stages of embryo development, and also by direct cell-to-cell contact of the cell membranes (this last type of control is exemplified by the development of neural tissue in the embryo). This last type of cell-cell mediated induction has also been shown to be active in the early embryo. </p>

<p align="justify">23.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; At the stage of pre-implantation, it has been shown that a cell-cell adhesion is mediated by cell-surface adhesive protein molecules called cadherins<sup><a href="#P132_25300" name="P132_25301">16</a></sup>. There are several types of cadherins responsible for cell adhesion at different stages of embryological development and in the adult organism (E, P, N, R, M), but at this particular stage of the morula, the major cell-surface adhesive protein expressed is called E-cadherin. This E-cadherin is responsible for the cells to adhere into a tight mass, and has been proven in vertebrates to influence tissue morphogenesis and cell differentiation. At a later stage, around fourteen days, some ectoderm cells lose their E-cadherin, allowing them to migrate inwards and form the mesoderm. Ectoderm cells also lose E-cadherin during formation of the neural tube, and start producing another cadherin called N-cadherin, which controls nervous tissue development. This process continues unabated, allowing like-cells to develop together, by having the same cadherin and new cells groups to form by the production of different cadherins. The cadherin adhesive proteins, it is important to remember, are produced by protein synthesis mediated by the nuclear DNA in each cell.</p>

<p align="justify">24.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; New evidence also suggests that the differentiation and developmental growth of different cells in the developing embryo, depends to a significant extent, on the interactions with the <i>Basal Lamina</i>, which is a non-cellular amorphous matrix made up of mucopolysaccharides (carbohydrates) and collagen protein<sup><a href="#P135_26699" name="P135_26700">17</a></sup>. This basal lamina underlines all epithelial and endothelial tissues, and separates these from other types of tissue. Now the <i>Zona Pellucida</i> surrounding the ovum and early embryo, is very similar in chemical composition, to the basal lamina, and is made up of a combination of protein and polysaccharides (mucoprotein) and elaborated by the ovum and follicular cells of the ovarian follicle. One may be led to conclude, that the <i>Zona Pellucida</i>, should contribute in a similar manner, to the ontological development of the blastomeres it encloses, at the early stage of embryonic development, as do the basal <i>laminae</i> during the later stages.</p>

<p align="justify">25.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Therefore it is very clear, that far from Ford&#8217;s erratic reasoning, the cells next to each other, not only can communicate with one another, but the substances with which they do so, which regulate the ontological development of the foetus, have been identified and lie under the absolute control of the new genome produced at the moment of fertilization. It also seems that factors outside the cells may contribute to this integrated development. A concluding remark in a recent publication<sup><a href="#P138_27999" name="P138_28000">18</a></sup>, says it all; <i>&#8220;In the intact developing organism, each cell must be listening to its neighbours and hence in all likelihood is detecting multiple signals, often simultaneously, and integrating them&#8221;.</i></p>

<p align="justify">26.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It follows therefore, that ontological development of the human embryo must start from conception, that the human embryo is a human person from the moment of conception and therefore, for those who believe that a person is endowed with a spiritual soul, the human embryo from the moment of conception must be endowed with such a spiritual soul! Ford&#8217;s effort to detach ontological continuity from the moment of conception is also proven untrue from the particular development of monozygotic (identical) twins. Ford<i> </i>stated that monozygotic twins proved that there was no ontological development in the just fertilized zygote, as two individuals came to be developed from one fertilized ovum, and if it was possible for one being to give rise to two individual beings, then philosophically, there could be no ontological continuity between the original fertilized zygote and the two new genetically identical embryos. Philosophically, this position could be contested by the argument, that it may not have been that the original zygote gave rise to two new embryos, but that the original zygote continued ontological development at an early stage of which, a new and separate physical separation occurred in the dividing cells, giving rise to a new individual with the same nuclear gene set, but a different independent, ontological development<sup><a href="#P141_29568" name="P141_29569">19</a></sup>. </p>

<p align="justify">27.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The scientific proof for this was forthcoming, when monozygotic twins where discovered to be composed of a twin with a karyotype of forty-seven (47) chromosomes and therefore affected by <i>Down&#8217;s syndrome</i>, while the other twin had a karyotype of forty-six (46) chromosomes, and was therefore normal. In these cases, a number of studies showed, that the trisomic twin was the original zygote, while the second normal embryo originated from it<sup><a href="#P144_30265" name="P144_30266">20</a></sup>!</p>

<p align="justify"><b><i>Inferential Argumentation from Evolutionary Theory</i></b></p>

<p align="justify">28.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Although there is neither the space here nor the scope to expound evolutionary theory and anthropology, it is a proven scientific fact that man is descended from the same cosmic dust as the rest of the universe many billions of years ago following the Big Bang. Five billion years ago our galaxy and sun were born. Four billion years ago followed the earth in its mineral form. 180 million years ago, the Earth had a fully developed biosphere. Two million years ago, all the flora and fauna we now know had taken shape. By forty thousand years ago, <i>Homo Sapiens</i> was roaming the face of the Earth. There is indisputable evidence that the mineral substances of the Earth had coalesced into the basic amino acids constituting the building blocks of proteins (Miller&#8217;s experiments) and that the early bacteria and viruses slowly evolved into first the simple then the more compound flora and conscious fauna constituting the higher creatures. Ultimately the appearance of man crowned this evolutionary step by the development of self-conscious man. The genetic material appearing in man is the same substance that makes up all living creatures on Earth. The relational character of reality shows that there is a continuity and kinship between man and the whole of creation. It is right here to give much credit to Teilhard de Chardin who was the first to be acutely aware of this relationship and who first expounded the theory of the evolution of consciousness with its <i>coup de grâce</i> being man. It was Teilhard who first put forward the idea of the Immanence of God in such a creation. A God who is ever present within but greater than creation itself. A panentheistic God whose spirit moves and vivifies the whole of creation including man himself. It is in this manner that the consciousness of man and every other creature can be considered as its soul. The Pauline and Johannine scriptural traditions as well as the Hebrew Scriptures bear out references to this view of creation. Every element of creation, physical, mineral and living bears out the abundant goodness and grace of God. As Aquinas writes: <i>For God brought things into being in order that his goodness might be communicated to creatures and be represented through them. And, because his goodness could not be adequately represented by one creature alone, he produced many and diverse creatures, that what was wanting to one in the representation of divine goodness, might be supplied by another. For goodness, which in God is simple and uniform, in creatures is manifold and divided. Hence, the universe as a whole participates in and represents divine goodness, more perfectly than any single creature alone.</i></p>

<p align="justify">29.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; According to this view of creation and the constitution of the universe, the dignity and sanctity of the human being is passed on within the non-dualistic union of spirit (consciousness) and physical body, from generation to generation by the simple physical existence of man himself. According to this model, the moment that man comes into physical existence from the very beginning, at conception, demarcates man&#8217;s transcendence and therefore his indisputable personhood.</p>

<p align="justify">30.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; For the secular agnostic, the ontological continuity of the purely physical process, a process that is proven scientifically, should be enough to convince of the personhood and respect due to man during the whole life cycle, from beginning to end. </p>

<p align="justify"> <i> </i></p>

<p align="justify"><i><b>The Definition of Conception </b></i></p>

<p align="justify">31.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It is pertinent to end this section, by referring to another ethical dilemma. The moment of conception may be invariably defined as the moment when the cytoplasmic membrane of the two gametes fuse, at the beginning of the fertilization process. Alternatively, it may also be taken to be the moment, when the haploid genetic material in the male and female pronuclei, comes together on the mitotic spindle, to form a new diploid zygote, with a new genetic constitution, that is at the end of fertilization<sup><a href="#P157_34408" name="P157_34409">21</a></sup> (17-24 hours). Some argue that the ontological development of the embryo, can be followed from the point of the nuclear arrangement on the spindle just before the first mitotic division of the zygote, where protein synthesis, under the control of the new genome, can be detected in the two-cell stage in the mouse, and the four-cell stage in the human zygote<sup><a href="#P158_34867" name="P158_34868">22</a></sup>. After the sperm cell unites with the cytoplasmic membrane of the oocyte, two to three hours must pass, before there is extrusion of the second polar body in the second meiotic division of the oocyte<sup><a href="#P159_35181" name="P159_35182">23</a></sup>. Now all the products of meiosis, produce four haploid nuclei, all with different genetic material. Therefore, at the point of gamete fusion, the ootid nucleus is not yet genetically defined<sup><a href="#P160_35479" name="P160_35480">24</a></sup>. The two pronuclei formed, do not actually fuse, but the nuclear membrane disappears, and the chromosomes arrange themselves on the newly formed spindle in preparation for the first mitotic cleavage division of the new zygote<sup><a href="#P161_35810" name="P161_35811">25</a></sup>. This is the first time that the maternal and paternal chromosomes come together. Before completion of this phase of mitosis (metaphase), the genetic material in the pronuclei, may be subject to various factors, which may ultimately produce viable zygotes with, triploidy or tetraploidy, or even subject to trisomy or monosomy<sup><a href="#P162_36350" name="P162_36351">26</a></sup>. That is, the genetic composition of the new zygote can be taken, to not yet be complete before this stage.</p>

<p align="justify">32.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; However, the other argument concluding that the human individual is present from gamete fusion at the beginning of the process of fertilization also bears significant weight, but one must explain ontological continuity down to that level. Several people maintain this to be so<sup><a href="#P165_36830" name="P165_36831">27</a></sup>, as the two pronuclei are taken to be the two haploid nuclei of the same single cell. Bi-nuclear cells are not a rarity in nature, and some animal species such as Cyclops and several fungal species, spend a very long part of their life, in this haploid bi-nuclear state<sup><a href="#P166_37260" name="P166_37261">28</a></sup>. Could this phase be represented also in man at the beginning of fertilization, as an evolutionary remnant? If so, this would explain why there is no prophase in a one-cell zygote, but only spindle formation during metaphase leading directly to the combined (2N) genome in the two-cell stage. Several new proteins have also been identified in the one-cell stage although these could be translated from maternal m-RNA<sup><a href="#P167_37780" name="P167_37781">29</a></sup>. However, there has recently been very strong evidence that the mammalian embryo is transcriptionally active and produces its own m-RNA, even from the one-cell stage, and not from the two-cell stage as previously thought<sup><a href="#P168_38110" name="P168_38111">30</a></sup>. It is significant that the level of transcription is modest (about one-fifth less) at this stage compared to the two-cell rate. Since it seems that the maternal and especially the paternal pronuclei, can be proven to be transcriptionally active from this stage, this logically leads one to conclude that the ontological development of the human embryo, can in fact be traced down to the level of the one-cell stage and ultimately, gamete fusion! In fact, occasionally, only one pronucleus is produced, and there is now evidence that suggests, that this pronucleus is diploid. In the meantime, until things become clearer, in devising scientific action, one should morally err on the side of caution, and assume the last hypothesis to be so, unless proven otherwise!   </p>

<p align="justify"><b><i>Moral Perspectives</i>  </b></p>

<p align="justify">33.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The confusing position of the several Christian churches, tends to compound rather than help the objectivity of politicians trying to reach enlightened conclusions, and seems to confute St. Augustine&#8217;s advice that &#8220;we believe in order to understand, and we understand in order to believe&#8221;. </p>

<p align="justify"><b><i>The Catholic Church </i></b></p>

<p align="justify">34.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Catholic Church&#8217;s position is clear and unambiguous. The human being must be respected and accorded full personality status from the moment of conception. This position has been repeatedly emphasized in respect of the human embryo<sup><a href="#P177_40094" name="P177_40095">31</a></sup> particularly in scientific research<sup><a href="#P178_40288" name="P178_40289">32</a></sup>, medical interventions, especially those regarding fertilization procedures<sup><a href="#P179_40601" name="P179_40602">33</a></sup>, and also with respect to abortion<sup><a href="#P180_40975" name="P180_40976">34</a></sup>. The Catholic Church maintains this position even in order to prevent selection on eugenic grounds<sup><a href="#P181_41682" name="P181_41683">35</a></sup>. It is interesting to understand, that the position the Roman Church has today, has in fact evolved over a period of time. Although this Church, from its very beginning, has always defended the <u>ensouled</u> embryo as a person<sup><a href="#P182_41976" name="P182_41977">36</a></sup>, in the past, there were some queries as to when this exact moment of ensoulment occurred during foetal growth, queries which even today are sometimes raised, as in the case with Norman Ford. The magisterum of the Church has taken a firm stand on the issue, dispelling any moral doubts<sup><a href="#P183_42464" name="P183_42465">37</a></sup>, particularly by <i>Donum Vitae</i>, which is clear on the issue of personhood and on the issue of foetal experimentation<sup><a href="#P184_44759" name="P184_44760">38</a></sup>.</p>

<p align="justify">35.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In <i>Donum Vitae</i> and the other documents of the period, from the Second Vatican Council onwards, the Catholic Church was ascertaining that even if there was still some doubt on the issue, without pretending to be an expert in scientific affairs, it was ready to give the human embryo the benefit of the doubt, and was convinced that since the genetic and biological beginnings of the human being, began at fertilization, this was sufficient for it to extrapolate the argument to the human person, that is body and soul present at fertilization.</p>

<p align="justify"><b><i>Other Christian Churches </i></b></p>

<p align="justify">36.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The situation in the other churches is rather confounding. The World Council of Churches (WCC) admits, that given the complexity of the argument, it is not to be expected that all the members in one particular church or separate different churches, could in fact arrive at the same moral decision on this issue<sup><a href="#P191_45999" name="P191_46000">39</a></sup>. In the Lutheran tradition, there are different opinions of when human beings become personalized, and doubts are expressed as to the absolute value of their dignity, bringing in the concept of comparison to the rights of the mother and the rights of the quality of life of the born child itself <sup><a href="#P192_46536" name="P192_46537">40</a></sup>. The difference of opinion in the different Protestant Christian churches was amplified during a discussion on human cloning, where a Lutheran theologian commented: <i>Nor do I suppose that I can represent Protestants generally. There is no such body. Indeed, Protestants are specialists in the art of fragmentation. In my own tradition which is Lutheran, we commonly understand ourselves as quite content to be Catholic except that when on certain questions we have been compelled to disagree. </i>This was corroborated during the same discussion, by another probably Calvinist Protestant theologian who stated: <i>I cannot say that a conceived egg, a fertilized egg is exactly the same as a born human being. I do not think anybody entirely says that. We do end ectopic pregnancies...</i><sup><a href="#P193_48333" name="P193_48334">41</a></sup><i>. </i>This is actually a false argument, as in ectopic pregnancies, there is an absolute threat to the life of the mother, which would ultimately end the life of the foetus itself, and the intervention here is considered as an indirect form of abortion, as the removal of the embryo is not the primary requisite.</p>

<p align="justify">37.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In their book &#8220;Is the Foetus Human?&#8221;, Eric Pastuszek and Robert B. French<sup><a href="#P196_48896" name="P196_48897">42</a></sup>, give an overview of the main church positions on abortion in North America, and reach certain interesting conclusions regarding position shifts over a ten-year period. In the different Protestant Churches, there is a mixed reaction, but by no means should it be understood that an anti-abortion position is solely a Catholic issue, as evidence suggests that the position of several Protestant denominations is equally manifest. This starting from the time of Roe Vs Wade up to the present day. Also some liberal Protestants shifted from a liberal pro-abortion view, to a moderate or conservative position during the 1980&#8217;s. They also stated that there is a recent shift where &#8220;major Protestant denominations had modified their pro-choice or pro-abortion position or, in some cases, reversed it&#8221;. In addition, as a whole, liberal Protestant churches, while struggling to maintain the right to abortion, also recognize that abortion denies the right to life of another individual. They also go on to state the position of the Eastern Orthodox Church, which maintains that abortion is murder, and the fact that Orthodox <u>Jewish </u>beliefs are the most long-standing beliefs in regard to the sanctity of life in the womb. On the other hand, Conservative Jews, allow abortion for certain economic, physical, emotional and social considerations. In alluding to the Catholic Church&#8217;s perennial opposition to abortion, they end the particular chapter, by quoting Mother Theresa of Calcutta: </p>

<p align="justify"><i>&#8220;The greatest destroyer of peace today is the cry of the innocent, unborn child. For if a mother can murder her own child in her own womb, what is left but for you and me to kill each other?</i></p>

<p align="justify">38.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Another interesting insight into the moral position regarding the personhood of the embryo, is given by Patrick J. O&#8217;Mahony in his book, A Question of Life - Its Beginning and Transmission<sup><a href="#P200_50841" name="P200_50842">43</a></sup>, where he gauges the reaction to the Warnock Committee&#8217;s suggestion that embryo experimentation (from IVF), in the UK, should be allowed up to the fourteenth day after fertilization, but the embryo which has been used for research should not be transferred to a woman. In the words of Mary Warnock herself<sup><a href="#P201_51181" name="P201_51182">44</a></sup>, this report struck up a balance between the protection of the human embryo and the need for scientific research particularly for medical purposes, where the embryo could be damaged or destroyed in the process. What was emphasized here was that the embryo was not to be protected in an absolute manner with absolute human rights but only with relative rights. The Jewish reaction to the Warnock Report was mixed<sup><a href="#P202_52107" name="P202_52108">45</a></sup>, and declared that the issue was complex and undefined, leading to differing opinions. The Board for Social Responsibility of the Church of England supported by a majority the recommendation that research under licence be permitted on embryos up to fourteen days old<sup><a href="#P203_52392" name="P203_52393">46</a></sup>. The General Synod of the church however disagreed with both the report and the board&#8217;s suggestion and voted against this by 151 to 128 votes, only to again overturn this decision five months later<sup><a href="#P204_52610" name="P204_52611">47</a></sup>. The Church of England was definitely divided on the matter reflecting the reality in the British Isles. Cardinal Hume on the other hand, explicitly stated that he could not accept the fourteen-day proposal because a new life came into existence from the moment of conception, starting a process of continuous growth<sup><a href="#P205_52949" name="P205_52950">48</a></sup>. </p>

<p align="justify">39.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Catholic Bishops&#8217; Conference of England and Wales, decreed in a statement amongst several points, that the human embryo had to be treated as a human person with the potential of development. They strongly condemned from the moral and factual point of view, the report&#8217;s allowance of destructive experimentation during the first fourteen days after conception, and that the embryos used for this type of research should be destroyed after the elapse of this period<sup><a href="#P208_53443" name="P208_53444">49</a></sup>. The Methodist Church was divided in its response, but the majority supported the fact that some research on human in vitro embryos should be permitted under licence<sup><a href="#P209_53631" name="P209_53632">50</a></sup>. The Board for Social Responsibility of the Church of Scotland, contrarily declared, that the human embryo was a human being from the first moment of fertilization, and it had the right to be protected and treated as such. However, it then goes on to make the curious statement, that these very same embryos, should be destroyed if the couples indicate that they have no wish for additional children, if there was no agreement among the couple for their use, or when the marriage relationship ends for any particular reason<sup><a href="#P210_54173" name="P210_54174">51</a></sup>. The Baptist Church, refers to the principle of the lesser of two evils, and applies this principle to the life of the embryo, that is it could be allowed to die in circumstances, which would not be acceptable for one to accept in the case of an ordinary person, but because it was a &#8220;potential person&#8221;, one had to allow it to die with a &#8220;sense of tragedy&#8221;<sup><a href="#P211_54560" name="P211_54561">52</a></sup>! This author reaches a different conclusion than the previous ones on the moral shift regarding the practice of abortion in the different churches in the West. At the beginning of the century they were all aligned with that of the Catholic Church, whilst today in the Church of England and other Churches, the official response towards abortion legislation has become more liberalized<sup><a href="#P212_54963" name="P212_54964">53</a></sup>. </p>

<p align="justify"><b><i>Other Religions </i></b></p>

<p align="justify">40.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; This section has proven without doubt how difficult it is to deal with this issue in any globally (or even regionally for that matter) coherent manner. The main Christian religions differ amongst themselves substantially on the status of the human embryo, even contradicting them over a different period. As mentioned before, the Jewish (Orthodox) position considers abortion as a fundamental absurdity. It is a prohibited act and its refusal morally justified. Muslims only consider the embryo as becoming human on the <u>hundredth day</u> of gestation and therefore deliberate termination of pregnancy may be morally acceptable in certain situations, such as where a foetus exhibits an anomaly. On the other hand, the <i>Buddhist </i>position declares, that the embryo is sacred, and that it possesses all the potentiality of a human being, abortion corresponding to the termination of life at whatever stage it is carried out, a position very close to that of the Catholic Church<sup><a href="#P217_55970" name="P217_55971">54</a></sup>. </p>

<p align="justify">41.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; How difficult it may appear then, to have a consensus on such a subject at a political level, where politicians&#8217; opinions are not only formed by expediency, but also by the different religious traditions and background<sup><a href="#P220_56407" name="P220_56408">55</a></sup>? These very same differences are in fact reflected very often at the level of political discussion and decision-making. They assume not only an importance due to the effect of the resultant legislation on society, but also due to the fact that as representatives, not delegates, of society, parliamentarians also have a duty to exhibit moral leadership as part and parcel of the political leadership they wield.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>C. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Cloning of Human Beings</b></p>

<p align="justify"><i>It keeps repeating itself, </i></p>

<p align="justify"><i>In this world so fine and honest, </i></p>

<p align="justify"><i>The parson alarms the populace, </i></p>

<p align="justify"><i>The genius is executed</i><sup><a href="#P228_57446" name="P228_57447">56</a></sup><i>.</i></p>

<p align="justify"><i>Albert Einstein</i></p>

<p align="justify"><i><b>Issues</b></i></p>

<p align="justify">42.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; One of the most recent advances in biotechnology announced itself to the dumbstruck world, in the form of a sheep called Dolly. The science of cloning, whereby a creature is reproduced, which is genetically equivalent to another creature, may be applied to micro organisms, plants and animals. I will not dwell on the effects cloning has on these living materials, except to say that in lower life forms, self-cloning, is one of the possible ways of asexual reproduction. In higher animals, through evolution, this form has given way to sexual reproduction, because of the greater genetic variation that it produces! Therefore, it is relevant to point out that natural selection has favoured the development of sexual reproduction over and above that of asexual reproduction. Humans, being considered as animals biologically (<i>Homo Sapiens sapiens)</i>, may consequently be cloned, and it is pertinent to extrapolate, that once a higher animal life form such as a sheep, can be cloned, then the technology is also available for cloning man, that is human cells. </p>

<p align="justify">43.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; There are three situations that have to be distinguished in the cloning of human and animal cells. First, the cloning of mature somatic cells, which may be used for the repair of specific developed and mature body tissue, such as cloning a liver or pancreas. There is no ethical problem with this type of therapeutic cloning. Second, the cloning of embryos to produce human stem cells, which still being immature and pluripotent, may be used therapeutically, but can also be abused to produce human clones. This case needs special attention and is being dealt with, in a new protocol to the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine under a protocol on embryo protection. Third, the cloning of human beings by transferring the nucleus of a normal mature cell into the enucleated reproductive cell (ovum) for a female of the species, then inserted into a female uterus, producing a human being genetically equal to the cell source. This is called nuclear transfer. It is this third situation that will take up the concerns of this chapter<sup><a href="#P236_59705" name="P236_59706">57</a></sup>. It would be wise to reveal at this stage of affairs, that it is possible to precisely duplicate the genetic materials in the cell-nucleus, resulting in the identical physical phenotype, however even cloned human cells will not be exactly the same as the source, because of the inability to equally reproduce the DNA in the cytoplasmic mitochondria<sup><a href="#P237_60202" name="P237_60203">58</a></sup>! </p>

<p align="justify"><b><i>European Legal and Ethical Positions</i></b></p>

<p align="justify">44.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The announcement of Dolly&#8217;s birth brought about a swift series of legal proclamations banning the cloning of human beings. Much work had already been done in Europe, which had led to a scientific and political consensus as to the illegality and immorality of <u>human </u>cloning. This work had been carried out for several years, both in the Council of Europe and in the European Parliament. It would be relevant to go through the main proclamations on the issue. Since the cloning of human beings, is a matter that directly concerns human rights, it is mostly dealt with in the Council of Europe, but its absolute importance has not prevented it from being discussed and prohibited, even in discussions and recommendations of the EP.</p>

<p align="justify">45.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In the Council of Europe, one finds<a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc= Recommendations 934"> Recommendations 934</a> (1982), 1046 (1986) and 1100 (1989), which effectively express a sanction on human cloning. The Council&#8217;s Oviedo Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine also contains articles (1 &amp; 13) that implicitly prohibit human cloning. However, the clearest prohibition against cloning has been the addition of the first protocol to this same Convention, which deals with the explicit banning of human cloning, and was opened for signature, potentially only by the signatories of the Oviedo Convention, on 12 January, 1998. In Article 1, the protocol clearly states that: <i>Any intervention seeking to create a human being genetically identical to another human being, whether living or dead, is prohibited</i>.</p>

<p align="justify">46.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Similar recommendations have been issued by the <i>European Union</i>. In June 1997, the <i>European Council</i> put forward a declaration banning the cloning of human beings, and suggested that the Council and Commission keep this as one of the priority policies when considering community policy<sup><a href="#P246_62110" name="P246_62111">59</a></sup>. In fact, the EU had already established that no funds would be allocated to human cloning research when adopting the specific research programme in the fields of biotechnology and biomedicine<sup><a href="#P247_62375" name="P247_62376">60</a></sup>. On the 28 May 1997, the Group of Advisors on the Ethical Implications of Biotechnology to the European Commission (GAEIB) also put forward recommendations concerning the ethical procedural policy in the cloning of animals and also strictly prohibiting human cloning<sup><a href="#P248_62716" name="P248_62717">61</a></sup>. They also asked that no funds for human cloning research be available under the fifth research programme. The European Parliament also approved a Resolution on Cloning on the 12 March 1997, where it expressly called for human cloning to <i>continue to be prohibited</i> and <i>for an explicit worldwide ban on the cloning of human beings</i><sup><a href="#P249_63239" name="P249_63240">62</a></sup>. It is important to point out, that this was not the first initiative by the EP against human cloning, and several debates in the Parliament had highlighted this problem, pointing out due considerations. One can refer to the Resolutions of the 16 March 1989 on the ethical and legal problems of genetic engineering<sup><a href="#P250_63607" name="P250_63608">63</a></sup> and artificial insemination &#8216;in vivo&#8217; and &#8216;in vitro&#8217;<sup><a href="#P251_63720" name="P251_63721">64</a></sup>, and 28 October 1993 on the cloning of human embryos<sup><a href="#P252_63825" name="P252_63826">65</a></sup>. In addition, in adopting legislation on the legal protection of biotechnological inventions in 1998 (Directive 98/44/EC), the legislation specifically excludes processes for the cloning of human beings from patentability (Article 6.2a), as it is considered offending to public morals.</p>

<p align="justify">47.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; On the international level, the issue of human cloning is being pursued by certain organizations. The World Medical Association<i>,</i> at the 49th assembly held in Hamburg in November 1997, adopted a resolution calling on doctors and other scientists engaged in research, to voluntarily abstain from participating in the cloning of human beings, until legal and ethical controls have been put into place. The UNESCO declaration for the protection of the human genome<sup><a href="#P255_64628" name="P255_64629">66</a></sup>, although not mentioning human cloning by name, implicitly forbids its utilization for any reason, as it directly opposes the hollowed and uncompromisable concepts of individual human dignity. Article 2a states that: <i>The genome of each individual represents his or her <u>specific genetic identity</u>, </i>while Article 10 declares that: <i>No scientific research or its applications in the fields of biology and genetics should be allowed to prevail over the respect for human dignity and human rights. </i>Other articles such as 5b and 6, also similarly preclude human cloning<sup><a href="#P256_65389" name="P256_65390">67</a></sup>. There is presently a debate proceeding at the UN, which aims to produce an international convention to prohibit reproductive, if not therapeutic cloning.</p>

<p align="justify"><b><i>Moral positions</i></b></p>

<p align="justify">48.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; One would expect that in the religious field, one would find as tight a position on human cloning as one does in the political field. This in fact does not turn out to be so! In the Protestant theological debates, positions vary from the outright prohibition, to the allowing of human cloning under certain circumstances, although most theologians are against it <i>per se</i>. There is no such thing as a common Protestant position. Quoting from an article by C. Ben Mitchell Ph.D., the writer clearly gives several moral reasons for stating, &#8220;<i>Cloning human embryos is wrong&#8221;</i><sup><a href="#P261_66348" name="P261_66349">68</a></sup>. Several Protestant Churches such as the United Methodist Church<sup>15</sup>, share this view. On the other hand other Protestant theologians are not always so categorical about absolutely banning human cloning<sup><a href="#P262_66707" name="P262_66708">69</a></sup>, such as the declaration by Dr. Nancy Duff of Princeton University that: <i>I would not rule cloning out of bounds apart from its consequences, and say that it is wrong in and of itself...if someone could show to me that it really would enhance the well-being of future lives...I cannot say that a conceived egg, a fertilized egg is exactly the same as a born human being. I do not think anybody entirely says that.</i></p>

<p align="justify">49.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Once again the moral and legal status of the human embryo is overshadowing this issue. Gerald P. McKinney, a Calvinist theologian, states that little attention has been paid to the ethical implication of human cloning<sup><a href="#P265_67432" name="P265_67433">70</a></sup>. He declares that it is <u>likely</u> that given the circumstances surrounding the procedure, most ethicists would resist it. However there is no categorical denial of the procedure as wrong in itself. In addition, strangely enough, the ecumenical declaration by the WCC in Moscow in 1989, did <u>not</u> list human cloning among the eleven recommendations it issued, as proposals of a practical nature to its member churches<sup><a href="#P266_67973" name="P266_67974">71</a></sup>.</p>

<p align="justify">50.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The position within the Catholic Church is much clearer and categorical, not only amongst individual theologians but also in the official teachings. The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith in its paper Instruction on Respect for Human Life in its Origin and the Dignity of Procreation, (Donum Vitae), issued in 1987, clearly delineates that: ...<i>attempts or hypothesis for obtaining a human being without any connection with sexuality through &#8220;twin fusion&#8221;, cloning or parthenogenesis are to be considered contrary to the moral law since they are in opposition to the dignity both of human procreation and of the conjugal union</i><sup><a href="#P269_68636" name="P269_68637">72</a></sup><i>.</i></p>

<p align="justify">51.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Also further on, the importance of sexual reproduction in human procreation is underlined, where one finds that: <i>Every human being is always to be accepted as a gift and blessing of God. However, from the moral point of view a truly responsible procreation vis-à-vis the unborn child must be the fruit of marriage</i><sup><a href="#P272_68975" name="P272_68976">73</a></sup><i>.</i></p>

<p align="justify">52.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger, in an interview to the Italian daily <i>La Repubblica</i> and reported by the Catholic Herald<i> </i>of the 14 March 1997, clearly condemned human cloning and said that it <i>is a dangerous possibility which should not be underestimated because you do not play with human life</i>. On the 24 June 1997, the Pontifical Academy for Life instituted by John Paul II, published a text called Reflections on Cloning. In the text one finds that: <i>On the level of human rights, eventual human cloning would represent a violation of two fundamental principles on which human rights are based: the principle of parity among human beings and the principle of non-discrimination </i>and also further down the line, that it <i>...is part of the project of eugenics</i>. Several other Catholic theologians also speak clearly against human cloning, such as Lisa Cahill of Boston College<sup><a href="#P275_69867" name="P275_69868">74</a></sup>, Rev. Dr. Albert Moraczewski representing the US National Conference of Catholic Bishops<sup><a href="#P276_70119" name="P276_70120">75</a></sup>. Eberhard Schockenhoff also clearly, not only condemns human cloning, but also highlights the difference between man-induced artificial cloning and that occurring naturally in the conception of twins or other multiple pregnancies, such as the <i>contemporaneousness of their existence</i> and the fact that their hereditary information was determined by two alien individuals<sup><a href="#P277_70641" name="P277_70642">76</a></sup>.</p>

<p align="justify">53.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The confusing situation amongst different religions, is made worse when one considers that many Jewish and Islamic scholars believe that human cloning is not only permissible, but might have a moral obligation if its aim is to rectify the problems of infertile couples<sup><a href="#P280_71308" name="P280_71309">77</a></sup>.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>D.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Patenting of Human Beings</b></p>

<p align="justify"><i>The Destiny of man has slipped from the hands of politicians into the hands of scientists, </i></p>

<p align="justify"><i>who know not what they do, but pass responsibility for results</i></p>

<p align="justify"><i> on to those whose sense of proportion and knowledge </i></p>

<p align="justify"><i>are inadequate to the situations created by science.</i></p>

<p align="justify"><i>Desmond McCarthy</i></p>

<p align="justify"><i><b>Issues</b></i></p>

<p align="justify">54.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Ever since genes started to be read, and their industrial and medical applications realized, individuals and industries started to think about the patent protection of the genetic and technical information at their disposal and the protection of new forms of life made possible by the process of transgenesis. New life forms such as microorganisms and new plant varieties have been registered for quite some time now, although new plant varieties are protected under their own specific legislation and not usually under general patenting laws. Patenting is of course, sought after, in order to protect the amount of research capital, that a particular individual or company would have invested, in a particular project. The lack of laws protecting intellectual property, would not induce commercial entities to invest substantial quantities of money in research, or would drive them away to other countries, which in fact had this legal protection on their statute books. </p>

<p align="justify">55.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In this regard, the European Union, until recently, lagged behind the USA and Japan, who evidently attracted much of the available investment for this simple reason. The main ethical issues which arise from the patenting question, include the fact whether or not, life-forms may be patented whether they be plants or animals, whether their genes may be patented, whether human genes in general, may be patented, and finally, whether human gene sequences of indeterminate function, called &#8216;c-DNA&#8217;, may also be patented. There is also the issue of sharing the financial spin-offs fairly with all nations and groups involved, and of providing accessibility to everyone as regards knowledge and information. The present set up of issuing patents, is generally seen by developing countries, to be upsetting the balance of development against the interests of the poor countries of the world and further upsetting the North-South imbalance in favour of the North. In my opinion, this last ethical problem is the most pressing and palpable problem.</p>

<p align="justify">56.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The EU has now addressed many (but not all) of the ethical problems associated with this issue by adopting Directive 98/44/EC of the European Parliament and Council. The main provisions of this directive have been accepted by the European Patent Office (EPO) set up under the European Patent Convention of 1973. More however needs to be done. For a detailed perspective on this issue, please refer to the document AS/Cult/Science (2003) 04.</p>

<p align="justify">Reporting committee: Committee on Culture, Science and Education </p>

<p align="justify">Reference to committee: <a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc=Doc. 9581">Doc. 9581</a> and Reference No 2767 of 18.11.2002</p>

<p align="justify">Draft recommendation adopted by the committee on 5 May 2003 with 6 votes against and 2 abstentions</p>

<p align="justify">Members of the committee: MM. <i>de Puig</i> (Chairman), Baroness <i>Hoope</i>r, MM. <i>Prisacaru, Smorawinski</i> (Vice-Chair), Apostoli, Asciak, Banks, Barbieri, Berceanu (Alternate: Baciu), Braga, Buzatu, Mrs Castro (Alternate: Mr <i>Varela i Serra</i>), MM. Chaklein, Colombier, Mrs Cryer, MM. Cubreacov, Dalgaard, Mrs Damanaki, Mrs <i>Delvaux-Stehres</i>, Mr <i>Devinsky</i>, Mrs <i>Domingues</i>, Mr Eversdijk, Mrs Eymer, Mrs Fehr, Mrs <i>Fernández-Capel</i>, MM. Gadzinowski, Galchenko, Galoyan, <i>Gentil</i>, Mrs Glovacki-Bernardi, MM. Goris, Gündüz I., Gündüz S., Mrs Had&#382;iahmetovi&#263; MM. Haraldsson, Hegyi, <i>Howlin</i>,<i> Huseynov R</i>, Iannuzzi (Alternate: <i>Gaburro</i>), Mrs Isohookana-Asunmaa (Alternate: Mr&nbsp;<i>Tiuri</i>), MM. Jakic, Jarab, Jurgens, Mrs Katseli, Mrs Klaar, Mrs <i>Labucka</i>, MM. Legendre, Lengagne, <i>Letzgus</i>, <i>Libicki</i>, <i>Livaneli</i>, Mrs <i>Lucyga</i>, MM. Lydeka, Malgieri, Marxer, Mrs Melandri, MM. Melnikov, Mestan, <i>Mezihorak</i>, Mrs <i>Milotinova</i>, Mrs <i>Muttonen</i>, Mr <i>O&#8217;Hara</i>, Mrs Ohlsson, MM. Podeschii, Rakhansky, Rockenbauer, Rybak, Mrs&nbsp;Samoilovska-Cvetanova, MM. Schellens, Schneider, <i>Shybko</i>, Sizopoulos, Mrs <i>Skarbĝvik</i>, MM. <i>Sudarenko (</i>Alternate:<i> Korobeynikov)</i>, Tusek (Alternate: <i>Grissemann</i>), Vakilov, Mrs <i>Westerlund Panke</i>, Mr. Wodarg, N.., N.., N&#8230;, N &#8230;</p>

<p align="justify">N.B. The names of those present at the meeting are printed in italics</p>

<p align="justify">Head of secretariat: Mr Grayson </p>

<p align="justify">Secretaries to the committee: Mr Ary, Mrs Theophilova-Permaul</p>
<hr align="left" size="1" width="200" noshade>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P74_7465" href="#P74_7466">1</a> </sup> From <i>By the Babe Unborn</i>, web-site http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Troy/7854/babe.txt</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P84_9183" href="#P84_9184">2</a> </sup> European Network of Scientific Co-operation on Medicine and Human Rights, <i>The human rights, ethical and moral dimensions of health care</i>, Council of Europe Publications, Strasbourg, 1998, pg. 145.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P87_9556" href="#P87_9557">3</a> </sup> See article by Serra, A., in &#8216;Advances in Medical Genetics Prospectives and Ethical Problems&#8217;, <i>Melita Theologica</i>, Vol. XLVIII, 1997, No. 1, University of Malta, pg. vii.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P88_10478" href="#P88_10479">4</a> </sup> See article by Lejeune, J., in<i> The Question of In Vitro Fertilization</i>, Society for the Protection of Unborn Children Educational Trust, London, 1984.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P93_11309" href="#P93_11310">5</a> </sup> Ford, N. M., <i>When did I begin,</i> Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1988.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P98_13093" href="#P98_13094">6</a> </sup> Locke 1690, Ch. 27, Book II, pg. 188, &#8220;We must consider what person stands for; which I think is a thinking intelligent being, that has reason and reflection, and can consider itself the same thinking thing, in different times and places; which it does only by that consciousness which is inseparable from thinking and seems to me essential to it; it being impossible for anyone to perceive without perceiving that he does perceive&#8221;.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P99_13581" href="#P99_13582">7</a> </sup> Harris, J., &#8216;The Concept of the Person and the Value of Life&#8217;, <i>Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, </i>Vol. 9, No. 4, 1999, John Hopkins University Press, Maryland, pg. 303.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P108_17343" href="#P108_17344">8</a> </sup> Junqueira, L. C., Carniero, J., Kelley, R. O., <i>Basic Histology</i>, Appleton and Lange, Connecticut, 1995, pg. 20 - 65.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P113_20404" href="#P113_20405">9</a> </sup> Transcription is the process whereby the DNA replicates its information onto Messenger RNA molecules, which then travel to Ribosomal RNA in the cytoplasm, so that with the help of Transfer RNA molecules, are able to initiate the process of protein synthesis called Translation.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P116_21485" href="#P116_21486">10</a> </sup> Larsen, W. J., <i>Human Embryology</i>, Churchill Livingstone, New York, 1997, pg. 19.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P121_22703" href="#P121_22704">11</a> </sup> Lewin, B., <i>Genes VI,</i> Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1997, Ch. 12 &amp; 38.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P124_23459" href="#P124_23460">12</a> </sup> Serra, A., &#8216;Advances in Medical Genetics Prospectives and Ethical Problems&#8217;, <i>Melita Theologica,</i> Vol. XLVIII, University of Malta, 1997, University of Malta, pg. xii.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P125_23761" href="#P125_23762">13</a> </sup> Lodish, H., Baltimore, D., Berk, A., Zipursky, S. L., Matsudaira, P., Darnell, J., <i>Molecular Cell Biology</i>, Scientific American Books, New York, 1995, pg. 568.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P126_24249" href="#P126_24250">14</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., pg. 1160.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P129_24386" href="#P129_24387">15</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., pg. 1160.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P132_25300" href="#P132_25301">16</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., pg. 1150-1153.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P135_26699" href="#P135_26700">17</a> </sup> Lodish, H., Berk, A., Zipursky, S. L., Matsudaira, P., Baltimore, D., Darnell, J., <i>Molecular Cell Biology</i>, W. H. Freeman and Company, New York, 2000, pg. 1024. </p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P138_27999" href="#P138_28000">18</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>. pg. 1050.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P141_29568" href="#P141_29569">19</a> </sup> An embryo&#8217;s potential for spontaneous twinning seems to be established at an early stage by factors determining the thickness of the Zona Pellucida. <i>Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal</i>, June 1999, John Hopkins University Press, Maryland, pg. 138.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P144_30265" href="#P144_30266">20</a> </sup> Serra, A., &#8216;Advances in Medical Genetics Prospectives and Ethical Problems&#8217;, <i>Melita Theologica</i>, Vol. XLVIII, University of Malta, pg. xvi.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P157_34408" href="#P157_34409">21</a> </sup> Turnbull, Sir A., Chamberlain, G., <i>Obstetrics</i>, Churchill Livingstone, Edinburgh, 1989, pg. 50-51.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P158_34867" href="#P158_34868">22</a> </sup> Knobil, E., Neill, J. D., <i>The Physiology of Reproduction - Volume 1</i>, Raven Press, New York, 1994, pg. 279, 337.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P159_35181" href="#P159_35182">23</a> </sup> Shaw, R. W., Soutter, W. P., Stanton, S. L., <i>Gynaecology</i>, Churchill Livingston, New York, 1997, pg. 244.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P160_35479" href="#P160_35480">24</a> </sup> Stout, G. W., Taylor, D. J., Soper, R., <i>Biology</i>, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1990, pg. 807.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P161_35810" href="#P161_35811">25</a> </sup> O&#8217;Rahilly, R., Muller, F., <i>Human Embryology &amp; Teratology</i>, Wiley-Liss, Inc., New York, 1996, pg. 28-29. See also, Sadler, T. W., <i>Langman&#8217;s medical embryology</i>, Williams and Wilkins, Maryland, 1995, pg. 29-31.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P162_36350" href="#P162_36351">26</a> </sup> Edwards, R. G., <i>Conception in the Human Female</i>, Academic Press, London, 1980, pg. 621-635.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P165_36830" href="#P165_36831">27</a> </sup> Serra, A., <i>About The Second Polar Body And Blastomere Genetic Analysis For Preimplantation Diagnosis, </i>and <i>Il Processo Della Fertilizzazione: &#8216;Lo Zygote&#8217;.</i></p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P166_37260" href="#P166_37261">28</a> </sup> Balinsky, B. I., <i>An Introduction to Embryology</i>, CBS College Publishing, Philadelphia, 1981, pg. 129.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P167_37780" href="#P167_37781">29</a> </sup> Knobil, E., Neill, J. D., <i>The Physiology of Reproduction - Volume 1</i>, Raven Press, New York, 1994, pg. 279.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P168_38110" href="#P168_38111">30</a> </sup> <i>Ibid.,</i> pg. 337. See also <i>PubMed Services Journal Browser</i>, National Library of Medicine, at web-site http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/PubMed/, PMID: 10529265, UI: 99458740; PMID: 8665158, UI: 96264841; PMID: 9671588, UI:98337834; PMID: 3567278, UI: 87185682; PMID: 1652263, UI: 91345899; PMID: 7826613, UI: 95127200; PMID: 8462992, UI: 93216305; PMID: 94099678, UI: 98072336; PMID: 10497327, UI: 99428615; PMID: 7537698, UI: 95255522; PMID: 9211427, UI: 97355232; PMID: 10497327, UI: 99428615; PMID: 1279404, UI: 93063005; PMID: 7925035, UI: 95009561; PMID: 8462750, UI: 93215945; PMID: 9013938, UI: 97166045; PMID: 7781890, UI: 95301089. </p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P177_40094" href="#P177_40095">31</a> </sup> <i>Donum Vitae</i>, Part I, No. 1, Vatican document, 1987. &#8220;The human being must be respected - as a person - from the very first instance of his existence&#8221;. </p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P178_40288" href="#P178_40289">32</a> </sup> <i>Instrumentum Laboris</i>, Vatican document, 1991, Part I. &#8220;The second fact is the denial, on the part of some sectors of the scientific and cultural world, of the <i>full value of the human being, from the first moment of fertilization</i>&#8221;.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P179_40601" href="#P179_40602">33</a> </sup> <i>Evangelium Vitae</i>, encyclical letter by Pope John Paul II, Vatican document 1995, Ch. IV-101. &#8220;When the Church declares that unconditional respect for the right to life of every innocent person - from <u>conception to natural death</u> - is one of the pillars on which every civil society stands, she wants simply to promote a human state&#8221;.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P180_40975" href="#P180_40976">34</a> </sup> <i>John Paul II</i>, addressing members of the <i>Pontifical Academy for Life</i> in Rome for their third plenary assembly, February 14, 1997, (VIS). &#8220;How can not one recall, that our era is seeing an unheard of and almost unimaginable slaughter of innocent human beings, to which many States have given the guarantee of the law? How many times has the Church raised her voice, unheeded, in defense of these human beings! And how many times unfortunately, has something been presented as a right and sign of civilization, but which is instead an aberrant crime with respect of the most defenseless of human beings&#8221;.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P181_41682" href="#P181_41683">35</a> </sup> Pius XII: <i>Broadcast speeches and messages,</i> Vol.X, 1948-49, pg. 98-99.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P182_41976" href="#P182_41977">36</a> </sup> O&#8217;Mahony P.J., <i>A Question of Life - Its Beginning and Transmission</i>, Sheed and Ward, London, 1990, pg. 108. Also see Pastuszek E., French R.B., <i>Is the Fetus Human?,</i> Tan Books, Illinois, 1993, Ch. 5.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P183_42464" href="#P183_42465">37</a> </sup> St. Thomas Aquinas was clear that there was actual homicide when an ensouled embryo was killed. He was equally clear that ensoulment did not take place at conception, - John T. Noonan, Jr., &#8216;An Almost Absolute Value in History&#8217;, in Noonan, J. T., Jr., ed., <i>The Morality of Abortion</i>, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1970. In the <i>Declaration on Abortion,</i> the Vatican&#8217;s Acta Apostolicae Sedis 66 ,1974, pg. 738, it is stated that it is possible to have a human life without soul. The official teaching is that we cannot be absolutely sure when the soul is present or when the human conceptus has personhood - it could well be at the moment of fertilization. But whatever about the personhood or soul, the Vatican declaration does believe that there is incipient biological human life and it should always receive the benefit of the doubt. Compare this with the remarks of a leading Anglican of the time, J. Fleming, who &#8220;rejects the contention that there is a distinction between <u>human beings</u> and <u>human persons</u> in the sense that the embryo is first a human being and later a human person. A person is someone, he says, who has certain human functional abilities - talking, choosing, awareness and suchlike. People, he says, have argued that personhood is achieved. He feels that this is a flawed arguement. If personhood is something achieved, it can be lost. What if the individual becomes mentally disabled? Does that individual cease to be a person? Again, nature does not revolve around function, rather function revolves around nature. I communicate, he says, because I am a human person. I am not a human person simply because I communicate. If the person were illiterate or dumb, he remains a person. Communication is the result of his personhood. He, therefore, suggests that personhood is an endowment, rather than an achievement which is present at fertilization&#8221;. This discussion on personhood was further complicated by the fact that the Classical Greek concept of personhood prevalent in the West and based on two components, was different to the Semitic concept of personhood, based on three components (Mgr. Karm Cassar, University of Malta). </p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P184_44759" href="#P184_44760">38</a> </sup> <i>Donum Vitae</i>, Vatican Document, 1987, Part1, No. 4 &amp; No. 5, &#8220;If the embryos are living, whether viable or not, they must be respected just like any other human person....experimentation on embryos which is not directly therapeutic is illicit....It is immoral to produce human embryos destined to be exploited as disposable &#8216;biological material&#8217;&#8221;.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P191_45999" href="#P191_46000">39</a> </sup><i> Costly Unity</i>, The World Council of Churches, Switzerland, 1993, pg. 8. Although the WCC, does recommend that experimentation on embryos should not be held unless in very definite and controlled conditions. See Chapter 3, footnote 43 (6).</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P192_46536" href="#P192_46537">40</a> </sup> Mortensen V., <i>Life and Death - Moral Implications of Biotechnology</i>, WCC Publications, Geneva, 1995, pg. 30, 31, 39, 53. &#8220;There are diverging interpretations...of when humans attain their dignity and how absolute or inviolable it is....not even Lutheran theologians define this right (to life) as absolute....This means that from a Christian point of view, abortion can only be a last resort, when the mental or physical health of the mother is seriously threatened by the pregnancy, or when it can be predicted that the child, if it were born, would have a short life of severe suffering....There are those (among Lutheran theologians) who give their argumentation on bioethical issues a specifically Christian basis, pointing to the fact that the human being is created by God and has infinite value. Others choose to put forward their arguements on a more common basis by ascribing human dignity either to personality or to the fact that each individual as a part of humankind is to be understood collectively&#8221;.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P193_48333" href="#P193_48334">41</a> </sup> Bioethics journal, <i>Ethics and Medicine, </i>Vol 14:1 1998, &#8216;Religion-Based Perspectives on Cloning of Humans&#8217;, Centre for Bioethics and Public Policy, London, pg. 17 &amp; 25. </p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P196_48896" href="#P196_48897">42</a> </sup> Tan Books and Publishers, Inc., Rockford, Illinois, 1993, pg. 58-65.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P200_50841" href="#P200_50842">43</a> </sup> Sheed and Ward, London, 1990.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P201_51181" href="#P201_51182">44</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., &#8220;This was a balance between the very strongly held feelings that people have about protection that the human embryo should be afforded and the desire, that I think all of us share, that the research which is going to help the diminution of genetic diseases should be allowed to go on....I don&#8217;t think there is an absolute all or nothing case here. I mean our point was, and the majorities&#8217; point, that you afford the embryo certain protection in law but not total and complete protection in law&#8221;.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P202_52107" href="#P202_52108">45</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., pg. 111.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P203_52392" href="#P203_52393">46</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., pg. 113.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P204_52610" href="#P204_52611">47</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., pg. 115-116.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P205_52949" href="#P205_52950">48</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., pg. 118.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P208_53443" href="#P208_53444">49</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., pg. 119-121.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P209_53631" href="#P209_53632">50</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., pg. 122.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P210_54173" href="#P210_54174">51</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., pg. 124-125.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P211_54560" href="#P211_54561">52</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., pg. 126.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P212_54963" href="#P212_54964">53</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., pg. 128.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P217_55970" href="#P217_55971">54</a> </sup> European Network of Scientific Co-operation on Medicine and Human Rights, <i>The human rights, ethical and moral dimensions of health care</i>, Council of Europe Publications, Strasbourg, 1998, pg. 86, 97, 146 &amp; 207.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P220_56407" href="#P220_56408">55</a> </sup> Observe the reaction to <i>Mr. Enoch Powell&#8217;s</i> private members&#8217; bill entitled <i>The Unborn Children Protection</i> <i>Bill</i>, which was designed to prohibit creation of embryos for purposes of experimentation in the UK. This had substantial support in the house, but was made to fail by delaying tactics from the left (<i>Michael Foot</i> and others). The passage of this bill led to a fracas in the House, where even the Speaker&#8217;s chair was broken, due to the intensity of the passions aroused.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P228_57446" href="#P228_57447">56</a> </sup> &#8220;<i>Es wiederholt sich immer wieder, In dieser Welt so fein und bieder, Der Pfaff den Poebel alarmiert, Der Genius wird executiert&#8221;.</i></p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P236_59705" href="#P236_59706">57</a> </sup> See report on the prohibition of cloning human beings <i><a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc=Doc. 7895">Doc. 7895</a> </i>&amp;<i> 7906</i> by the Parliamentary Assembly, Council of Europe Publications, Strasbourg.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P237_60202" href="#P237_60203">58</a> </sup> Cormack, D. H., <i>Essential Histology</i>, J. B. Lippincott Company, Philadelphia, 1993, pg. 58.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P246_62110" href="#P246_62111">59</a> </sup> <i>Europe</i>, Documents No. 2041/42, 20 June 1997, Agence Europe, Brussels.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P247_62375" href="#P247_62376">60</a> </sup> Council Decisions of 15 December 1994, <i>94 / 912 / EC</i> and <i>94 / 913 / EC</i>.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P248_62716" href="#P248_62717">61</a> </sup> <i>Opinions of the Group of Advisors on the Ethical Implications of Biotechnology of the European Commission</i>, European Commission Secretariat-General SEC/9658/97, OOPEC, Luxembourg, pg. 130-136.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P249_63239" href="#P249_63240">62</a> </sup> <i>OJ C</i> 115, 14. 4. 97, OOPEC, Luxembourg, pg. 92-94.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P250_63607" href="#P250_63608">63</a> </sup> <i>OJ C</i> 96, 17. 4. 1989, OOPEC, Luxembourg, pg. 165.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P251_63720" href="#P251_63721">64</a> </sup> <i>OJ C</i> 96, 17. 4. 1989, OOPEC, Luxembourg, pg. 171.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P252_63825" href="#P252_63826">65</a> </sup> <i>OJ C</i> 315, 22. 11. 1993, OOPEC, Luxembourg, pg. 224.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P255_64628" href="#P255_64629">66</a> </sup> On the 9 December 1998, the <i>United Nations General Assembly</i> endorsed without a vote, the UNESCO declaration termed, the <i>Universal Declaration On The Human Genome And Human Rights</i>, adopted in 1997.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P256_65389" href="#P256_65390">67</a> </sup> In the USA, <i>President Clinton</i> called for the prohibition of public monies for the use of research in human cloning. A proposal to Congress for a cloning prohibition act in the United States, was also presented.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P261_66348" href="#P261_66349">68</a> </sup> <i>Ethics and Medicine</i>, Vol. 14:1 1998, article entitled &#8216;A Protestant Perspective on Cloning&#8217;, Centre for Bioethics and Public Policy, London, pg. 26-29.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P262_66707" href="#P262_66708">69</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., article entitled &#8216;Religion-Based Perspectives on Cloning of Humans&#8217;, pg. 8-25.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P265_67432" href="#P265_67433">70</a> </sup> Robert Nelson, J., <i>On the New Frontiers of Genetics and Religion, </i>Wm B. Eerdmans Publishing Co.,<i> </i>Michigan, USA, 1994, pg. 162.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P266_67973" href="#P266_67974">71</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., pg. 172-174.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P269_68636" href="#P269_68637">72</a> </sup> Part I, section 6.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P272_68975" href="#P272_68976">73</a> </sup> Part II, section A1.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P275_69867" href="#P275_69868">74</a> </sup> &#8216;Religion-Based Perspectives on Cloning of Humans&#8217;, article in <i>Ethics and Medicine</i> 14:1, 1998, Centre for Bioethics and Public Policy, London, pg. 8 <i>et seq</i>.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P276_70119" href="#P276_70120">75</a> </sup> <i>Ibid</i>., pg. 10 <i>et seq. </i>Of particular note is the quotation &#8216;it is entirely unsuitable for human procreation even under exceptional circumstances&#8221;. </p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P277_70641" href="#P277_70642">76</a> </sup> &#8216;First Sheep, then Human Beings? Theological and Ethical Reflections on the Use of Gene technology&#8217;, article in <i>Concilium </i>1998/2, SCM Press, London, 1998, pg. 85 <i>et seq</i>. See also articles by Maurice Eminyan, in <i>The Times</i> of April 11, 1997, Allied Malta Newspapers, Malta, pg. 9, and &#8216;A Christian Outlook&#8217; in <i>The Sunday Times</i>, of March 15, 1998, Allied Malta Newspapers, Malta, pg. 10.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P280_71308" href="#P280_71309">77</a> </sup> <i>Houston Chronicle</i>, Saturday, March 15, 1997, Houston, Texas, pg. 8A.</p><!-- TRANSIT - INFOAFTER -->
</body>
</html>
