<html>
<head>
<meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=iso-8859-1">
<title>The OECD and the World Economy</title>
<meta name="GENERATOR" content="HTML Transit 7.0 by Stellent (tm), Inc. www.stellent.com">
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="/PortailStyle.css">
</head>
<body bgcolor="#ffffff"><a name="TopOfPage"> </a>
<!-- TRANSIT - INFOBEFORE -->
<table width="100%" border="0" cellpadding="4" cellspacing="0">
  <tr>
    <td><div align="left"><img src="/Documents/LogoText.jpg" width="218" height="48"></div>
    </td>
    <td><div align="right"><img border="0" SRC="/images/logos/Logo130X120.jpg" width="130" height="120"></div>
    </td>
  </tr>
</table>
<hr size="1">

<p align="justify"><b>Doc. 9851 </b></p>

<p align="justify">30 September 2003 </p>

<p><b>The OECD and the World Economy</b></p>

<p align="justify">Report</p>

<p align="justify">Committee on Economic Affairs and Development</p>

<p align="justify">Rapporteur: Mr Caccia, Canada, Liberal Party</p>

<p><b>I. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Draft Resolution</b></p>

<p align="justify"><b>General world economic situation and prospects</b></p>

<p align="justify">1.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Parliamentary Assembly, composed of Delegations of OECD and Council of Europe member states, has examined the recent activities of the OECD as they relate to the world economy, in the light of the report prepared by the Enlarged Assembly&#8217;s Committee on Economic Affairs and Development and the contributions from various other committees.</p>

<p align="justify">2.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly expresses cautious optimism as regards the possibility of a resumption of more healthy world economic growth, as prospects for especially the United States and Japan improve. It notes that the OECD in a recent unofficial forecast now foresees the OECD area to grow by 2.5% in 2003, as opposed to the organisation&#8217;s June 2003 prediction of only 1.9%. Remaining concerns include, however, the continued hesitation felt by consumers and investors in reaction to such factors as remaining fears over terrorism; the cost of the occupation of post-Saddam Hussein Iraq, not least as it affects the US budget deficit;  continued geo-political tension over North Korea&#8217;s and Iran&#8217;s nuclear programmes; eroded confidence in international governance such as the United Nations, but also in company ethics following major corporate scandals; and the dimmed prospects of successfully concluding the World Trade Organisation&#8217;s Doha Development Agenda resulting from the failure to reach agreement at the WTO Ministerial Conference in Cancun.</p>

<p align="justify">3.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The speedy conclusion of the war in Iraq and the adoption by the United Nations Security Council of<a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc= Resolution 1483"> Resolution 1483</a> (2003) opening the way to the country&#8217;s reconstruction, are developments that could contribute to regional and world growth, most importantly via lower oil prices resulting from resumed Iraqi exports. However, the frequent sabotage acts against the country&#8217;s infrastructure, and terrorist acts such as the bombing of the United Nations headquarters in Baghdad in August 2003 threaten to considerably slow down the reconstruction and render it more expensive.</p>

<p align="justify">4.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It must be hoped that the weaker dollar can soon revive US exports, and with them the overall US economy, and that a stronger euro and yen may stimulate overdue structural reform in the countries concerned, in order to permit them to play their full part in global economic recovery. An accommodating stance by, especially, the European Central Bank is also desirable in order to enable the euro area economy to fulfil this role.</p>

<p align="justify">5.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Such structural changes &#8211; varying according to the countries but of particular urgency for the large euro area economies as well as for Japan &#8211; include reform to preserve long term public finances as populations age and to introduce greater flexibility in labour markets. Unless reforms are undertaken urgently, continued weak growth risks undermining further already fragile public finances, not least as a result of increased unemployment resulting in lower tax income and added expenditure related to unemployment. It should be recalled that promotion of venture and inward foreign investment will stimulate the economies and create employment.</p>

<p align="justify">6.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly appreciates the OECD&#8217;s endeavours to ensure integrity and transparency in the world economy. It encourages the OECD and its member countries to intensify their efforts so as to enhance integrity and transparency in economic activities. In particular, stricter legislative control over corporate governance in many OECD countries is needed to ensure ethical behaviour.</p>

<p align="justify">7.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly in this connection notes with concern the widening gap in growth rates &#8211; and hence in GDP per capita &#8211; between a faster-growing United States on the one hand and several larger, more slowly growing European economies and Japan on the other. This development, which may lead to even more disruptive trade balances and frictions in the future, must be counteracted by more rapid structural reform in the latter group of countries, permitting faster growth capable of narrowing the gap.</p>

<p align="justify">8.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly views with concern the prospects for the US economy against the background of the uncovered future pension liabilities, which amount to $350 billion<i><b>, </b></i>and the country's growing public and private debt, as they result from a combination of tax cuts and enhanced expenditure, especially in the military and security fields.  It draws attention to the&nbsp;United States&#8217; resulting excessive dependence on global savings - sorely needed elsewhere - and to the risk that such dependence poses to a balanced development of the world economy.  More generally and holding for all countries, the Enlarged Assembly recalls the risk posed to governments' ability to govern if deficits and accumulated debt are allowed to rise unchecked. It recalls that, whereas the United States in 2000 and 2001 enjoyed budget surpluses of $236 billion and $127 billion, respectively, the deficit is forecast to reach $455 billion in the 2003 fiscal year.</p>

<p align="justify">9.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly deeply regrets the failure of the World Trade Organisation Ministerial Meeting in Cancun to reach an agreement on the principles for a successful conclusion of the Doha Development Agenda.  It now expects all parties to reflect on the causes for the setback, understand each others&#8217; concerns and redouble their efforts to engage in the necessary compromises to reach a final accord in 2004, in the interests of an open, fair and multi-lateral system for trade and investment.</p>

<p align="justify">10.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly warmly commends the World Health Organisation on its speedy and resolute action to contain the spread of SARS (severe acute respiratory syndrome), thereby preventing not only even greater human suffering than has been the case, but also literally saving an already strained world economy from even greater damage. OECD and Council of Europe member states must further strengthen WHO resources and thereby its ability to fight dangerous epidemics in the future. In addition, as a measure against SARS, the Enlarged Assembly requests that the structure of international cooperation centering around the WHO be strengthened through the development of a remedy or vaccine and public health countermeasures, to be made available to all nations on a timely basis, whether they are members of the WHO or not.</p>

<p align="justify">11. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly notes the increasing economic importance of the cultural sector, for example the music industry, tourism, sport, publishing and the audiovisual media (cinema and television). It believes that closer and more specific attention should be paid to this sector in discussion of the management of world commerce. It notes the positive declarations by the Council of Europe and Unesco on cultural diversity and welcomes the Canadian initiative to promote an international instrument in this field. It believes that the Council of Europe and OECD should also support this initiative.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>OECD reform and enlargement</b></p>

<p align="justify">12.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly is aware of the difficult choices facing the OECD as regards the expected enlargement from its present 30-country membership, not least against the background of imminent European Union enlargement and the rapid economic progress made by many other countries around the world. These considerations &#8211; ranging from the increasingly challenging task of preserving the Organisation&#8217;s consensus principle in reaching decisions, to overall working efficiency with more members, and to the need to preserve a balanced membership as between world regions &#8211; need to be tackled urgently. The Enlarged Assembly therefore welcomes the commitment made at the 2003 OECD Ministerial Council Meeting to making decisions on key reform issues in 2004 as proposed by the OECD Secretary General. The Enlarged Assembly resolves to follow all the above matters closely on behalf of the parliaments of all OECD and Council of Europe member countries.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>Sustainable Development</b></p>

<p><b><i>An overview for parliamentarians</i></b></p>

<p align="justify">13. &#8220;<i>Sustainable development is development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.</i>&#8221;<sup><a href="#P57_8295" name="P57_8296">1</a></sup>  The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe has adopted this definition and has long promoted an integrated approach to sustainable development, which sees protecting the environment, promoting human and social development and enhancing economic growth as inseparable dimensions of development.  In this approach, economic analysis and policy-making are not done in isolation from the impact of economic development on people and the environment, nor is economic development understood without recognition of its social and ecological underpinnings. </p>

<p align="justify">14.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Repeatedly, the Assembly has stressed the importance of sustainable development and the need to adopt an integrated approach. Most recently, it has adopted some provocative forward-looking reports on sustainable development goals and on reforms to key multilateral institutions for governing the global economy (including<a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc= Resolutions 1319"> Resolutions 1319</a>, 1318, 1292, 1288, and 1269).  </p>

<p align="justify">15.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The successful implementation of the sustainable development agenda envisioned by the United Nations, the OECD and others, depends on far-reaching changes in the way policy-development and analysis takes place in member governments as well as inside the OECD.  Parliamentarians have to ensure that governments adopt the technique of horizontal integration of policy analysis and development across all branches of government.  The same can be said of OECD organisational units.  Equally urgent is the necessity of shifting our conceptual approach from the conventional &#8220;economic&#8221; policy to the sustainable development economy.  What does this imply?  It implies a shift in economic policy-making and analysis.</p>

<p align="justify">16.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Parliamentarians know that the OECD, with its impressive record and research capabilities, can play an important and influential role in moving forward the global sustainable development agenda.  It is already attempting to do so, by identifying best practices among countries, devising comparative performance indicators, and providing detailed guidance on the application of sustainable development criteria to various policy sectors, particularly those that often have large environmental impacts.  </p>

<p align="justify">17.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Parliamentarians appreciate the fact that the OECD has adopted and advocated the integrated approach to sustainable development.  In addition, in the 2001 OECD Ministerial Mandate on Sustainable Development, for which the Enlarged Assembly has expressed strong support (Resolution 1259), member governments made a major political commitment to the full integration of sustainable development objectives into their national and international policies.  OECD governments are therefore politically committed to integrate environmental and social objectives into their economic decisions.  Not to balance them, but to integrate them into the heart of economic decision-making at all levels of authority and action from the local to the global.  As to the OECD Secretariat, it should be noted that it plays a key role; and not an easy one.  At present, it is supposed to integrate environmental and social objectives and considerations into economic analysis and policy development &#8211; the largest part of the OECD&#8217;s work and organisation.  The reverse also applies, namely that economic objectives and considerations must be integrated into environmental and social analysis and policy development.</p>

<p align="justify">18.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Greater attention should be paid by economic bodies such as the OECD to the integration of the cultural dimension and its diversity, in economic development, thus enhancing sustainable development.</p>

<p><b><i>For governments:</i></b></p>

<p align="justify">19.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly notes that the OECD has done important comparative work on environmental issues, and that it has demonstrated the urgent need for action in a number of areas.  For example, the 2001 <i>OECD Environmental Outlook </i>identifies the following areas as most pressing and assigned them &#8220;red light signals&#8221;: climate change / greenhouse gas emissions, motor vehicle and aviation air pollution emissions, effects of agricultural production on the environment, chemicals in the environment, municipal waste generation, freshwater scarcity, biodiversity, and fisheries.  The Enlarged Assembly believes that the failure of OECD members states to make urgently needed progress in these and other areas is a reflection of the fact that sustainable development is not or no longer seen as a priority issue.  As an organisation of nation-states, the OECD is limited in its choices, progress and decisions by the will of its members&#8217; governments.  The development and implementation of a substantive sustainable development agenda by the OECD is ultimately dependent, therefore, on the priorities of national parliaments and governments. </p>

<p align="justify">20.  The Enlarged Assembly notes that the 2001 Ministerial Mandate on Sustainable Development is due to expire in 2004.  Its renewal is of utmost necessity.  Therefore, the Enlarged Assembly calls on the OECD&#8217;s member governments to renew the Ministerial Mandate on Sustainable Development and to provide the OECD with the necessary resources to implement it fully.  And it urges parliamentarians to press member governments to make a long-term commitment to the implementation of the OECD&#8217;s sustainable development agenda.</p>

<p align="justify">21.  The Enlarged Assembly notes with concern the fact that resource constraints have made it difficult for the OECD to make significant progress in many areas of the 2001 Ministerial Mandate, even in the priority areas.<sup><a href="#P83_13923" name="P83_13924">2</a></sup>  The Enlarged Assembly urges the OECD&#8217;s member governments to make adequate resources available so that the OECD can fully implement the 2001 Ministerial Mandate and further develop its sustainable development agenda.</p>

<p align="justify">22.  The Enlarged Assembly calls on member governments to muster the political will to reach agreement on the selection of indicators to measure progress along all three dimensions of sustainable development, where such indicators have <i>not</i> yet been chosen.  </p>

<p align="justify">23.  The Enlarged Assembly also calls on member governments to intensify efforts to reach agreement on indicators to measure progress in the <i>social</i> dimension of sustainable development.  Policy analysis and proposals have focussed, for the most part, on the sustainability of pension systems in industrialized countries and on official development assistance.  Yet important issues such as education and social cohesion have so far received little attention in OECD discussions about sustainable development.   </p>

<p><b><i>For the OECD:</i></b></p>

<p align="justify">24.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly commends the OECD for the important work it has done on sustainable development and on environmental issues, both in general and in response to the 2001 Ministerial Mandate on Sustainable Development.  Work on implementing the latter has focused on:  (i) the preparation of a report to last year&#8217;s UN World Summit on Sustainable Development (WSSD) in Johannesburg; (ii) the development of indicators for use in OECD peer reviews; (iii) overcoming obstacles to the phasing out of environmentally damaging subsidies; and (iv) the social aspects of sustainable development.</p>

<p align="justify">25.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Progress made to date in implementing the sustainable development agenda confirms the OECD&#8217;s ability to play a central role in moving the world economy onto a sustainable path.  For instance: sustainable development sections are included now in the <i>Economic Survey</i>; environmentally harmful subsidies are under scrutiny; indicators to measure progress along all three dimensions of sustainable development are being developed; the 2001 <i>Environmental Outlook</i> provides an assessment of environmental pressures and conditions to 2020; and work is underway on a new environmental outlook with a longer-term time horizon.</p>

<p align="justify">26.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly commends the OECD for its analytical work on environmental problems in member countries and calls on the OECD to continue and intensify this valuable work, which could be very useful to parliamentarians.  </p>

<p align="justify">27.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly also commends the OECD for its contribution to the development and implementation of sustainable development indicators and calls on the OECD to continue and intensify its efforts in this area.</p>

<p align="justify">28.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Although the 2001 OECD Ministerial Mandate defines sustainable development as &#8220;an overarching goal of OECD governments and the OECD,&#8221; the OECD has not made the desired progress in two vital areas for the successful implementation of the sustainable development agenda set by the 2001 Ministerial Mandate: (i) the horizontal integration of analysis and policy-development across OECD organisational units responsible for the dimensions of sustainable development; and (ii) the required conceptual shift in economic analysis and policy-making, which would lead to the integration of environmental and social objectives into economic analysis an policy-development.  </p>

  <ul><p align="justify">i. The Enlarged Assembly urges the OECD to further integrate across the organisation its analytical and policy-development work, so as to ensure an integrated outcome; and to expand its work on sustainable development into the core areas of economic and fiscal policy analysis and development.</p>

  <p align="justify">ii. The Enlarged Assembly also urges the OECD to intensify efforts in bringing the sustainable development perspective to bear on economic analysis, and to switch economic analysis and policy development from a narrow focus on economic growth to a broader focus on sustainable development.  One area, where the OECD can and should make a far greater contribution, is in the development and employment of indicators in economic analysis, so as to reflect the full economic, social and environmental costs and benefits of human activities.</p>

</ul><p align="justify">29. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly suggests that OECD extend its integrated approach to sustainable development to include the significant cultural and educational dimensions. (a) The Assembly insists that cultural factors such as archaeological and built cultural heritage and the contemporary cultures of indigenous populations are properly taken into account in the impact analyses of major development projects such as dams. (b) It also proposes that integrated sustainable development be instated as a core element in higher education and business courses related to development.</p>

<p align="justify">30.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The precautionary principle is another important consideration.  Policy makers should not wait for the smoking gun, but rather take preventive measures without waiting for full scientific certainty, when there is evidence pointing to serious irreversible damage to human health or the environment.  The principle is enshrined in international agreements, including the Second North Sea Declaration, the Framework Convention on Climate Change, The Maastricht Treaty of the European Union, the Helsinki Convention, the Biosafety Protocol, the Nine Principles of the United Nations&#8217; Global Compact, and the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises. The Enlarged Assembly notes that the precautionary principle has not been widely applied to economic policy analysis and development and calls on the OECD to make a greater effort to incorporate it in analytical and policy-development work.</p>

<p align="justify">31.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly urges the OECD to deepen its work on sustainable development to include policy areas, which &#8211; if changed &#8211; could help move OECD economies towards a sustainable development path.  In particular, the OECD has done some important work identifying obstacles to the introduction of environmental taxes and to the elimination of certain harmful subsidies.  However, work on tax expenditures and perverse subsidies has lagged behind.  </p>

<p align="justify">32.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In the 2001 Ministerial Mandate, OECD Ministers of Finance, Economics and the Environment called on the Roundtable on Sustainable Development to &#8220;strengthen its role as a forum for international dialogue among stakeholders.&#8221;  The Enlarged Assembly calls on OECD governments to ensure the continuation of the OECD Round Table on Sustainable Development&#8217;s activities by securing renewed funding for its operations as an independent body. </p>

<p align="justify">33. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Finally, the Enlarged Assembly asks the OECD Secretary-General to report to the Enlarged Assembly the outcome of the 2004 <font color="#223152">OECD Council meetings at Ministerial level, as they relate to the OECD&#8217;s sustainable development agenda.</font></p>

<p align="justify"><b><i>For Parliamentarians:</i></b></p>

<p align="justify">34.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The role of parliamentarians in achieving sustainable development goals cannot be over-emphasized.  Considering that modern governance requires innovative and critical thinking to implement sustainable development, it becomes clear that new ideas are needed if we are to find solutions to pressing and interlinked environmental, social and economic problems.  Parliamentary attention and action is needed to trigger the political will required to reach adequate solutions when difficult political choices are involved.  Parliamentarians should be made aware of the fact that the OECD has not been allocated adequate resources to make significant progress in several areas of the 2001 Ministerial Mandate.  Member governments should be urged by parliamentarians </p>

<p align="justify">a. to renew the OECD Ministerial Mandate on Sustainable Development before it expires in 2004, and </p>

<p align="justify">b. to make a lasting commitment to the implementation of the OECD&#8217;s sustainable development agenda.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>II. Explanatory Memorandum by the Rapporteur</b></p>

<p align="justify"><b>Table of contents</b></p>

<p align="justify"><b>I.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Introduction</b></p>

<p><b>II. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The General World Economic Situation: Cause for Concern and </b></p>

    <ul><ul><p><b>for Action Long Overdue</b></p>

</ul></ul><p><b>III.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Resumed World Trade: Key to Resumed World Growth</b></p>

<p align="justify"><b>IV. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; OECD Outreach. The Challenges of Further Enlargements</b></p>

<p><b>V. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The OECD&#8217;s Sustainable Development Agenda</b></p>

  <ul><p align="justify"><b>a. Background</b></p>

  <p align="justify"><b>b. Defining Sustainable Development</b></p>

  <p align="justify"><b>c. Obstacles to the Implementation of Sustainable Development</b></p>

  <p align="justify"><b>d. The 2001 OECD Ministerial Mandate on Sustainable Development</b></p>

  <p align="justify"><b>e. Implementation of the 2001 Ministerial Mandate</b></p>

  <p align="justify"><b>f. Progress to Date (Spring 2003): A Review for Parliamentarians</b></p>

    <ul><p align="justify"><b>(i)&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Work done in the four priority areas identified by the OECD Secretariat in 2001</b></p>

    <p align="justify">1.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Report to the World Summit on Sustainable Development (WSSD)</p>

    <p align="justify">2. The indicators for Measuring Progress Across All Three Dimension of Sustainable Development</p>

    <p align="justify">3. Overcoming Obstacles to the Phasing Out of Environmentally Damaging Subsidies</p>

    <p align="justify">4. The Social Aspects of Sustainable Development</p>

    <p align="justify"><b>(ii) &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Other work done on issues related to sustainable development</b></p>

    <p align="justify"><b>(iii) &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Assessing the impact of the sustainable development agenda on the OECD&#8217;s economic analysis and reporting</b></p>

  </ul><p align="justify"><b>g. Progress in the OECD Area and Beyond: Critical Issues</b></p>

  <p align="justify"><b>h. Conclusions</b></p>

    <ul><p align="justify"><b>(i)&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Progress in the Implementation of the OECD&#8217;s Sustainable Development Agenda</b></p>

  </ul><p align="justify"><b>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;(ii)&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Concluding Remarks</b></p>

  <p align="justify"><i>&#8220;Fifteen years ago, many believed that environmental protection could be bought only at the expense of slower economic growth. Today, we know that at the macro level that is not true. Beyond that, we also know from our work on urban decline, development assistance, and other fields, that economic development is often not sustainable in a dirty environment or on a badly degraded resource base.&#8221;</i></p>

          <ul><ul><ul><ul><p align="justify">Emile van Lennep, OECD Secretary-General, speaking at the 1984 International Conference on Environment and Economics at the OECD.<sup><a href="#P190_23965" name="P190_23966">3</a></sup></p>

</ul></ul></ul></ul></ul><p align="justify"><b>I. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Introduction </b></p>

<p align="justify">1.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The debate of the Enlarged Parliamentary Assembly on &#8220;The OECD and the World Economy&#8221; will be held in September 2003. The present draft report is based on the Rapporteur&#8217;s discussions with the OECD&#8217;s Secretary General, Mr. Donald Johnston, and his senior staff in March 2003. It also takes into account the OECD&#8217;s April 2003 Economic Outlook and reports published by the organisation. </p>

<p align="justify">2.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The report consists of two parts: the current economic situation and prospects for the near and medium future; and second, given the growing importance of environmental sustainability and social development to the long-term health of the global economy, the very important OECD sustainable development agenda, as launched by the organisation&#8217;s 2001 Ministerial Mandate.</p>

<p><b>II. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The General World Economic Situation: Cause for Concern and for Action Long Overdue</b></p>

<p align="justify">3.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The OECD&#8217;s reading of the current world economic situation - as it came out in the Rapporteur&#8217;s conversations with its officials and in the &#8220;OECD Economic Outlook&#8221; published in June 2003 - is far from optimistic, and yet it holds out hope for the future if the, in its view correct measures are implemented.  The OECD calls economic growth in its member countries over the past few months &#8220;disappointing&#8221;. In the United States, the long-awaited economic recovery has not yet truly taken hold. In the eurozone, that is, the twelve European Union countries that share a common currency, reality has not lived up to even those successively reduced forecasts that were presented over the past few months. </p>

<p align="justify">4.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Adding to the woes of Euroland has been the pronounced strengthening of the euro vis-à-vis the dollar and many other currencies. Thus, by May 2003 it was approaching the $1.20 mark, that is, going beyond the exchange rate prevailing at the time of its launch in January 1999. (It has since come down somewhat, to around $1.12 in September 2003.) While this was likely to reduce the huge US current account deficit, help American exports and thereby give the country&#8217;s economy renewed vigour, it also threatened to dash whatever hopes there were for a Euroland recovery by making exports from the area &#8211; which had kept it afloat during the preceding years of a weak euro - more expensive.     </p>

<p align="justify">5.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The OECD sees a whole series of geopolitical and psychological reasons for the current weakness of the economies in the OECD area. There was at least until recently apprehension over future oil prices, although these have more lately come down in the wake of the surprisingly swift conclusion of the war in Iraq. The fear of terrorism persists, nourished further by the recent attacks in Saudi Arabia and Chechnya, while the risk of new armed conflict, notably in the Middle East or over North Korea, remains. The OECD also points to a &#8220;loss of confidence in international governance&#8221;, which the Rapporteur understands as signifying both corporations tarnished by scandal and international institutions shown as divided such as the United Nations, NATO or the World Trade Organisation. Finally, the SARS epidemic has hurt economic development especially in economically dynamic China, and more generally in south-east Asia. Only thanks to the rapid intervention of one international institution not normally associated with economic development &#8211; the World Health Organisation &#8211; that particular threat seems to have been held at bay, at least for now.  </p>

<p align="justify">6.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; However, the OECD emphasises that these factors should not blind us to many additional reasons behind the current weak economic growth &#8211; reasons incumbent on individual countries.  The latter, the OECD feels, will have to find a way back to a greater economic dynamism.  One task will be to reduce the over-capacity in many sectors due to excessive investment undertaken in the recent boom years.  The legislative and financial cleanup after the long series of recent corporate scandals has to be pursued, and a new business morality will again have to pervade our societies and corporations. Finally, there are numerous structural reform measures which many countries have put on the back burner but which now are becoming increasingly urgent. Prominent among them are pension reform, especially in the major Euroland economies, and increased flexibility in labour markets. </p>

<p align="justify">7.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Provided these problem areas are resolutely addressed, the OECD argues, prospects for resumed growth look considerably brighter, aided by positive underlying developments. US excess production capacity is already being reduced, paving the way for the world&#8217;s - unfortunately sole - &#8216;locomotive&#8217;.  New investment may quicken as a result, helped by the rebuilding of the currently low levels of stock in Europe. Finally, the financial and monetary conditions in the entire OECD area are considered favourable for economic recovery.  </p>

<p align="justify">8.<b>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Growth</b> in the OECD area is forecast at a modest 1.9% for 2003, up only marginally from 2002 (1.8%).  Among the major industrial countries, only the United States (2.5%), Great Britain (2.1%) and the Rapporteur&#8217;s own Canada (3.5%) will show growth going beyond the 2% level. However, also many smaller European countries - such as Greece, Ireland, Hungary, the Czech Republic and Slovakia as well as Australia and Korea - are expected to do better than the average.  By contrast, the euro area and Japan will have to content themselves with an estimated 1% growth in 2003.  The OECD foresees overall higher growth for 2004 in the OECD area, at 3%, with an even higher figure of 4% for the US.</p>

<p align="justify"> </p>

<p align="justify">9.<b>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Unemployment</b> will remain worryingly high for many countries. The OECD average is forecast at 7.2% in 2003, but at 8% for the European Union and all of 8.8% for the euro zone.  Especially Germany (8.3%), France (9.3%) and Italy (9.2%) will be seriously affected.  </p>

<p align="justify">10.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The only consolation is that slow growth will keep <b>inflation</b> down, at least temporarily.  In 2003, it is expected at 1.7% for the entire OECD area, and for a EMU member like Germany at no more than 0.8% - a figure that may cause some observers to fear a risk of deflation in that country.  Deflation is already a fact in Japan, where the price level is forecast to come down by 2.2% in 2003.</p>

<p align="justify">11.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Against the background of persistent <b>deflation</b> in Japan, the world&#8217;s second largest economy, and the prospect of a similar development in several other major OECD countries such as Germany or even the United States, the theme of inflation/deflation was naturally raised in the discussions.  The reasons for the fear of deflation are several: the war in Iraq with its uncertain aftermath; the many other geopolitical risks, including terrorism; the SARS epidemic; and the resulting reluctance of consumers to buy and producers to produce.</p>

<p align="justify">12.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; However, the OECD is not so sure about writing off inflation just yet. It can rise anew, it argues, as a result of the considerable budget deficits registered in many countries that may be accompanied by a greater preparedness to support the economy via less strict fiscal policies.  Furthermore, monetary policies are relatively permissive, with many people calling for even lower interest rates especially in Euroland.</p>

<p align="justify">13.<b>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The OECD in this situation suggests at two-pronged strategy:</b> immediate <b>stimulation of economic growth</b> on the one hand, and <b>structural reform</b> on the other. Regarding the first, the room for fiscal stimulation is limited, as the OECD-wide budgetary deficit will for both cyclical and structural reasons reach 3.5% of GDP this year.  Measures are, rather, sought in the realm of monetary policy.  The OECD considers the monetary conditions in the United States, with its historically low Federal Reserve policy-setting rate, to be well tuned to the expected economic recovery.  For the euro area, by contrast, the OECD believes that a considerable lowering of the European Central Bank policy-setting rate is needed, especially since inflation in the euro area is expected to be limited, not least as a result of the currently much stronger euro.</p>

<p align="justify">14.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; These measures, however justified to get economies going again in the short term, are not enough. They must be accompanied by a new commitment to structural reform on the part of especially those OECD countries &#8211; such as in parts of the EMU zone and in Japan, where economies are particularly listless.  Only through fundamental reforms in the markets for labour, services, goods and capital as well as in pensions can the growth potential, dynamism and shock resistance of these economies be re-established.</p>

<p align="justify">15.  <b>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Tax cuts and governability: </b>The United States Congress in May 2003 approved a tax cut of $ 330 billion (supplemented by some $ 20 billion in assistance to struggling states in the Union). This comes on top of an earlier, 10-year tax cut project enacted in 2001 and must be seen against an expected US budget deficit for 2003 of $ 400 billion, down from a healthy budget surplus as late as 2001. The two tax cuts are forecast by some in the United States to add well over $ 2 trillion in deficits by 2013, this at a time when the country is spending unprecedented amounts on its military, including on the start of a hugely expensive Missile Defence System (MDS). </p>

<p align="justify">16.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The question is whether the US Administration &#8211; or any government facing similar deficits such as Japan or some countries in Europe &#8211; can be expected to be able to govern effectively if such debt circumstances were to come true, or whether they will gradually lose manoeuvrability as deficits mount and more and more of national resources will be paid just to mortgage them.</p>

<p align="justify">17.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Rapporteur would wish the OECD to consider this issue, namely how, and under what circumstances, tax cuts may indeed revive a national economy, such as happened under President Reagan in the US and Margaret Thatcher in Great Britain and such as it is now tried e.g. in France in apparent defiance of the EMU&#8217;s Stability and Growth pact; and conversely, under what circumstances they can be expected to lead to increasing government paralysis.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>Have prospects improved more recently?</b></p>

<p align="justify">18.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The summer of 2003 may have seen a moderate improvement in the economic situation in the OECD area, and the Rapporteur wishes to refer to it since it was hypothesised by no other than the OECD&#8217;s Head Economist Jean-Philippe Cotis in a statement in early September. (The present report formally builds on the June 2003 OECD Economic Outlook.)  </p>

<p align="justify">19.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Thus, Mr Cotis predicted real growth in the United States of around 2.5% for 2003 and over 2% for Japan, while the forecast for the euro region remained more modest, at around 0.5%.  If prospects in the eurozone do not improve, the OECD does not exclude a further reduction in the ECB policy setting interest rate, said Mr Cotis, especially since core inflation has now sunk to considerably less than 2% as a result of high unemployment and the gap between potential and actual output. The OECD furthermore expresses concern over the rising budget deficits in several Eurozone countries and recommends remedial action as soon as possible, and at any rate by the time any improvement takes place, such as in 2004. </p>

<p align="justify">20.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The US recovery now expected comes at a price, however.  The budget deficit foreseen for 2004 is close to $500 billion even before the cost of the war in Iraq is included, with the latter estimated at around $150 billion for 2004.  The cost of the military occupation alone is estimated at about $4 billion a month, to which should be added the cost of operating the nascent Iraqi civilian government, projected at $20 billion for 2004.  </p>

<p align="justify">21.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Nor is any significant reduction in US unemployment to be expected.  It still remains at somewhat above 6%.  With the United States continuing its role as the world&#8217;s sole economic locomotive, this is not surprising.  Added US growth seems to lead predominantly to higher imports from the rest of the world, rather than to any markedly improved domestic employment situation.  Indeed, the United States at the present time needs, and indeed still receives, over $2 billion in international capital inflow per day, much of it in government bonds, so that it could be argued that it is the international community which largely defrays the cost of the occupation of Iraq.</p>

<p align="justify">22.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The US budget deficit for the 2003 budgetary year ending 30 September is expected at $450 billion, compared to an estimate in February 2003 of &#8216;only&#8217; $307 billion.  Three factors are generally held to explain this high figure.  There is firstly the war in Iraq and the cost of the occupation, believed to account for about $42 billion in the 2003 budgetary year.  Secondly, the federal government has in 2003 participated in the compensation to old age pensioners for their expenditure on medicaments.  Finally, the various tax cuts introduced by the Bush administration this year have lowered tax income by $30 billion. </p>

<p align="justify">23.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Additionally, tax income has remained far behind expectations.  Over the last three years they have been steadily sinking - a development last observed during the 1930s depression.  All hopes are now directed at the last few months of 2003, when economic recovery may result in higher employment and therefore more tax income.</p>

<p align="justify">24.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It remains that the expected 2004 budget deficit at somewhere close $500 billion will be the highest in the country&#8217;s history.  This development is all the more remarkable as the country enjoyed a budget surplus of $236 billion in 2000 and $127 billion in 2001 (the highest budget deficit so far was in 1992, at $290 billion).  The only consolation is that the deficit in 2004 will &#8216;only&#8217; be around 4.6%, as opposed to 6% during the 1980&#8217;s, due to the rise in GDP, the basis of comparison, in the intervening period.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>III. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Resumed World Trade: Key to Resumed World Growth. The WTO setback at Cancun</b></p>

<p><b>  </b></p>

<p align="justify">25.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Rapporteur also raised the future of world trade with the OECD officials, in view of the recent slowdown both in world trade as such (a historically low 3.6% increase in 2002) and in the negotiations for the so-called Doha Development Agenda of the World Trade Organisation. The goal is to conclude the Doha Development Agenda by the end of 2004.</p>

<p align="justify"><b> </b></p>

<p align="justify">26.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Doha was also a major theme at the OECD Ministerial Council held in Paris in early May 2003. The OECD is optimistic that the political frictions between major OECD countries caused by the Iraq conflict can soon be overcome and kept from spilling over into the trade arena, and that countries will realise the &#8216;make-or-break&#8217; significance importance of Cancún and Doha for the international trading system of decades to come.  </p>

<p align="justify">27.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It is particularly difficult to fight protectionism and proceed to more open trade at a time when several major countries or regions are experiencing slow growth.  Difficulties are particularly noticeable in agriculture, also as regards exports from developing to developed countries.  Yet few other measures could so help developing countries to grow economically as freer exports of agricultural commodities to what are often absurdly protected markets for such products of richer countries.  Furthermore, it is high time that custom duties be finally eliminated on industrial goods, nearly half a century after the first GATT negotiation Round in the 1960s.</p>

<p align="justify">28.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Agriculture is already at serious variance with the WTO multi-lateral system and progress on textiles has been stalled for so many years that major liberalisation is now long overdue.  The OECD is vital to the WTO process, firstly because most important WTO players are also members of the OECD, and secondly because these countries use the OECD as an informal negotiation forum in order to reach basic understanding on critical issues up for WTO negotiations or on &#8216;new&#8217; - not yet &#8220;stand pointed&#8221; - subjects that may ultimately enter the WTO agenda, such as cyber security, privacy and consumer protection.</p>

<p align="justify">29.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Various OECD officials, and ministers at the OECD Ministerial Meeting in May 2003 pointed to the growing divergence in growth rates within the OECD area and called for stronger cooperation in economic and trade policies as a means to increase growth overall and thereby reduce the divergence.  Economic growth comes about not primarily through monetary and financial policies, it was stressed, but through longer-term measures such as structural reform, increased productivity, trade liberalisation and better corporate governance.  </p>

<p align="justify">30.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Success on the Doha Development Agenda is all the more needed since any failure would lead to a further weakening of an international trading system already eroded by the growing number of regional trading blocs and bilateral agreements between countries.  Bilateralism means not only increased room for discrimination against others, but also the fragmentation of a GATT-WTO system of universal rules built up over decades and the loss of the economic benefits gained via open trade for as long.  If such trends continue, the WTO risks becoming a body concerned more with dispute settlement than with rule-making and trade opening.  </p>

<p align="justify">&nbsp;</p>

<p align="justify">31.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The inability of the WTO Ministerial Conference in Cancun, Mexico, in September 2003 to reach agreement on a declaration on the way forward for the Doha Development Agenda is of course a major disappointment, even though it should not be perceived as necessarily dooming the process;. for there will now be time for all sides &#8211; notably the industrialised countries and the G-21+ group of developing countries led by India and Brazil &#8211; to ponder the reasons for the setback and, the Rapporteur hopes, to approach the forthcoming negotiations at WTO headquarters in Geneva in a spirit of greater compromise than that shown in Cancun.</p>

<p align="justify">&nbsp;</p>

<p align="justify">32.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The fundamental reason for the collapse of the Cancun talks is commonly held to be the refusal of the G-21+ group to include the so-called Singapore themes &#8211; guidelines for a global investment regime, transparency in public procurement, the protection of intellectual property and others &#8211; against the agreement from the EU and the US in particular to liberalise agricultural trade, in a package deal where all sides would have to make compromises.&nbsp; The OECD countries, especially the United States and the EU, were highly critical of what they perceived as an unbending negotiation stance on the part of the G-21+ group.&nbsp; The latter for their part claimed that, although the failure to reach agreement was regrettable, the group had now arisen as a worthy partner to the industrialised countries in the WTO set-up, and one which the latter would henceforth have to take more seriously.&nbsp; Finally, the demonstrators against globalisation manifesting outside the Cancun negotiating premises were jubilant, as they considered no agreement to be preferable to what they feared would have been an unjust one.</p>

<p align="justify">&nbsp;</p>

<p align="justify">33.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Rapporteur by contrast believes that all efforts must now be directed at finding a compromise solution capable of instilling new life into the flagging Doha Development Agenda process, in order to avoid pessimism to gain ground and thereby negatively affect future trade and investment.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>The World Health Organisation as the saviour of the world economy? </b></p>

<p align="justify">34.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It is not often that the Enlarged Assembly refers to the World Health Organisation in its annual reports on &#8220;OECD and the World Economy&#8221;.  However, the WHO&#8217;s successful curbing of the SARS epidemic merits praise.   As soon as the first cases appeared and the contagiousness of the disease had become clear, the WHO - no doubt building on the experience of AIDS in the preceding decades and on its Emerging Disease Programme - had mobilised scientists, laboratories and public health authorities around the world, leading to full identification of the SARS virus only a few weeks into the epidemic.  (In the case of AIDS, two years were needed).  </p>

<p align="justify">35.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The WHO immediately recommended travel restrictions to affected regions, such as Hong Kong, Beijing and Toronto in the Rapporteur&#8217;s own country, Canada.  Also, radical measures were taken to isolate those infected and to submit suspected cases to quarantine.  This had disastrous economic consequences for the regions in question, in the form of halted tourism and business trips.  However, one can easily imagine the cost to the world economy, apart from the human tragedy that would have resulted, if no measures had been taken.  The WHO therefore deserves our full respect and we must be sure to equip it with sufficient resources to stave off any future health threats of the SARS kind.  It is also remarkable that the world was able to come together so quickly and without ideological or nationalist hang-ups to face the epidemic.  It shows that the world may well be profoundly divided politically but profoundly united when it comes to mankind&#8217;s survival. The medical world seems to be far ahead of us politicians and we should take them as examples.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>IV.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; OECD Outreach. The Challenges of Further Enlargements.  </b></p>

<p align="justify">36.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The OECD today has 30 member countries &#8211; the last to join being Slovakia in 2000.  Of the ten countries foreseen to join the European Union in 2004, four are members of the OECD (the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland and Slovakia), while six are not (Cyprus, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta and Slovenia).  Naturally enough, the latter group desire early OECD membership and argue that there should be a virtual &#8216;automaticity&#8217; between joining the EU and the OECD.  </p>

<p align="justify">37.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; However, some larger European OECD members as well as some non-European countries are concerned that enlargement may proceed too quickly. While they have nothing <i>per se</i> against new, worthy members, they believe that inner OECD reform - both in the organisational set-up and in the decision making procedures &#8211; is necessary beforehand. The May 2003 OECD Ministerial at any rate committed itself to deciding in a year&#8217;s time on the principles that should guide further enlargement and the inner reform that will accompany it.  </p>

<p align="justify">38.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; For one thing, the organisation&#8217;s rule of consensus will be increasingly difficult to maintain as a large number of predominantly smaller European countries join.  Furthermore, the non-Europeans worry about an even greater European &#8216;tilt&#8217; in the organisation&#8217;s membership and hence emphases, and this at a time when they feel that the OECD needs to focus more than ever on global issues. Indeed, some 70 non-member countries across the world are involved one way or the other in the organisations multiple activities.</p>

<p><b>V. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The OECD&#8217;s Sustainable Development Agenda</b></p>

  <ul><p align="justify"><i>&#8220;The OECD membership must accept the lead responsibility to address the challenges of sustainable development of the planet, not just of their own needs within their own respective societies.  This means a concerted effort to preserve and where necessary rebuild the platform upon which all rests, namely, as the Bruntland report said, the soil, water, air and living things.&#8221;  </i></p>

          <ul><ul><ul><ul><p align="justify">Donald Johnston, OECD Secretary-General,</p>

          <p align="justify">speaking at an OECD-Side event at the World Summit on Sustainable Development in Johannesburg, 3 September 2002.</p>

</ul></ul></ul></ul></ul><p align="justify"><b>a.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Background</b></p>

<p align="justify">39.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Having covered the economic developments, it is most desirable for parliamentarians to be briefed about the crucial overarching theme of sustainable development, one of the OECD&#8217;s major pillars.</p>

<p align="justify">40.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; When the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe adopted the Brundtland Commission&#8217;s definition of sustainable development<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P300_47430" name="P300_47431">1</a></sup> shortly after the Commission had published its report &#8220;Our Common Future,&#8221; it adopted an integrated approach as the way to implement it, which sees protecting the environment, promoting human and social development and enhancing economic growth as inseparable dimensions of development.  In this approach, economic analysis and policy-making cannot be done in isolation from the impact of economic development on people and the environment; nor can economic development be understood without recognition of its social and ecological underpinnings. </p>

<p align="justify">41.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Since then, the Assembly has repeatedly stressed the importance of sustainable development and the need to adopt an integrated approach.  It has expressed its strong support for the OECD&#8217;s sustainable development agenda (Resolution 1259), and it has adopted some provocative forward-looking reports on sustainable development goals and on reforms to key multilateral institutions for governing the global economy [noting especially the following by the Assembly&#8217;s Committee on the Environment and Agriculture &#8211; &#8220;World Summit on Sustainable Development:  Ten Years After Rio&#8221; (adopted June 2002); &#8220;Follow-Up to the World Summit on Sustainable Development&#8221; (adopted January 2003); &#8220;Globalisation and Sustainable Development&#8221; (adopted January 2003) &#8211; and by the Committee on Economic Affairs and Development:  &#8220;Managing Globalisation:  The Role of the World Trade Organisation in the World Economy&#8221; (January 2002); &#8220;The International Monetary Fund and the World Bank:  Challenges Ahead&#8221; (adopted June 2002).]  The analysis in these reports needs to be brought to bear as well in the Assembly&#8217;s Economic Affairs and Development Committee&#8217;s approach to the OECD.  <b>The Enlarged Assembly should continue to encourage more innovative and critical thinking from a sustainable development perspective.  Parliamentarians can also help in their respective parliaments to strengthen the political will needed to tackle sustainable development issues, especially when difficult choices are involved or conflicts arise.</b></p>

<p align="justify">42. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; OECD governments have in their 2001 ministerial communiqué made a major political commitment to the full integration<b> </b>of sustainable development objectives into their national and international policies.  This means that <b>OECD governments are politically committed to integrate environmental and social objectives into their economic decisions.</b>  Not to balance them, but to integrate them into the heart of economic decision-making at all levels of authority and action from the local to the global.</p>

<p align="justify">43.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Except for rhetoric, the implementation of the sustainable development agenda has faced major obstacles.  These include pandemics, conflicts over natural resources, wars and military adventures, environmental degradation, climate change and other events which threaten to erode the very institutions and decision-making processes needed to address the urgent challenges of increasing poverty and disparities between rich and poor people and regions.  The spread of SARS, with its severe impact on some regions and economic sectors, is only another example.  </p>

<p align="justify">44.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The successful implementation of the sustainable development agenda envisioned by the OECD, the United Nations and others, depends on far-reaching changes in the way policy-development and analysis takes place in member governments as well as inside the OECD.  We have to ensure that our governments adopt the technique of horizontal integration of policy analysis and development across all branches of government.  The same can be said of OECD organisational units.  Equally urgent is the necessity of shifting our conceptual approach from the conventional &#8220;economic&#8221; policy to the sustainable development economy.</p>

<p align="justify">45.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The OECD, with its impressive record and research capabilities, can play an important and influential role in moving forward the global sustainable development agenda and it is already attempting to do so, by identifying best practices among countries, devising comparative performance indicators, and providing detailed guidance on the application of sustainable development criteria to various policy sectors, particularly those that often have large environmental impacts.  But political will and leadership at the national, regional and global level needs to be mobilized to make these changes possible.  That is where we as parliamentarians come into the picture.  But first, the outlook.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>b.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Defining Sustainable Development</b></p>

<p align="justify">46.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The most widely used and accepted definition of sustainable development was put forward in 1987 by the Brundtland Commission in its report &#8220;Our Common Future&#8221;:</p>

    <ul><ul><p align="justify"><b>&#8220;Sustainable development is development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.&#8221;</b></p>

</ul></ul><p align="justify">47.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Despite widespread acceptance of this general definition, there are still fundamental disagreements &#8211; including in the OECD &#8211; about the meaning of sustainable development and about the implications of this definition for economic practices, policies and analysis.  </p>

<p align="justify">48.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; On one side of the argument is the view that development that is environmentally, socially but also economically sustainable requires the integration of environmental protection, human and social development, and economic growth in economic analysis and in decision- and policy-making.  We must ensure that economic growth does not reduce the natural capital and does not threaten the natural and social foundations of human existence.  In other words, <b>the &#8220;integrated&#8221; approach to sustainable development argues that economic analysis and policy-making cannot be done in isolation from the impact of economic development on people and the environment; nor can economic development be of lasting value without recognition of the social and ecological dimensions. </b></p>

<p align="justify">49.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; On the other side of the argument is the position held by many in the business community and shared by some economists that sustainable development must be seen as a balance between the economy and the environment.  <b>The &#8220;balance&#8221; approach locates the economy as an entity separate from the environment and from social values.  The result is that economic growth and efficiency goals are more often than not given precedence over social development and the protection of the environment</b>, especially during an economic downturn.</p>

<p align="justify">50. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Current thinking presumes we are dealing with two systems.  In fact, we are dealing with one system.  They are intertwined.</p>

<p align="justify">51.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; An important part of the debate between the two sides relates to the inclusion and application of the <b>precautionary principle </b>or approach.  In essence, the precautionary principle means that if there is a body of evidence pointing to serious irreversible damage to human health or the environment, we should not wait for the smoking gun, but rather take preventive measures without waiting for full scientific certainty.  The precautionary principle has been enshrined in many international agreements, including the Second North Sea Declaration, the Framework Convention on Climate Change, The Maastricht Treaty of the European Union, the Helsinki Convention, the Biosafety Protocol, the Nine Principles of the United Nations&#8217; Global Compact, the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises, as well as the Canadian Environment Protection Act.  </p>

<p align="justify">52.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The precautionary principle is central to an integrated approach to sustainable development.  Those who favour a balance approach generally oppose the precautionary principle and argue that full scientific proof of serious damage to human health or the environment is needed before regulatory steps should be taken.</p>

<p align="justify">53.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; To summarize, the idea of integrating the economy with environment and social objectives is based on understanding the interdependence between the economy, the environment and social equity. When we damage the environment, we weaken the economy.  When we protect the environment, we strengthen the economy, improve social cohesion and enhance the quality of life. This is the genius of the Brundtland approach, which is supported by social and environmental NGOs, civil society, experts in the field, and by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe. When instead the environment and socio-economic goals are conceptually treated as separate entities, the result is long-term negative economic, environmental and social impacts. </p>

<p align="justify"><b>c.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Obstacles to the Implementation of Sustainable Development </b></p>

<p align="justify">54.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; There are a number of powerful, interrelated obstacles.</p>

<p align="justify">55.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; First among these are, as the OECD has pointed out, disagreements about the meaning of sustainable development and its implications for economic analysis, policy and practices,<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P339_56421" name="P339_56422">2</a></sup> discussed in the previous section. Disagreements on sustainable development exist, as they exist on economic development.  Yet, that does not mean analytical work cannot be pursued.</p>

<p align="justify">56.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Then we face the enormous continuing disparities in socio-economic conditions among rich and poor countries which pose &#8220;powerful obstacles to agreement on shared goals and to coordination of policy responses.&#8221;<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P342_56948" name="P342_56949">3</a></sup>  As an organisation representing the world&#8217;s richest countries, the OECD has a particular responsibility and role to play in the provision of international assistance for sustainable development.  The OECD is in the forefront of pursuing global economic reforms &#8211; for example, in trade and finance &#8211; that both benefit developing countries and promote sustainability.  But continuous parliamentary support is needed.</p>

<p align="justify">57.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Third, these diverging interpretations of the meaning and importance of sustainable development have resulted in the lack of progress towards needed changes in policy-making and implementation.  Here again, the absence of a conceptual shift in economic and development analysis is having a negative impact on the successful implementation of the sustainable development agenda.  This is most evident in the area of economic and fiscal policy, which have continued to operate largely unchanged in most countries.  The contribution appropriate policy changes, for example with regard to national taxation system, can make to achieving sustainable development goals by fundamentally altering the incentive structures of economic actors has not been understood so far in most quarters, but has been opposed by vested interests in maintaining incentives and subsidies.</p>

<p align="justify">58.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; A fourth major obstacle is the lack of sufficient political will and leadership among OECD governments, despite ministerial declarations.  Most member governments do not treat sustainable development as a priority, and most have yet to accept and act on the implications of the integrated approach they have formally adopted for example in the 2001 and 2002 Ministerial communiqués.  The lack of political will has manifested itself in a number of areas, including in the lack of reform of government organisation and structure in member states, the withdrawal of the United States from the ratification process of the Kyoto Protocol and the absence &#8211; so far &#8211;of key states (including Russia), and in the failure of the United Nations Commission on Sustainable Development to generate action at the national level. </p>

<p align="justify">59.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Fifth, while some OECD member states have been willing to allocate the necessary financial resources to the implementation of the sustainable development agenda, either at home or abroad, most have not done so, especially with regard to levels of Official Development Assistance (ODA).  In 2002 the 1969 Pearson target of 0.7 percent of gross national income was achieved by only five members of the OECD&#8217;s Development Assistance Committee (DAC) &#8211; Denmark (0.96), Norway (0.91), Netherlands (0.82), Luxembourg (0.78), and Sweden (0.74).  Seven DAC countries spent more than 0.40 percent of GNI.  And the total was a mere 0.23 percent for all 22 DAC members.  Total ODA from DAC countries was just under US $ 57 billion.  </p>

<p align="justify">60. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Yet, OECD countries find it possible to spend well over US$ 300 billion annually on agricultural subsidies. As OECD Secretary General Johnston has pointed out, these subsidies &quot;both damage the environment and impose a heavy toll on developing countries. ... they may cause annual welfare losses of almost $20 billion for developing countries, an amount equivalent to about 40% of the annual ODA of OECD countries.&quot; Some governments have also continued to subsidize environmentally harmful economic activities in other sectors (including fisheries and energy). Such subsidies are economically harmful and trade distorting as well. They destroy markets for agriculture and other products produced in developing countries. <b>At the same time, the social safety net needed to compensate and protect people from the short-term affects of policy changes aimed at achieving sustainable economic development has been cut back considerably.  </b></p>

<p align="justify">61.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Sixth, the OECD&#8217;s sustainable development agenda has been similarly affected by underfunding, which has forced the Secretariat to limit or delay work on many parts of the agenda (see section 5. Progress to Date).</p>

<p align="justify">62.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Seventh, international economic institutions that help governing the world economy &#8211; in particular the IMF, the World Bank and the WTO &#8211; implement rules and promote policies that for the most part do not reflect changed realities of the world economy and the sustainable development agenda agreed to in the framework of the United Nations and the OECD.  As the Enlarged Assembly has pointed out, reform is urgently needed (see for example<a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc= Resolution 1288"> Resolution 1288</a>).</p>

<p align="justify">63.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Eighth, despite substantial efforts on the part of the OECD, the United Nations, the International Energy Agency, the European Environment Agency, and other governmental and non-governmental organisations, we still do not have international agreement on indicators needed to measure progress in important areas of each of the three pillars of sustainable development.  Technical issues continue to be a problem in some areas (especially were quantitative measurement is difficult), but the main obstacle here appears to be the lack of political agreement on the meaning of each dimension and the ways in which progress in each dimension should be assessed individually and in relation to the other pillars.</p>

<p align="justify">64.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Finally, as noted in the introduction, current developments often overshadow the sustainable development agenda and distract the political attention of key countries and the public from the longer-term &#8211; and often more difficult &#8211; policy-changes required to achieve sustainability.  </p>

<p align="justify"><b>d.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The 2001 OECD Ministerial Mandate on Sustainable Development&nbsp;</b></p>

<p align="justify">65.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Under the leadership of Secretary-General Donald Johnston, the OECD Ministerial Council initiated a three-year project on sustainable development in 1998, which recognized sustainable development as an overarching goal and resulted in ministers of economics, finance and the environment meeting for the first time in May 2001.  Ministers jointly set out an important mandate for the OECD to guide member governments in implementing sustainable development policies.  This is an excerpt from the Ministers&#8217; declaration:</p>

<p align="justify">66. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; &#8220;Su<b>stainable development is an overarching goal of OECD governments and the OECD. Th</b>e three dimensions of sustainable development -- enhancing economic growth, promoting human and social development, and protecting the environment -- are interdependent objectives requiring concerted international action by OECD, transition and developing countries, based on their common and differentiated responsibilities, to deliver essential public goods of a global nature. We recognise that OECD countries bear a special responsibility for leadership on sustainable development worldwide, historically and because of the weight they continue to have in the global economy and environment. We recognise the urgency of the challenge and the gap between policy design and implementation. We are committed to closing this gap and will work energetically with countries outside the OECD's membership to achieve our joint sustainable development goals. &#8230; We will ensure that sustainable development strategies are put in place in all our member countries by the time of the [2002 Johannesburg] World Summit [on Sustainable Development].&#8221; It<b> is hoped the very laudable initiative of bringing together ministers of economics, finance and the environment, when repeated in future, will be enlarged to include health ministers.67</b></p>

<p align="justify">67.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It should be noted that the OECD had prepared a report entitled <i>Policies to Enhance Sustainable Development</i>.  The 2001 Ministerial Mandate endorsed the policy recommendations included in that report and stressed the need to respond to climate change as &#8220;the most urgent global environmental challenge.&#8221;  With regard to the management of natural resources it noted that &#8220;the market prices of natural resources must reflect the full environmental and social costs and benefits of economic activity.&#8221;  Specifically, Ministers called on the OECD to assist member governments by:</p>

  <ul><p align="justify">&#8226; developing agreed indicators that measure progress across all three dimensions of sustainable development, including decoupling of economic growth from environmental degradation, with a view to incorporating these into OECD&#8217;s economic, social and environmental peer review processes, and filling gaps in the statistical and scientific data;</p>

  <p align="justify">&#8226; identifying how obstacles to policy reforms, in particular to the better use of market-based instruments, and to the reduction of environmentally harmful subsidies, can be overcome; and deepening its analytical work on these instruments;</p>

  <p align="justify">&#8226; analysing further the social aspects of sustainable development, including work on human and social capital, as well as their interaction with their economic and environmental dimensions;</p>

  <p align="justify">&#8226; providing guidance for achieving improved economic, environmental and social policy coherence and integration.<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P376_65929" name="P376_65930">4</a></sup></p>

  <p align="justify">With regard to the last point, it should be noted that market prices should reflect full economic costs, let alone social and environmental costs.</p>

</ul><p align="justify">68.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Enlarged Assembly welcomed the OECD&#8217;s Ministerial Mandate on Sustainable Development in its 2001 report on &#8220;The OECD and the World Economy&#8221; and expressed its strong support for the OECD&#8217;s sustainable development agenda, as well as for the OECD&#8217;s <i>Environmental Strategy for the 21<sup>st</sup> Century</i>, adopted by Ministers in May 2001 (Resolution 1259).</p>

<p align="justify"><b>e.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Implementation of the 2001 Ministerial Mandate</b></p>

<p align="justify">69.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In implementing the 2001 Ministerial Mandate, the OECD emphasized the need for a focused policy agenda and the development of concrete policy measures to make progress towards the goal of moving the OECD and its member countries towards an integrated approach to sustainable development.  In light of significant resource constraints and the tight timetable envisioned in the Mandate &#8211; the OECD is to report back to the Ministerial Council in 2004 &#8211; the Secretariat gave priority to the following areas:</p>

  <ul><p align="justify">&#8226; the preparation of a report to last year&#8217;s UN World Summit on Sustainable Development (WSSD) in Johannesburg;</p>

  <p align="justify">&#8226; the development of indicators for use in OECD peer reviews; </p>

  <p align="justify">&#8226; overcoming obstacles to the phasing out of environmentally damaging subsidies; and </p>

  <p align="justify">&#8226; the social aspects of sustainable development.<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P393_67572" name="P393_67573">5</a></sup></p>

</ul><p align="justify"><b>f.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Progress to Date (Spring 2003): A Review for Parliamentarians</b></p>

<p align="justify">70.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Work is under way on most of these issues, but remains to be completed.  As mentioned, <b>resource constraints have made it difficult for the OECD to make significant progress in many areas of the 2001 Ministerial Mandate, even in the four priority areas</b>:  &#8220;While the work on indicators and the WSSD have been fully funded, work on the parts of the mandate has been scaled back or delayed due to resource constraints.&#8221;<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P399_68343" name="P399_68344">6</a></sup>  This is a serious observation which requires parliamentary attention.</p>

<p align="justify">71.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; For the most part, &#8220;the activities undertaken in response to the Ministerial mandate span a three-year period, and lessons learnt will be brought together in a final report to ministers in 2004.&#8221;  This will include a synthesis of the sections of OECD <i>Economic Surveys </i>reviewing country policies for sustainable development, which have been part of the OECD peer Reviews since September 2001.  The Secretariat plans to have drafted sustainable development sections for all 30 Member countries by September 2003.<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P402_69040" name="P402_69041">7</a></sup></p>

<p align="justify">72.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Progress in implementing the OECD&#8217;s sustainable development agenda will be assessed in three ways here: (i) by examining work done in the four priority areas identified by the Secretariat in 2001; (ii) by examining work done more generally on issues related to sustainable development; and (iii) by assessing the impact, if any, of the sustainable development agenda on the OECD&#8217;s economic analysis and reporting.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>(i) &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Work done in the four priority areas identified by the OECD Secretariat in 2001:</b></p>

<p align="justify">(1) &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Report to the World Summit on Sustainable Development (WSSD)</p>

<p align="justify">73.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; This report entitled <i>Working Together Towards Sustainable Development - The OECD Experience</i> argues that, over the past decade, there has been &#8220;progress in each of the three dimensions of sustainable development,&#8221; and OECD countries have achieved some &#8220;reductions in selected environmental pressures&#8221; and &#8220;improved the quality of life for most of their citizens.&#8221;  But it warns that actions taken so far &#8220;fall far short of what is needed.&#8221;  The report states that <b>&#8220;Concrete policies and co-operative partnerships are needed to eradicate poverty, to change unsustainable consumption and production patterns, and to better manage the natural resources and ecosystems which support economic and social development.&#8221;</b><sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P411_70534" name="P411_70535">8</a></sup></p>

    <ul><ul><p align="justify">(2) &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Indicators for Measuring Progress Across All Three Dimensions of Sustainable Development</p>

</ul></ul><p align="justify">74.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The intent is to incorporate the assessment of sustainable development policies into the OECD&#8217;s peer review process.  In its most recent progress report (April 2003), the OECD explains the process of developing indicators:</p>

<p align="justify">&#8220;Work on this part of the mandate is proceeding in three stages.  The first consisted of identifying a set of concrete policy issues and developing a framework for their analysis in individual OECD country reviews.<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P418_72216" name="P418_72217">9</a></sup>  This step was largely completed [in April 2002] with an identification of a list of indicators covering seven themes&#8221;: greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution, water pollution, natural resources, waste management, living standards in developing countries, and sustainable retirement incomes.  The second phase began in 2002 and &#8220;consists of analysing three of the seven themes for each OECD country.  In the final stage of the project, a synthesis paper will draw together the lessons learned from individual reviews in 2004.&#8221;<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P419_72866" name="P419_72867">10</a></sup></p>

<p align="justify">&#8220;Several of the indicators proposed for use in OECD peer reviews are the result of efforts to compile indicators measuring the <i>decoupling </i>of environmental pressures from economic growth.&#8221;  An OECD report entitled <i>Indicators to Measure Decoupling of Environmental Pressure from Economic Growth</i> explores this concept.  It shows that some progress has been made in OECD countries with regard to slowing down increases in, stabilizing or reducing environmental pressures while the economy is growing.  But there is no decoupling for some environmental pressures, and much more can be done to ensure that economic growth does not lead to further environmental degradation.<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P422_73646" name="P422_73647">11</a></sup></p>

    <ul><ul><p align="justify">(3) Overcoming Obstacles to the Phasing Out of Environmentally Damaging</p>

    <p align="justify">Subsidies</p>

</ul></ul><p align="justify">75.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Parliamentarians should be made aware of the fact that the OECD has repeatedly pointed out that current tax systems and government subsidies are major obstacles to achieving sustainable development goals.<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P428_74123" name="P428_74124">12</a></sup>  Exemptions to new &#8220;green tax&#8221; systems targeted at changing producer and consumer behaviour all too often benefit &#8220;the most polluting and energy-intensive industries&#8221;; subsidies that support output levels make practices in sectors like agriculture and fisheries economically viable, which have been identified as severely damaging to the environment; and tax expenditures continue to promote  unsustainable economic practices.<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P429_75040" name="P429_75041">13</a></sup></p>

<p align="justify">76.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In its efforts to help member countries remove obstacles, the OECD has produced analytical work and suggested policy responses.  And in co-operation with the European Commission and the European Environment Agency (EEA), the OECD has developed a Database on Environmentally Related Taxes (http://www.oecd.org/env/tax-database), which monitors taxes and some types of fees in 41 countries, including all OECD and EU members and 11 European countries not currently part of either organisation.</p>

<p align="justify">77.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The OECD has done some important work in this area.  But its efforts have focussed largely on identifying obstacles to the introduction of environmental taxes and to the elimination of direct subsidies, while <b>work on tax expenditures and the more general role of the tax system in changing consumer and producer behaviour has lagged behind. </b>The fact that environmentally damaging subsidies are also economically harmful and trade distorting should also be emphasized to a greater extent.</p>

<p align="justify">(4) &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Social Aspects of Sustainable Development</p>

<p align="justify">78.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The OECD has recognized the importance of the social dimension of sustainable development.  The 2001 Ministerial Mandate selected it as one of the four priority areas.  Since then, the OECD has developed conceptual work, notably on the links between environmental and social conditions and on some of the broader social aspects of sustainable development.</p>

<p align="justify">79.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The OECD also examines the capacity of existing &#8211; mostly national-level &#8211; systems of governance and social protection to balance progress among the three dimensions of sustainable development and their ability to deal with the complex linkages between environmental and social changes in the context of an increasingly global economy.  Secretary-General Donald Johnston, for example, has argued that moving forward with the sustainable development agenda and with necessary policy measures, which may have adverse effects on individuals and groups, &#8220;requires addressing the concerns of the people and communities that stand to lose the most from the reforms.  This may require upgrading the capacity of the general social protection system to respond to new demands.&#8221;<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P442_77499" name="P442_77500">14</a></sup></p>

<p align="justify">80.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Mr. Johnston has also reiterated the OECD&#8217;s position that one of the main obstacles to sustainable development is the &#8220;huge disparities [that exist] between regions and countries with regard to development, [because they] make agreement on goals, principles and measures difficult.&#8221;  Social and economic development, in particular sustained reductions in poverty and raising living standard in developing countries, therefore become central objectives of the sustainable development agenda.  The OECD&#8217;s main actions in this area have been to promote increases in aid and investment flows to developing countries and the elimination of trade barriers in OECD countries to facilitate trade-led development.  All this explains why the organisation has been actively involved in moving the Doha Development Agenda forward.<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P445_78384" name="P445_78385">15</a></sup></p>

<p align="justify">81.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Beyond this, however, <b>the OECD has made little concrete progress in addressing the social aspects of sustainable development.  So far concrete policy analysis and proposals have focussed, for the most part, on the sustainability of pension systems in industrialized countries and on official development assistance.</b>  Important issues such as education and social cohesion have received little attention in discussions about sustainable development in the OECD.  All this may be due, as the OECD&#8217;s Deputy Secretary-General, Berglind Ásgeirsdóttir, told the Rapporteur, to the difficulty in reaching agreement of members countries&#8217; ministers on the meaning of the social pillar of sustainable development.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>(ii) &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Other work done on issues related to sustainable development:</b></p>

<p align="justify">82.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The OECD has done a substantial amount of work on sustainable development related issues, which is not directly tied to 2001 Ministerial Mandate.  This includes reporting and analytical work, notably the <i>OECD Environmental Outlook</i>, published for the first time in 2001, as well as numerous meetings of experts and working groups on issues ranging from climate change to sustainable household consumption.</p>

<p align="justify">83.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The OECD has also set up two bodies to support its work on sustainable development: the OECD Global Forum on Sustainable Development, which provides a policy dialogue between OECD and non-OECD countries on best practices for achieving sustainable development; and the Round Table on Sustainable Development, an independent body housed at the OECD, which &#8220;gathers ministers, heads of international organisations, NGOs and business representatives to address selected issues,&#8221; and triggers innovative and provocative analytical work using OECD data.<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P454_80131" name="P454_80132">16</a></sup></p>

<p align="justify"><b>(iii) &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Assessing the impact of the sustainable development agenda on the OECD&#8217;s economic analysis and reporting.</b></p>

<p align="justify">84.<b>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The OECD has formally adopted and advocated an integrated approach to sustainable development.</b>  It means protecting the environment, promoting human and social development, and enhancing economic growth as the three inseparable dimensions of development.  Consequently, economic analysis and policy-making cannot be carried out in isolation from the impact of economic development on social conditions and the environment; nor should economic development take place without recognition of social and ecological values. </p>

<p align="justify">85.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; This ministerial commitment in 2001 to the full integration<b> </b>of sustainable development objectives into their national and international policies has clear implications for policy analysis and development: it means that OECD governments are expected to integrate environmental and social objectives into their economic decisions.  <b>As to the OECD Secretariat, it is expected to integrate environmental and social objectives and considerations into economic analysis and policy development </b>&#8211; the largest part of the OECD&#8217;s work and organisation &#8211; and vice versa.  While the organisation has made considerable efforts to apply economic analysis to environmental and social policy, the extent to which the reverse is true is unclear. The OECD should be leading in analysing the environmental impact of economic policy, and vice versa.</p>

<p align="justify">86.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; At this point parliamentarians should be made aware of three OECD publications, the <i>Economic Outlook</i>, the <i>Economic Surveys</i>, and the <i>OECD Agenda for Growth</i>.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>The <i>Economic Outlook </i>(Preliminary Edition, April 2003)</b></p>

<p align="justify">87.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The <i>Economic Outlook </i>&#8220;puts forward its own &#8230; projections for output, employment, prices and current balances over the coming two years, based on a detailed review of each Member country &#8230; . Particular attention is paid to the policies that governments are adopting to solve [current] economic problems.&#8221;<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P470_82275" name="P470_82276">17</a></sup>  It is the OECD&#8217;s flagship publication.  Together with the more detailed country <i>Economic Surveys</i>, it exemplifies the organisation&#8217;s strengths in the area of economic analysis and policy development, and its role in shaping policy debates in member countries.  It is therefore particularly noteworthy &#8211; and surprising &#8211; that the <i>Economic Outlook </i>makes no mention of sustainable development and its linkages.  </p>

<p align="justify">88.<b>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The <i>Economic Outlook</i> offers a very narrow, classic, analysis of and projections for the world economy</b>.  The quantitative indicators employed (specifically real GDP, real total domestic demand, inflation, unemployment, current account balance, short-term interest rates, world trade) reflect <b>no recognition of the environmental and social underpinnings of economic developments </b>(including short-term growth) <b>or of the environmental and social consequences of economic growth</b>.  </p>

<p align="justify">89.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Yet, as the OECD itself has shown in other publications, alternative methods (including growth and development indicators) are needed and available.<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P475_83448" name="P475_83449">18</a></sup>  .  The OECD itself has carried out a significant amount of work on developing indicators to measure progress in the three dimensions of sustainable development.  In addition, the OECD has done important conceptual and analytical work on sustainable development, environmental issues and policy, and the social aspects of sustainable development.  But, as the following examples illustrate, the <i>Economic Outlook </i>remains aloof.</p>

<p align="justify">90. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The main indicator used in the <i>Outlook</i> to measure economic development is Gross Domestic Product (GDP).  GDP is an output measure that shows the sum of all market transactions in an economy in one year.  It is therefore an important indicator of economic growth.  Nevertheless, GDP does not account for the production of non-market goods; it treats all market transactions as equally beneficial; it does not include environmental and social costs of output growth; and it does not value those environmental resources (such as clean air and water or biodiversity) that are not traded in the market place either.  Therefore, while the GDP is an important indicator of economic activity that involves market goods and services (that is goods and services that have prices), it is less useful as an indicator to determine overall success in increasing welfare or achieving socially and environmentally sustainable economic growth and development.  </p>

<p align="justify">91.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; A modified version of GDP, or GDP in conjunction with other indicators that incorporate more of the goods and services that result in welfare improvements, particularly environmental amenities, could be used more effectively to help policy makers formulate policy.  An example of an alternative measures for national income accounting is an indicator called Net National Welfare (NNW).<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P480_85294" name="P480_85295">19</a></sup>  It incorporates the GDP and is defined as:</p>

    <ul><ul><p align="justify"><i>NNW = Total Output &#8211; Depreciation &#8211; Total Externality Costs</i></p>

</ul></ul><p align="justify"><i>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;= GDP + Nonmarket Output</i></p>

        <ul><ul><ul><ul><p align="justify"><i>- Depreciation of Natural Capital</i></p>

        <p align="justify"><i>- Depreciation of Created Capital (manmade capital)</i></p>

        <p align="justify"><i>- Pollution Abatement, Environmental Health and Clean-Up Costs</i></p>

        <p align="justify"><i>- Externality Costs</i></p>

</ul></ul></ul></ul><p align="justify">92. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;  It should be noted that the <i>Outlook</i> emphasizes the need for &#8220;prudent fiscal policies&#8221; and for &#8220;providing economic agents with a sense of long-term direction.&#8221;<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P490_85847" name="P490_85848">20</a></sup>  But <b>it remains silent on the role fiscal policy and tax systems play in structuring consumer and producer behaviour in relation to sustainable development issues.</b>  This blind spot is surprising considering the OECD&#8217;s work on environmentally harmful subsidies and on the potential role of the tax system in achieving sustainable development goals, none of which is acknowledged or incorporated into the analysis presented in the <i>Outlook</i>.  <b>The negative impact of tax expenditures, which encourage unsustainable economic practices, on the ability of governments to pursue &#8220;prudent fiscal policies&#8221; is also ignored.</b></p>

<p align="justify">The Country by Country <i>Economic Survey</i></p>

<p align="justify">93.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Its purpose is to assess OECD member governments&#8217; policies &#8211; in particular macro-economic and structural policies &#8211; in order to promote a &#8220;better understanding of the country&#8217;s economic situation and key challenges&#8221; and suggest policies to improve economic performance.<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P495_86819" name="P495_86820">21</a></sup>  </p>

<p align="justify">94.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Parliamentarians should note that, beginning in 2002, each <i>Economic Survey </i>has included a section on sustainable development, which examines progress made in some specific areas using agreed-upon performance indicators.  By September 2003, the Secretariat will have drafted sustainable development sections for all 30 Member countries.  A synthesis report will then be drafted based on the most recent <i>Economic Surveys</i> of all 30 Members and submitted to OECD Ministers in 2004 as part of the final report on the 2001 sustainable development Mandate.  </p>

<p align="justify">95.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Parliamentarians should note the remarkable fact that to date, performance indicators have been agreed upon in seven policy areas: reducing greenhouse gas emissions, air pollution and water pollution, moving towards sustainable use of renewable and non-renewable (sic) resources, reducing and improving waste management, improving living standards in developing countries, and ensuring sustainable retirement incomes.  For each country survey, three of these policy areas are chosen for progress review.<sup> <a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P500_88172" name="P500_88173">22</a></sup>  In the case of the <i>Economic Survey of Germany</i>, on which we focus here,<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P501_88353" name="P501_88354">23</a></sup> the examination covers policies put in place to reduce air pollution, waste management policies, and &#8220;policies that have been adopted or are required for fiscal sustainability in the long run without compromising the goal of income adequacy of older persons.  &#8230; The section also considers whether institutional arrangements are in place to integrate policy-making across the different elements of sustainable development.&#8221;<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P502_88925" name="P502_88926">24</a></sup>  The <i>Economic Survey</i> <i>of the United States </i>examined policies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and water pollution, and the sustainable use of renewable and non-renewable resources.  The topics for Finland were reducing greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, and moving towards sustainable use of renewable and non-renewable resources.</p>

<p align="justify">96.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It is worth noting that the sustainable development section in the <i>Economic Surveys of Germany</i> offers some very good analysis of policies in the three selected areas, employing performance indicators that allow for comparison with other countries.  The section includes comparative data on all OECD countries, and in using economic-efficiency and cost-benefit analysis to assess policies, it draws attention to some important aspects of environmental and social policy.  The section on sustainable development reflects a greater degree of integration of the three dimensions of sustainable development in analysis and policy-development than is the case with the <i>Economic Outlook</i>.  However, the thrust is very much in the direction of balancing social and environmental objectives against economic growth goals.  Overall, as the <i>Survey</i>&#8217;s authors point out, &#8220;the emphasis [of the sustainable development sections of  <i>Economic Surveys</i>] has been on the trade-offs that have to made between costs of achieving goals.&#8221;<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P505_90342" name="P505_90343">25</a></sup>  Thus, <b>the economy continues to be treated</b> <b>as an entity separate from the environment and from social and political development, </b>whereas they are linked. </p>

<p align="justify">97.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Other sections of the <i>Economic Survey of Germany </i>suggests that the 2001 Ministerial Mandate and the OECD&#8217;s formal commitment to an integrated approach to sustainable development has had little if any impact on the peer review process for economic policy and development.  Indeed, there is a noticeable tension between those parts of the <i>Survey</i> which make explicit reference to sustainable development and reiterate the OECD&#8217;s commitment to an integrated approach (pages 19-21 and 152-171) and the remainder of the <i>Survey</i> which makes virtually no mention of sustainable development.  This contrast is particularly striking where policy areas are discussed that have obvious relevance to sustainable development, such as fiscal policy, transport, infrastructure, and natural resources.</p>

<p align="justify">98.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Although a very useful section on sustainable development &#8211; limited to three specific policy areas &#8211; is included, <b>the <i>Economic Survey </i>reflects little of the integration of &#8220;policy-making across the different elements of sustainable development&#8221; in the OECD.  </b>Yet the organisation calls for such integration in the <i>Survey.</i>  The <i>Survey</i>&#8217;s economic analysis &#8211; one might add &#8211; appears virtually unconcerned by the recognition expressed in the sustainable development section that &#8220;there is growing concern that long-run sustainable development may be compromised unless OECD countries take measures to achieve balance between economic, environmental, and social outcomes,&#8221;<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P510_92093" name="P510_92094">26</a></sup> a recognition that reveals considerable conceptual ambivalence with respect to the meaning of sustainable development.</p>

<p align="justify">99.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Parliamentarians should note that the <i>Economic Surveys</i> are published by the Economic Development and Review Committee.  One must conclude that these shortcomings are not only the result of a lack of organisational integration within the OECD secretariat and an integrated analytical approach to economic and development analysis.   They seem to reflect a lack of political will to move the sustainable development agenda forward. Where there is no will, there is no way.</p>

<p align="justify">The OECD&#8217;s <i>Policy Agenda for Growth</i> (summary report, April 2003)</p>

<p align="justify">100.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In April 2003, the OECD released the results of a four year study on the sources of economic growth in the OECD (the OECD Growth Project) and differences between member countries:  &#8220;Today it is clear that these growth divergences are not only well entrenched, but also that policy differences are largely responsible.&#8221;<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P517_93131" name="P517_93132">27</a></sup>  The report highlights macroeconomic policies which &#8220;not only play a role in shaping the business cycle but &#8230; also impact the underlying trend of growth.&#8221;<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P518_93380" name="P518_93381">28</a></sup></p>

<p align="justify">101.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The recognition that policies shape &#8220;the underlying trend of growth&#8221; is encouraging provided it implies the possibility of developing a coherent policy strategy composed of economic, environmental, and social policies, with the aim of shifting current growth patterns away from an unsustainable model to a sustainable development path.  Strangely enough, however, this recognition is not made in this report.  Instead, <b>the OECD&#8217;s <i>Policy Agenda for Growth </i>is based on a narrow, one-dimensional interpretation of economic development, which excludes the social and ecological pillars and consequences of one-dimensional economic growth</b>.  The OECD&#8217;s <i>Policy Agenda for Growth</i> therefore does not point the way to a sustainable economic growth path.  In order to move towards a sustainable economic growth path the <i>Policy Agenda</i> would require the changes in the OECD&#8217;s structure and the organisation&#8217;s internal modus operandi outlined in the conclusion. </p>

<p align="justify"><b>g.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Progress in the OECD Area and Beyond: Critical Issues</b></p>

<p align="justify">102.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The state of the sustainable development agenda after last year&#8217;s WSSD in Johannesburg was aptly summarized in the Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly&#8217;s<a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc= Recommendation 1594"> Recommendation 1594</a> &#8220;Follow-Up to the World Summit on Sustainable Development&#8221; (January 2003):  </p>

<p align="justify">&#8220;In 1992 the United Nations Conference on Environment and Development held in Rio de Janeiro adopted the Rio Declaration, in which environmental protection and social and economic development are designated as essential for ensuring sustainable development. A programme of action, Agenda 21, was laid down in order to achieve this development.  Ten years later, the state of our planet is just as alarming and the results of the measures taken in Rio are disappointing. Deforestation and greenhouse gas emissions are increasing, access to water is still not secured to the majority, and the exhaustion of resources continues. The situation is scarcely better with regard to development: cases of inequality and utter destitution are on the increase. In addition, environmental problems and sustainable development are still nowhere near the top of our governments&#8217; policy action programmes.&#8221;</p>

<p align="justify">103.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; This observation is of key importance.  The Committee of Ministers has hopefully taken note of it.  In order to reinforce the Assembly&#8217;s message, it is worth highlighting some key areas of concern in the 2001 <i>OECD Environmental Outlook.</i><sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P529_95922" name="P529_95923">29</a></sup>  The purpose is to emphasize the urgent need to make significant progress in moving the world economy toward a sustainable development model.  The issues selected are identified as most pressing and assigned &#8220;red light signals&#8221; in the <i>Environmental Outlook</i>.<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P530_96421" name="P530_96422">30</a></sup>  There are also a number of other issues, where progress towards sustainability is insufficient.  They are designated as &#8220;yellow light signals.&#8221;  </p>

<p align="justify">104.<u>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Climate Change / Greenhouse Gas Emissions</u>:  &#8220;OECD countries contribute approximately 50% of emissions of greenhouse gases (CO<sub>2</sub>, CH<sub>4</sub> and N<sub>2</sub>O), but this share is expected to decline in the period to 2020.  <u>Emissions of greenhouse gases (GHG) in OECD countries increased by 4% in the 1990-1998 period</u>. The emissions grew most rapidly in North America and in the Asia-Pacific region, while emissions in Europe have decreased by almost 5%. GHG emissions are likely to increase substantially in the period to 2020.  Projections by the OECD show that total CO<sub>2</sub> emissions in OECD countries are likely to increase by about 33% from 1995 to 2020. This illustrates the challenge of achieving Kyoto Protocol targets, which could require OECD countries to reduce emissions by roughly 20% to 40% below Reference Scenario levels.  GHG emissions will lead to increases in global mean temperatures and a possible rise in sea levels. The climate is already changing, which in turn will almost certainly require adaptation measures. The most urgent policies needed to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions are: wide implementation of taxes on greenhouse gases; <u>reform of subsidies that contribute to climate change</u>;<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P533_98162" name="P533_98163">31</a></sup> promotion of alternative transport fuels, vehicles and modes, and renewable energy technologies; and introduction and effective implementation of domestic and international emission trading systems.&#8221; (page 157)<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P534_98425" name="P534_98426">32</a></sup></p>

<p align="justify">105.<u>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Motor Vehicle and Aviation Air Pollution Emissions</u>:  &#8220;Growth in the transport sector continues to be strong, with road transport (passenger and freight) and aviation showing the highest growth rates.  Motor vehicle kilometres travelled are projected to increase by 40% in OECD regions and by 86% worldwide to 2020. Over the same period, air travel is projected to triple worldwide.  Emissions from transport in OECD countries have been reduced for some major air pollutants, notably lead, carbon monoxide (CO), volatile organic compounds (VOC), and more recently for nitrogen oxides (NOx). At the same time, <u>emissions of greenhouse gases, in particular carbon dioxide (CO<sub>2</sub>), from transport have increased in OECD countries</u>.  Further reductions of 15% to 55% compared to present levels are expected for the above air pollutants for transport in OECD countries by 2020. However, CO<sub>2</sub> emissions from motor vehicles in OECD countries are projected to increase by approximately 44% from 1995 to 2020.  Emissions of nitrogen oxides, particulate matter and volatile organic compounds have not been reduced to the same degree [as emissions of sulphur oxides, carbon monoxide and lead], although reductions have been observed in some countries. This is primarily due to the strong growth in motor vehicle traffic, which has largely outweighed the efficiency gains from new technological development, and contributed to photochemical smog (tropospheric ozone), acid deposition and eutrophication.  Projected <u>worldwide increases in transport will have serious impacts on public health and the environment</u>. Issues causing the most concern are climate change, air pollution, noise and land use.&#8221; (pages 168, 183)</p>

<p align="justify">106.<u>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Effects of agricultural production on the environment</u>:  &#8220;Although existing evidence of the effects on environmental quality is partial and incomplete, <u>recent trends in agricultural development in OECD countries</u> &#8211; particularly the more intensive use and increased risks of agrochemicals, irrigation, and the use of larger and more powerful farm machinery &#8211; <u>appear to have had negative effects on the environment</u>. They have contributed to the higher energy intensity of agricultural production, pollution of ground and surface water by pesticides and fertilizers, soil erosion in some regions, and to increased resistance of pests to chemical control.&#8221; (page 89)</p>

<p align="justify">107.<u>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Chemicals in the Environment</u>:  &#8220;In OECD countries the production, consumption and trade of chemicals and chemical products has grown steadily, and is projected to continue to grow through 2020 roughly at the same rate as GDP (with faster growth in developing countries). However, production in OECD countries is expected to shift from high volume basic chemicals to speciality chemicals and products derived from the life sciences.  The chemicals industry in OECD countries has made significant progress in reducing the release of pollutants to the environment during the manufacturing process.  <u>Major concerns exist about the possible impact on the environment and human health of substances produced by the chemicals industry</u>, which are found in virtually every man-made product. Many are being detected in the environment, where particular problems can be caused by persistent, bioaccumulative and toxic chemicals. Concern is growing, for example, about chemicals which cause endocrine disruption and which persist in the environment.&#8221; (page 224)</p>

<p align="justify">108.<u>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Municipal Waste Generation</u>:  &#8220;The annual generation of municipal waste in OECD countries increased by around 40% between 1980 and 1997, amounting to about 540 million tonnes in 1997. With continued economic growth, municipal waste generation is expected to keep growing, reaching an estimated 770 million tonnes annually by 2020, which would represent a further increase of some 43%.  In 1997, approximately 64% of municipal waste was destined for landfill, 18% for incineration, and 18% for recycling in OECD countries. Further implementation of waste management policies, however, is expected to help to reduce landfilling and increase recycling in the future. By 2020, about 50% of municipal waste is expected to be landfilled, 17% incinerated, and 33% recycled.  In the mid-1990s, total waste generated in OECD regions was estimated to be 4 billion tonnes. In the future, both <u>municipal and industrial waste are expected to show high growth rates</u>, while waste generation from the agricultural and mining sectors is expected to grow at a slower rate to 2020.&#8221; (page 235)</p>

<p align="justify">109.<u>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Freshwater scarcity</u>:  &#8220;Water scarcity can have direct negative effects on human health, the economy, and the environment. Over the last 50 years there have been dramatic reductions in the global per capita availability of freshwater, from 17 000 m<sup>3</sup> per capita per annum in 1950 to 7 300 m<sup>3</sup> in 1995. This is largely a result of increasing population pressures, but has also been influenced by the decline in availability of uncontaminated freshwater. Current trends indicate that the level of per capita available water resources is likely to decline even further in the near future, as most countries continue to expand their populations and pollute available water sources. As a result, <u>by 2020 over one-quarter of a billion people are expected to be living under high water stress</u>, representing an increase of 75% from 1995 levels.&#8221; (page 102)<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P545_104251" name="P545_104252">33</a></sup></p>

<p align="justify">110.<u>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Biodiversity</u>:  &#8220;The main pressures on biodiversity in OECD countries come from land use changes as populations increase, the unsustainable use of the natural resource base (<i>e.g. </i>in fisheries, agriculture, and forestry), climate change and pollution. Although some of these pressures are expected to decrease in the near future, <u>the total burden on biodiversity is expected to remain high to the year 2020</u>. Biodiversity loss in developing countries is even more serious, with the main driver being habitat loss as natural areas are opened up to agriculture and natural resources exploitation.&#8221; (page 133)</p>

<p align="justify">111.<u>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Fisheries</u>:  &#8220;Current fishing levels and methods place significant  pressures on world fisheries and marine ecosystems. <u>The harvesting of fish stocks has moved successively from one fishery to another as yields from each reach their peak and then decline</u>. These practices have resulted in an estimated 50% of the world fish stocks being fully exploited, 15% that are overfished, 7% which are depleted, and 2% that are recovering from over-fishing (FAO, 2000<i>a</i>). The remaining 25% of the main world fish stocks are still capable of producing higher yields. In addition to affecting the stocks of commercially valuable fish, fishing activities often contribute to the depletion of non-target fish (through by-catch), marine pollution, and habitat destruction (<i>e.g. </i>through bottom trawling and dynamite fishing). Marine degradation is further exacerbated, and fish stocks negatively affected, by pollution and other ecosystem changes originating from non-fishery sector sources, such as agriculture run-off, water pollution, the deposition of chemicals from air pollution, coastal zone development, and global warming. <u>The introduction of invasive species to fishery &#8230; can also lead to serious repercussions for fishery ecosystems</u>.&#8221; (page 109)<sup><a href="edoc9851-01.htm#P550_106251" name="P550_106252">34</a></sup></p>

<p align="justify">112.<u>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Population Growth and Demographic Change</u>:  &#8220;<u>Population increases are expected to put further stress on the environment</u>. &#8230;  World population is projected to grow by one-quarter, from the current 6 billion to 7.5 billion in 2020; the population in OECD countries is projected to increase by less, from 1.1 billion in 1995 to 1.2 billion in 2020.&#8221;  &#8220;The physical expansion of urban areas (urban sprawl) leads to increasing pressures on the environment [through] disproportionally high levels of land use, energy consumption and resource use compared with more central high density zones in cities.&#8221;  In addition, the changing age structure of OECD populations is expected to have important implications for sustainable development in the OECD area, in particular with regard to the sustainability of pension systems. (pages 39-41).</p>

<p align="justify"><b>h. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Conclusions</b></p>

  <ul><p align="justify"><i>&#8220;The OECD membership must be the global locomotive for planetary sustainable development.  If such critical issues pivotal to ensuring the planet&#8217;s future cannot be resolved within the OECD membership, what chance would there be for agreement and commitment at the global level?&#8221;</i></p>

          <ul><ul><ul><ul><p align="justify">Donald Johnston, OECD Secretary-General,</p>

          <p align="justify">speaking at an OECD-Side event at the World Summit on Sustainable Development in Johannesburg, 3 September 2002.</p>

</ul></ul></ul></ul></ul><p align="justify"><b>(i) &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Progress in the Implementation of the OECD&#8217;s Sustainable Development Agenda</b></p>

<p align="justify">113.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Since the 2001 Ministerial Mandate, the OECD has made some important progress in the development and implementation of its sustainable development agenda.  However, <b>resource constraints have resulted in an inability to follow-up on all issues raised in the Mandate, which addressed only some of the key sustainable development areas</b>.  </p>

<p align="justify">114.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In the Rapporteur&#8217;s discussions at the OECD and the assessment of key OECD documents, it became clear that <b>the OECD has not made the desired progress in two areas that are vital to the successful implementation of the sustainable development agenda</b> set by the 2001 Ministerial Mandate: (<b>i) the horizontal integration of analysis and policy-development across OECD organisational units </b>responsible for the dimensions of sustainable development; <b>and (ii) the required conceptual shift in economic analysis and policy-making</b>, which leads to the integration of environmental and social objectives into economic analysis an policy-development.  Left alone, the application of economic analysis to the review of environmental and social policies is not enough.  </p>

<p align="justify">115.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Since 2001, by virtue of the Ministerial Mandate, <b>the OECD has officially adopted and advocated an integrated approach to sustainable development.  This fact, however, seems to have had a limited impact on the economic analysis and policy-development process carried out by the OECD</b>.  Instead, a narrow economic concept still dominates, which sees the economy as a separate entity in isolation from environmental and social values and consequences.  When discussed at all in the context of core economic analysis and reporting, sustainable development is seen from the &#8220;balance&#8221; perspective.  The result is that narrow economic growth and efficiency goals are given greater value over social development and the protection of the environment, especially during an economic downturn, as confirmed in meetings held by the Rapporteur with OECD officials in March 2003, including one senior official&#8217;s comment with regard to the sustainable development agenda: &#8220;the focus of the Economics Directorate is on assessing the economic viability of environmental policy &#8230;&#8221;  Yet <b>the view of the crucial and inextricable linkages between the social, environmental and economic dimensions of sustainable development continues to exist</b></p>

<p align="justify">116.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; At the same time, parliamentarians of the Enlarged Assembly have confidence in the OECD&#8217;s sustainable development agenda.  Progress made to date in implementing it &#8211; in particular analytical and policy-development work presented in the relevant sections of the more recent <i>Economic Surveys</i> plus the work done on environmentally harmful subsidies and on the development of indicators to measure progress along all three dimensions of sustainable development &#8211; confirms this confidence.  In addition, the 2001 <i>Environmental Outlook</i> provides an important assessment of environmental problems and policies, largely from a sustainable development perspective, although this work is not reflected in the methods and conclusions of the <i>Economic Outlook</i> of the <i>Agenda for Growth</i>.  Furthermore, the OECD is now also working on a longer term environmental outlook.  But the fact remains that as long as the organisation does not adequately integrate analysis and policy-development across its organisational units responsible for core policy areas, the potential to develop a coherent, integrated sustainable development agenda remains elusive. </p>

<p align="justify">117.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Rapporteur has raised these concerns with the Secretary General Donald Johnston in a letter sent following meetings at the OECD in March 2003.  </p>

<p align="justify"><b>(ii) &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Concluding Remarks</b></p>

<p align="justify">118.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The devastating effects of unqualified economic growth on the natural environment and the interplay between economy and environment have been on the world&#8217;s political agenda ever since the Club of Rome published its controversial <i>Limits to Growth</i> report and the United Nations held its first Conference on the Human Environment three decades ago in Stockholm.  Since its introduction in the Brundtland Report in 1987, the concept of sustainable development has served to focus international discussion about our common future around the inextricable linkages between economic growth, social development and the natural environment.  </p>

<p align="justify">119.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In addition, throughout this period, evidence, scientific and otherwise, has mounted as to the long-term effects of environmental exploitation and degradation on economic growth and social development: the fact that the very foundations of our existence are increasingly threatened by climate change, pollution, natural resource depletion, the extinction of animal and plant species, and the destruction of whole ecosystems, is now widely recognized.  However, despite many international conferences and numerous political declarations recognizing the urgent need to move the world economy to a sustainable development model, real progress has so far been limited to a few areas &#8211; such as the repair of the ozone layer &#8211; and the overall growth path of the global economy has not been changed.</p>

<p align="justify">120.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The failure to make urgently needed progress on the sustainable development agenda in the OECD and beyond is a reflection of the fact <b>sustainable development is not or no longer seen as a priority issue</b> &#8211; an assessment shared with the Rapporteur by several of his interlocutors at the OECD.   With regard to the OECD, this fact poses a particularly urgent problem, since <b>the 2001 Ministerial Mandate will run out next year.  The Mandate&#8217;s renewal would be seen as an important indication that the industrialized world is still committed to sustainable development.</b>  </p>

<p align="justify">121.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; As an organisation of nation-states, the OECD can only do so much.  It is limited in its choices, progress and decisions by the will of its members&#8217; governments.  <b>The development and implementation of a substantive sustainable development agenda by the OECD is ultimately dependent</b>, therefore, <b>on the political will generated by national parliaments and governments.  International agreements and agendas, including Johannesburg and Rio, require parliamentary activism and pressure that triggers political will at the executive level.  For in the end, sustainable development is not just about technical or semantic issues.  It comes down to political will and parliamentary pressure, changes in values and practices, public education and long-term thinking.</b>  In other words, the OECD cannot do it alone.  The 2001 Ministerial Declaration represents a small step in the direction of sustainable growth moderated by the knowledge that this planet is finite and the growth of its human population relentless.</p>

<p align="justify"><i>Reporting committee</i>: Committee on Economic Affairs and Development</p>

<p align="justify"><i>Reference to committee</i>:  Standing mandate.</p>

<p align="justify"><i>Draft resolution</i> unanimously adopted by the Enlarged Committee on Economic Affairs and Development on 30 September 2003 at its meeting with delegations from the Parliaments of Canada, Japan, and Korea and with representatives of other committees concerned.</p>

<p align="justify"><i>Members of the committee</i>: Mrs Zapfl-Helbling (Chairperson) (Alternate:<i> Mr Frey</i>), <i>Mr Kirilov</i> , Mrs <i>Burbiene</i>, Mrs Pericleous-Papadopoulos (Vice-chairpersons), <i>Mr</i> <i>Açikgöz</i>, <i>Mr Adam</i>, Mr Agramunt (Alternate: <i>Mr Yanez-Barnuevo</i>), Mr I. Aliyev (Alternate: <i>Mr Abbasov</i>), Mr Anacoreta Correia, Mr Andov, Mr Arnau, Mr Assis Miranda, <i>Mr Ates</i>, Mr Berceanu, <i>Mr Braun</i>, <i>Mr Brunhart</i>, Mr Budin, <i>Mr Çavusoglu</i>, <i>Mr Cosarciuc</i>, <i>Mr Crema</i>, <i>Mr Dimic</i>, Mr Djupedal, Mr Duivesteijn, Mr Eyskens, <i>Mr Figel</i>, <i>Mr Floros</i>, Mr Galchenko, <i>Ms Griffiths</i>, Mr Grignon, Mr Gusenbauer, Ms Hakl, <i>Mr Haupert</i>, <i>Mr Högmark</i>, Mr Jonas, Mr Kacin, <i>Mr Karapetyan</i>, Mrs Kestelijn-Sierens, Mr Klympush, <i>Mr Korobeynikov</i>, Mr Kraus, Mr Krivokapic, <i>Mr Lachnit</i>, Mr Le Guen, Mr Leibrecht, <i>Mr</i> <i>Liapis</i>, Mr Makhachev, Mr Masseret, <i>Mr Melcak</i>, Mr Mikkelsen, Ms Milicevic,  <i>Mrs Muizniece</i>, Mr Naumov, <i>Mr Öhman</i>, <i>Mr O&#8217;Keeffe</i>, <i>Mr Opmann</i>, Mrs Patarkalishvili, Mrs Petursdottir, Mrs Pintat Rossell, Mr Podgorski, Mr Popa, Mr&nbsp;Puche, Mr Pullicino Orlando, Mr Ramponi, Mr Reimann, Mr Riccardi, Mr Rivolta, Lord Russell-Johnston, Mr Rybak, <i>Mr Sasi</i>, <i>Mr Schreiner</i>, <i>Mr Severin</i>, Mr Seyidov, <i>Ms Smith</i>, Mr Stefanov (Alternate: <i>Mr Velikov</i>), Mr Tepshi, <i>Mr Torbar</i>, Mrs Vadai, Mr Walter (Alternate: <i>Baroness Hooper</i>), <i>Mr Wielowieyski</i>, Mr Wikinski, Mr Zhevago.</p>

<p align="justify">Canada: <i>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Mr Caccia, Senator Di Nino</i>, </p>

<p align="justify">Japan: <i>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;  Mr Hanashi, Mr Unno, Mr Kagita, Mr Hikasa</i></p>

<p align="justify">Korea:<i>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;  Mr Lee, Mr Hahm</i></p>

<p align="justify"><i>N.B. The names of those members present at the meeting are printed in italics</i></p>

<p align="justify"><i>Head of Secretariat</i>: Mr Torbiörn</p>

<p align="justify"><i>Co-Secretaries to the committee</i>: M. Bertozzi, Ms Ramanauskaite; Ms Kopaçi-Di Michele, Ms Stewart</p>
<hr align="left" size="1" width="200" noshade>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P57_8295" href="#P57_8296">1</a> </sup> This is the internationally accepted definition of sustainable development put forward in 1987 by the Brundtland Commission in its report &#8220;Our Common Future.&#8221;</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P83_13923" href="#P83_13924">2</a> </sup> In responding to the 2001 Ministerial Mandate, the Secretariat gave priority to the four areas: (i) the preparation of a report to last year&#8217;s UN World Summit on Sustainable Development (WSSD) in Johannesburg; (ii) the development of indicators for use in OECD peer reviews; (iii) overcoming obstacles to the phasing out of environmentally damaging subsidies; and (iv) the social aspects of sustainable development.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P190_23965" href="#P190_23966">3</a> </sup> <i>The OECD Observer (September 1984).</i></p><!-- TRANSIT - INFOAFTER -->
</body>
</html>
