<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//IETF//DTD HTML//EN">
<html>

<head>
<meta http-equiv="Content-Language" content="fr">
<meta name="GENERATOR" content="Microsoft FrontPage 5.0">
<meta name="ProgId" content="FrontPage.Editor.Document">
<title> Honouring of obligations and commitments by Armenia </title>
<style>
<!--
h4
	{margin-bottom:.0001pt;
	text-align:right;
	page-break-after:avoid;
	font-size:12.0pt;
	font-family:"Times New Roman";
	font-weight:normal; margin-left:0mm; margin-right:0mm; margin-top:0mm}
 table.MsoNormalTable
	{mso-style-parent:"";
	font-size:10.0pt;
	font-family:"Times New Roman"}
span.MsoFootnoteReference
	{vertical-align:super}
-->
</style>
<style fprolloverstyle>A:hover {color: #FF0000; font-weight: bold}
</style>
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="../../../css/pa2.css">
</head>

<body>

<blockquote>
  <table border="0" cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" style="border-collapse: collapse; float: left; text-align: left; width: 130px; height: 120px" bordercolor="#111111" id="AutoNumber1" height="120">
    <tr>
      <td width="100%" height="120" nowrap><font face="Tahoma" size="4"> <span style="letter-spacing: 0.5pt"> Parliamentary <b>Assembly</b></span><b><span style="letter-spacing: 1"><br>
      Assembl�e</span></b> parlementaire</font></td>
    </tr>
  </table>
  <div align="right">
    <table border="0" cellspacing="0" style="border-collapse: collapse" bordercolor="#111111" width="130" cellpadding="0" id="AutoNumber2" height="120">
      <tr>
        <td><img border="0" src="../../Logo130X120.jpg" WIDTH="130" HEIGHT="120"></td>
      </tr>
    </table>
  </div>
  <hr noshade color="#000000" size="1">
  <p align="justify"><strong>Honouring of obligations
        and commitments by Armenia</font></span></strong></p>
  
  <p align="justify"> <strong>Doc.
            10163</strong><br>
    </font></span></font>27
  April 2004</span></font></font></p>
  
  <p align="justify"> <strong>Report</strong><br>
    </font></span>Committee on the Honouring
    of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe<br>
  Rapporteurs: Mr Ren� Andr�, France, Group of the European People&#146;s Party,
  and Mr Jerzy Jaskiernia, Poland, Socialist Group</span></font></p>
  </font></font>
  <hr size="1">

  <p align="justify"><i>Summary</span></i></p>
  <p align="justify">Since the end of March 2004, a series of 
  protests were organised by the opposition forces in Armenia, calling for the 
  holding of a &#147;referendum of confidence&#148; in President Kocharian. The 
  demonstrations, while announced, have not been authorised by the authorities 
  who threatened their organisers with criminal prosecution. In the early 
  morning of 13 April, the security forces violently dispersed some 2000-3000 
  protesters who were attempting to march towards the presidential palace, 
  calling for President Kocharian&#146;s resignation. The police reportedly used 
  truncheons, water cannons and tear gas, causing dozens of injuries.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The Parliamentary Assembly considers 
  that the actions of the Armenian authorities are contrary to the letter and 
  the spirit of the recommendations formulated in its 
  <a href="../../AdoptedText/TA04/ERES1361.htm">Resolution 1361 (2004)</a> 
  adopted last January and it demands Armenia to urgently comply with its 
  obligations and commitments.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The Assembly calls upon the authorities 
  and the opposition to refrain from any action which may lead to further 
  violence and to engage in a dialogue without preconditions, with a view to 
  resolving the present conflict in accordance with Council of Europe standards 
  and European democratic practice.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">I.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  Draft resolution <i>[<a href="../../AdoptedText/TA04/ERES1374.htm">Link to the 
  adopted text</a>]</i></span></p>
  <p align="justify">1.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  Since the end of March 2004, a series of protests were organised by the 
  opposition forces in Armenia, calling for the holding of a &#147;referendum of 
  confidence&#148; in President Kocharian. The possibility of such a referendum was 
  first mentioned by the Armenian Constitutional Court following the 
  presidential elections in February and March last year. The Constitutional 
  Court has since reversed its decision and the authorities qualify the 
  opposition demands and protests as an attempt to seize power by force.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">2.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  The demonstrations, while announced, have not been authorised by the 
  authorities who threatened their organisers with criminal prosecution. 
  Following the demonstrations on 5 April, the prosecutor general opened 
  criminal investigations against several members of the opposition and many 
  more were arrested. On the same occasion, several journalists were beaten up 
  by unknown persons while the police was standing by taking no action.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">3.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  New demonstrations took place on 9, 10 and 12 April in Yerevan. In the early 
  morning of 13 April, the security forces violently dispersed some 2000-3000 
  protesters who were attempting to march towards the presidential palace, 
  calling for President Kocharian&#146;s resignation. The police reportedly used 
  truncheons, water cannons and tear gas, causing dozens of injuries. A number 
  of protesters were arrested, including members of parliament, some of whom are 
  members of the Assembly, and some were allegedly mistreated during their 
  custody by the police. The security forces also assaulted and arrested several 
  journalists who were covering the opposition rally.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">4.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  The tensions in Armenia continue to run high; new protests are planned for the 
  week of 26 April. For the time being, there seems to be little room for 
  dialogue between the authorities and the opposition, even if some offers have 
  been made and some members of the ruling majority &#150; and notably the Speaker of 
  the Armenian parliament &#150; have begun criticising the heavy-handed crackdown on 
  demonstrators.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">5.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  With regard to the conduct of the authorities, the Parliamentary Assembly 
  recalls that its actions are contrary to the letter and the spirit of the 
  recommendations formulated in its Resolution 1361 (2004) adopted last January. 
  It is particularly concerned with the fact that:</span></p>
  <blockquote>
    <p align="justify">i.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
    massive arrests, including on the basis of the Administrative Code, ignored 
    the demand to immediately end the practice of administrative detention and 
    change the Administrative Code used as a legal basis for this practice;</span></p>
    <p align="justify">ii.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
    the authorities refused to authorise opposition rallies for reasons not 
    permitted under the European Convention on Human Rights. Moreover the new 
    draft law on the procedure of conducting gatherings, meetings, rallies and 
    demonstrations, currently in the parliamentary procedure, was evaluated as 
    excessively restrictive by experts of the Venice Commission;</span></p>
    <p align="justify">iii.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
    persons detained during the recent events were reportedly subjected to 
    ill-treatment by police and security forces, in spite of Assembly&#146;s demands 
    to take resolute and more active steps to remedy misconduct by law 
    enforcement officials;</span></p>
    <p align="justify">iv.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
    freedom of expression continues to be seriously curtailed and several acts 
    of violence against journalists, which took place during the recent events, 
    were carried out or were allowed to happen by the police and security 
    forces.</span></p>
  </blockquote>
  <p align="justify">6.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  With regard to the conduct of the opposition, the Assembly stresses that they 
  should do their utmost to avoid any future violence.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">7.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  As to their demands for the holding of a &#147;referendum of confidence&#148; and the 
  resignation of President Kocharian, the Assembly stresses that:</span></p>
  <blockquote>
    <p align="justify">i.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
    both the presidential, and the parliamentary elections which followed in May 
    last year were severely criticised by the international community, including 
    by the Assembly delegations. The elections fell short of the international 
    standards in key areas and the irregularities observed notably included 
    biased media coverage, detention of opposition proxies and campaign staff, 
    falsification of results, intimidation of observers as well as generally 
    inadequate performance of the elections administration. </span></p>
    <p align="justify">ii.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
    although the fraud, in spite of its magnitude, did not decisively change the 
    outcome of the elections nor invalidate their final results, in its report 
    on the honouring of obligations and commitments by Armenia, adopted in 
    January 2004 (Resolution 1361), the Assembly expressed profound 
    disappointment at the conduct of the elections and called for a thorough 
    investigation into electoral fraud and an end to the judicial impunity for 
    those responsible for it. </span></p>
  </blockquote>
  <p align="justify">8.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  Consequently, the Assembly considers that the opposition, while entitled to 
  fully enjoy their constitutional rights to peaceful assembly, should refrain 
  from attempts to use street demonstrations to reverse the results of last 
  year&#146;s elections, which have been, in spite of the irregularities, validated 
  by relevant national and international bodies.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">9.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  The Assembly calls upon the Armenian authorities to:</span></p>
  <blockquote>
    <p align="justify">i.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
    allow peaceful demonstrations and refrain from any further action which 
    would legally, or in practice, lead to unjustified restrictions to the 
    freedom of assembly guaranteed by the European Convention on human rights;</span></p>
    <p align="justify">ii.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
    immediately investigate &#150; in a transparent and credible manner - the 
    incidents and human rights abuses reported during the recent events, 
    including assaults of journalists and human rights activists, and inform the 
    Assembly of their findings and possible legal actions against persons 
    responsible;</span></p>
    <p align="justify">iii.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
    immediately release the persons detained for their participation in the 
    demonstrations and immediately end the practice of administrative detention 
    and amend the Administrative Code to this effect;</span></p>
    <p align="justify">iv.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
    create fair conditions for the normal functioning of the media, notably as 
    regards the issuing of broadcasting licences to television companies, 
    particularly to television channel A1+;</span></p>
    <p align="justify">v.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
    send a written report to the Assembly, before the opening of the June 2004 
    part-session, on the steps it has taken with regard to sub-paragraphs 9.i , 
    ii, iii and iv.</span></p>
  </blockquote>
  <p align="justify">10.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  The Assembly calls upon the authorities and the opposition to refrain from any 
  action which may lead to further violence and to engage in a dialogue without 
  preconditions, with a view to resolving the present conflict in accordance 
  with Council of Europe standards and European democratic practice.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">11.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  The Assembly believes that the recent events have added a measure of urgency 
  to its demands for Armenia&#146;s full and unconditional compliance with their 
  obligations and commitments. It resolves to continue to closely monitor the 
  situation in Armenia and, if no progress with regard to sub-paragraphs 9.i, 
  ii, iii and iv is made by the opening of the June 2004 part-session, to 
  reconsider the credentials of the Armenian delegation, in accordance with Rule 
  9 of its Rules of Procedure.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">II.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  Explanatory memorandum by the co-rapporteurs</span></p>
  <p align="justify">1.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  Introduction</span></p>
  <p align="justify">Since the end of March, opposition 
  forces in Armenia decided to jointly organise mass protests to force a 
  &#147;referendum of confidence&#148; in President Kocharian. The possibility of such a 
  referendum was first mentioned by the Armenian Constitutional Court following 
  the presidential elections in February and March last year, which were 
  strongly criticised by the international community.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The opposition intentions are likely to 
  have been inspired by last year&#146;s events in the neighbouring Georgia, where 
  massive protests led to the resignation of President Shevardnadze and early 
  presidential and parliamentary elections.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The Armenian authorities reacted to the 
  opposition call for protests with a campaign of political intimidation and 
  administrative and judicial harassment. Once the protests started, the 
  reaction was even more ruthless. Demonstrations were violently dispersed, 
  journalists were beaten up, a large number of opposition supporters were 
  arrested and premises of the opposition parties were raided by the police.
  </span></p>
  <p align="justify">The Head of the OSCE presence in Yerevan 
  blamed both the authorities and the opposition for violent incidents. Most 
  media and NGO reports put the blame squarely on the government.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">New opposition rallies were announced 
  for the week of 26 April. The tensions continue, there seems to be little room 
  for dialogue right now.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">2.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  Background to the recent events</span></p>
  <p align="justify"><i>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  The 2003 presidential and parliamentary elections</span></i></p>
  <p align="justify">Armenia conducted two important 
  elections last year &#150; President Kocharian was reelected president in March and 
  the new parliament was elected in the elections which took place in May.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">Both elections were severely criticised 
  by the international community, including by the Assembly delegations. The 
  elections fell short of international standards in key areas, and the 
  irregularities observed included notably biased media coverage, detention of 
  opposition proxies and campaign staff, falsification of results, intimidation 
  of observers as well as generally inadequate performance of the elections 
  administration. </span></p>
  <p align="justify">The Assembly&#146;s monitoring report, 
  adopted in January 2004 (Resolution 1361), expressed profound disappointment 
  with the conduct of the elections. The Assembly also called for a thorough 
  investigation into electoral fraud an end to the judicial impunity for those 
  responsible for it.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">However, in their explanatory 
  memorandum, the rapporteurs concurred with the findings of the OSCE 
  observation mission that the fraud, in spite of its magnitude, did not 
  decisively change the outcome of the elections nor invalidate their final 
  results. </span></p>
  <p align="justify">It was in this spirit that the Assembly 
  ratified the credentials of the Armenian delegation after the May 
  parliamentary elections. However, the acceptance of the results should not be 
  understood by Yerevan as the readiness to condone and tolerate this kind of 
  conduct in the future. They were given the benefit of the doubt, but they 
  should be very careful not to gamble with the trust of the international 
  community. The recent events regrettably indicate that the authorities have 
  not fully understood this message. </span></p>
  <p align="justify"><i>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  &#147;Referendum of confidence&#148;</span></i></p>
  <p align="justify">After several presidential candidates 
  from the opposition contested the results of the Presidential elections in 
  February and March last year, the Armenian Constitutional Court ruled that 
  their complaints were well-founded but did not invalidate the results. 
  Instead, it proposed the holding of a &#147;referendum of confidence&#148; in President 
  Kocharian. </span></p>
  <p align="justify">This decision, delivered on 16 April, 
  was severely criticised by President Kocharian and his supporters, as a 
  challenge to the President&#146;s legitimacy. The Constitutional Court has since 
  reversed its position and stated, on 26 January 2004, that its original 
  decision had been misunderstood and manipulated.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">In spite of this decision of the 
  Constitutional Court, the holding of a &#147;referendum of confidence&#148; constitutes 
  the main demand of the present opposition campaign of protests. </span></p>
  <p align="justify">3.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;
  Chronology of recent events<a href="#_ftn1" name="_ftnref1" title>[1]</a>
  </span></p>
  <p align="justify">- </span>17 March 
  2004</span></p>
  <p align="justify">President Kocharian dismissed Aram 
  Tamazian, Prosecutor-General for the past three years.&nbsp; Mr Kocharian 
  stated that the role and prestige of the Office of the Prosecutor-General had 
  declined under Mr Tamazian's leadership, appointed in his place was Aghvan 
  Hovsepian, Deputy Prosecutor-General.&nbsp; He had served as 
  Prosecutor-General in 1998 and 1999.&nbsp; Four Yerevan procesutors were 
  dismissed on 22 March.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 23 March</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The European Union's special envoy for 
  the southern Caucasus, Heike Talvitie, met the Minister for Foreign Affairs 
  and two Deputy Speakers of Parliament.&nbsp; Ms Talvitie referred to the 
  controversial draft legislation currently before Parliament which would 
  restrict freedom of assembly.&nbsp; Tigran Torosian, a &quot;parliamentary 
  official&quot;, gave an assurance that this bill was in conformity with European 
  principles and standards, and that it was currently under examination by the 
  Council of Europe's Venice Commission.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 26 March</span></p>
  <p align="justify">In a joint communique to Parliament, the 
  three political parties of the governing coalition issued a warning about 
  attempts to break constitutional law, and called the responsible authorities 
  to maintain order with determination and firmness.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 28 March</span></p>
  <p align="justify">A major gathering organised by the 
  Artarutiun opposition bloc in Giumri, Armenia's second city, degenerated into 
  fighting between those who back Artarutiun and supporters of President 
  Kocharian.&nbsp; Four members of Artarutiun were arrested for assaulting a 
  police officer.&nbsp; The chairperson of Artarutiun, Stepan Demirchian, had 
  told participants (numbering around 1 000): &quot;we are witnessing the death 
  throes&#148; of the Kocharian regime, and &#147;the Armenian people cannot tolerate the 
  rule of such thugs&quot;.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 29 March</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The Union of Industrialists and 
  Entrepreneurs, which represents the most influential business persons, issued 
  a statement warning that political unrest would have negative effects on the 
  Armenian economy and that such a situation would jeopardise the chances of 
  finding a solution to the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict on terms favourable to 
  Armenia.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 30 March</span></p>
  <p align="justify">President Kocharian's press service 
  stated that the opposition's threats were baseless and aggressive, and that 
  the organisation of unauthorised public meetings was a &quot;criminal offence&quot;, and 
  would be dealt with as such.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The chairperson of the Armenian Helsinki 
  Association, Mikael Danielian, was attacked and beaten up by four unknown men 
  as he left his home.&nbsp; He had constantly expressed criticism of the 
  Armenian authorities for violations of human rights.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The prosecutor general opened a criminal 
  case against members of the opposition Justice Alliance under Article 301 
  (public calls for seizure of power by force) and 318/2 (publicly insulting 
  representatives of government).</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 31 March</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The authorities warned the opposition 
  leaders that they might well be arrested during an investigation of their 
  plans to &quot;seize power by violence and change the constitutional order of the 
  Republic of Armenia&quot;.&nbsp; The Artarutiun opposition bloc and the National 
  Unity Party planned to organise demonstrations in April calling for the 
  resignation of President Kocharian, whose re-election in 2003 they challenged.&nbsp; 
  The leader of Artarutiun, Stepan Demirchian, emphasised that the opposition 
  was not seeking violence, but merely wished to restore constitutional order.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 1 April</span></p>
  <p align="justify">At a meeting with European ambassadors, 
  President Kocharian said that the situation was tense in Armenia.&nbsp; He 
  declared that stability was his priority, and he rejected accusations that his 
  government had threatened to arrest opposition leaders.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The Armenian Revolutionary Federation 
  gave its support to the governing coalition against the opposition, while the 
  Republican Party and Orinats Yerkir said that arrests among the opposition 
  would be unjustified.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 5 April</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The National Unity Party organised a 
  rally in Yerevan that drew an estimated 3000 participants. Fights broke out 
  and journalists trying to film the clashes were beaten up while police was 
  standing by taking no action</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The leaders of the two main opposition 
  parties, Stepan Demirchian and Artashes Geghamian, announced that they would 
  be organising demonstrations from 9 April onwards in order to force the 
  government to resign, despite a number of arrests of opposition supporters 
  made by the authorities on 4 April.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 6 April</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The police confirmed that 48 opposition 
  activists and supporters had been arrested following an unauthorised 
  demonstration on 4 or 5 April.&nbsp; It was reported that, during this 
  demonstration, some journalists had been attacked by unknown persons, without 
  the police intervening.&nbsp; The police chief declared that the law 
  enforcement agencies had been told to intervene only in extreme cases.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The leaders of the three main opposition 
  parties, Artashes Geghamian, Aram Sargsian and Stepan Demirchian, during new 
  demonstrations in Yerevan on 9 and 10 April, decided to call for President 
  Kocharian's resignation, on the grounds that his re-election had been 
  fraudulent and therefore unlawful.&nbsp; They issued an ultimatum to the 
  authorities, giving them until midday on 12 April to organise a referendum of 
  confidence in Mr Kocharian.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 9, 10 and 12 April</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The organisers estimate that 30,000 
  people (60 of whom were arrested) took part in the 9 April demonstrations, 
  with 10,000 taking part on 10 April and 15,000 on 12 April.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 13 April</span></p>
  <p align="justify">At 2 am on 13 April, special police 
  equipped with truncheons, water cannons and tear gas grenades attacked between 
  2,000 and 3,000 demonstrators who were attempting to march towards the 
  presidential palace to call for the resignation of the President, causing 
  dozens of injuries. </span></p>
  <p align="justify">Security forces brutally attacked 
  several journalists reporting on the opposition rally.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The police then moved on to the 
  headquarters of the National Accord Party, the People's Party of Armenia and 
  Hanrapetitiun, destroying their offices and arresting some members of these 
  parties, including three MPs.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">Artashes Geghamian and Aram Sargsian 
  called for new demonstrations.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">President Kocharian met the three 
  leaders of the governing coalition parties and expressed condemnation of the 
  previous days&#146; opposition demonstrations and support for the police action.&nbsp; 
  He added that the authorities would use all lawful means of preventing any 
  more extremist demonstrations</span></p>
  <p align="justify">Vahan Hovannisian (a member of the 
  Armenian Revolutionary Federation, Dashnaktsutiun), Deputy Speaker of 
  Parliament, said that the opposition had overestimated its capacities and that 
  its demands were of an extremist nature.&nbsp; He pointed out that the three 
  coalition parties had made an offer the previous week to begin dialogue with 
  the opposition.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">At this time, Artashes Geghamian and 
  Aram Sargsian were in hiding, fearing arrest.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">Stepan Demirchian rejected police claims 
  that the demonstrators had used violence against the police.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">A spokesman for the US State Department, 
  Richard Boucher, expressed the United States' concern about the acts of 
  violence in Armenia, and urged the two sides to engage in dialogue.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 14 April</span></p>
  <p align="justify">Artashes Geghamian, at a press 
  conference in the parliament building, said that the police had searched the 
  National Unity Party headquarters and his own flat, seizing documents and even 
  family photographs.&nbsp; He added, with the support of two members of the 
  Artarutiun alliance, Albert Bazeyan and Viktor Dallakian, that the opposition 
  would continue to campaign for the resignation of the country&#146;s leadership.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">At a meeting with members of Armenia's 
  United Communist Party, President Kocharian called for dialogue with the 
  opposition.&nbsp; Tigran Torosian and Samvel Balasanian, members of the 
  governing coalition, also proposed dialogue, during a meeting with Artashes 
  Geghamian, who rejected the offer.&nbsp; Tigran Torosian added that a 
  referendum of confidence in the President would be both unlawful and 
  unconstitutional.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The President of the Parliamentary 
  Assembly, Mr Schieder, and the Secretary General of the Council of Europe, Mr 
  Schwimmer, expressed serious concern about the violent events in Armenia.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">At a meeting with Natalia Voutova, 
  Special Representative of the Secretary General of the Council of Europe, the 
  Prosecutor General, Mr Hovsepian, said that the police had acted lawfully on 
  13 April.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 15 April</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The three parties of the governing 
  coalition reiterated their offer of dialogue, but the opposition leaders, Mr 
  Demirchian, Mr Sargsian and Mr Geghamian, rejected this proposal and voiced 
  their intention of organising a demonstration in Yerevan on 16 April.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">1,000 people demonstrated in Yerevan 
  against police brutality and the arrests of 13 April.&nbsp; 115 people had 
  been arrested on 13 April, including three MPs who had subsequently been 
  released.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The police accused the former Minister 
  of Defence, Mr Harutiunian, who had been arrested on 13 April, of disturbing 
  public order and insulting officials.&nbsp; </span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 16 April</span></p>
  <p align="justify">A demonstration organised by the 
  Artarutiun alliance and the National Accord Party was attended by 6,000 
  people.&nbsp; Mr Demirchian told the demonstrators that the police brutality 
  of 13 April was a crime that could be neither forgiven nor forgotten.&nbsp; Mr 
  Sargsian added that the opposition would continue to organise demonstrations 
  until President Kocharian resigned.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 19 April</span></p>
  <p align="justify">In an interview with Russian daily <i>
  Izvestia</i>, Mr Kocharian described the repeated opposition demonstrations as 
  based on a &quot;misunderstanding&quot; and as a &quot;temporary phenomenon&quot;, and said that 
  Georgia's &quot;Revolution of Roses&quot; could not be reproduced in Armenia, whatever 
  the opposition thought.&nbsp; He added: &quot;I do not understand the purpose of 
  these demonstrations, when the opposition is represented in Parliament and can 
  work and prove to society its effectiveness and its capacity to solve problems 
  better than the President&quot;.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 20 April</span></p>
  <p align="justify">Speaking to journalists, Mr Kocharian 
  denied rumours that he was planning to divert the attention of the opposition 
  which was campaigning for his resignation by dismissing his Prime Minister or 
  dissolving Parliament and calling new elections.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The Prime Minister, Andranik Markarian, 
  said that, were he to be dismissed, he would join the opposition.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The United States Ambassador in Yerevan 
  had separate meetings with Mr Demirchian and Mr Geghamian.&nbsp; No 
  information about these discussions is available.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 21 April</span></p>
  <p align="justify">An estimated 20,000 people demonstrated 
  to call for the resignation of President Kocharian.&nbsp; Mr Sargsian called 
  on the demonstrators to meet again on 27 April for what he called a &quot;decisive&quot; 
  demonstration.&nbsp; Mr Dallakian summarised the opposition's conditions for 
  accepting the governing coalition's offer of dialogue: the release of all 
  political prisoners, the end of government &quot;repression&quot; against the opposition 
  and the resignation of the Minister of Defence and the Prosecutor-General.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">- 22 April</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The Venice Commission experts concluded 
  that the draft law on the freedom of assembly was not in conformity with 
  European principles and standards.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">4.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  <a href="../../AdoptedText/TA04/ERES1361.htm">Resolution 1361 (2004)</a> on the honouring of obligations and commitments by 
  Armenia</span></p>
  <p align="justify">In January 2004 the Assembly adopted its 
  its second monitoring report since the accession of Armenia to the Council of 
  Europe in January 2001. Resolution 1361, adopted on this occasion, takes note 
  of some encouraging developments that took place in the last two years &#150; 
  notably the ratification of Protocol 6 to the European Convention on Human 
  Rights which formally abolished the death penalty&nbsp; </span></p>
  <p align="justify">However, the Resolution &#150; as already 
  mentioned &#150; sharply criticised the two elections carried out in 2003. 
  Moreover, it listed a number of serious concerns with regard to the democratic 
  and human rights conduct of the Armenian authorities and expressed its 
  expectations that these issues will be speedily dealt with in accordance with 
  Council of Europe standards and principles.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">Regrettably, the reaction of the 
  Armenian authorities in the events of March and April this year demonstrate 
  that the Assembly&#146;s request for further progress was ignored and that, with 
  regard to some of the Assembly&#146;s key concerns, the situation has even 
  worsened.</span></p>
  <p align="justify"><i>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  Administrative detention</span></i></p>
  <p align="justify">With regard to the scandalous and 
  continued use of administrative detention, Resolution 1361 urged the 
  authorities to amend the Administrative Code to put an end to this practice 
  which is incompatible with the organisation&#146;s standards. The Assembly also 
  asked the authorities to submit this new draft to Council of Europe expertise 
  by April 2004. </span></p>
  <p align="justify">Instead of immediately ending this 
  practice and preparing the necessary legislative drafts to this effect, the 
  Armenian authorities resorted to a wide use of administrative detentions 
  during the recent events. While it is difficult to verify the exact number of 
  persons who were arrested and the legal basis used for their detention, most 
  reports indicate that their number was between two and three hundred. </span>
  </p>
  <p align="justify">The Assembly repeats its demand for an 
  immediate end to the practice of administrative detention. The Administrative 
  Code must be revised without any further delay. </span></p>
  <p align="justify"><i>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  Freedom of assembly</span></i></p>
  <p align="justify">Resolution 1361 asked the Armernian 
  authorities to immediately begin examining the question of balance between the 
  freedom of assembly and respect for public order, and to adopt a law on 
  demonstrations and public meetings in full compliance with Council of Europe 
  standards.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">Regrettably, during the March and April 
  events the authorities have displayed a diametrically opposite attitude. Most 
  of opposition demands for authorisation of their meetings were turned down, 
  reportedly for reasons that cannot be deemed as justified in accordance with 
  Council of Europe standards and practice. According to Human Rights Watch, the 
  opposition demands were turned down because of the &#147;detriment to the city&#146;s 
  economic well being&#148; or &#147;blocking traffic&#148;. </span></p>
  <p align="justify">Moreover, a draft law on rallies and 
  demonstrations, which is currently in the Parliamentary procedure, was 
  evaluated by the Venice Commission which found that the restrictions to the 
  freedom of assembly envisaged by the draft law were too broad and limitative, 
  giving the state authorities the right to restrict freedom of assembly for 
  reasons which are not permitted by the European Convention on Human Rights.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The Assembly insists that the comments 
  of the Venice Commission are fully taken into account in the last reading of 
  the law in the Armenian parliament, and that the freedom of assembly is no 
  longer restricted in the manner which we have seen during the recent events.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The opposition, for its part, shares the 
  responsibility to prevent violence during their rallies.</span></p>
  <p align="justify"><i>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  Conditions of detention</span></i></p>
  <p align="justify">In January, the Assembly asked Armenia 
  to make further efforts to improve conditions of detention, on the basis of 
  recommendations formulated by the Council of Europe&#146;s Committee for the 
  Prevention of Torture (CPT). Regrettably, according to Human Rights Watch, 
  several persons arrested during the recent events were subjected to abuse 
  during their detention by the police. These allegations must be investigated, 
  in a speedy, transparent and credible manner, and if their veracity is 
  confirmed, persons responsible should be punished in accordance with the law. 
  The Armenian authorities should inform the Assembly, in the shortest delays, 
  on the steps it has taken to comply with this request.</span></p>
  <p align="justify"><i>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  Freedom of expression and media</span></i></p>
  <p align="justify">This is a long standing concern, also 
  repeated in January. The situation has hardly improved. The authorities 
  continue to refuse to give the broadcasting licence to the television channel 
  A1+. Moreover, during the recent events several journalists were severely 
  beaten by unknown persons while police were standing by, while others were 
  assaulted and arrested by the security forces themselves. Intimidation of the 
  press through such a conduct will not be tolerated. The lack of media freedom 
  which made it very difficult to obtain accurate information on the recent 
  events was also mentioned in the reaction of the Council of Europe&#146;s Secretary 
  General. </span></p>
  <p align="justify">5</span>.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; 
  Conclusion</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The recent events in Armenia resulted in 
  a worsening of the situation with regard to key concerns expressed by the 
  Assembly in its January report, and notably with regard to the continuation of 
  administrative detention and conditions of detention, human rights violations 
  by members of police and security forces, freedom of assembly, and freedom of 
  media. This situation cannot be allowed to continue. The rapporteurs expect an 
  immediate and significant change in the conduct and legislative practice 
  concerning the respect of Armenia&#146;s obligations and commitments. Failure to do 
  so before the Assembly&#146;s June session could lead to sanctions.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The opposition should enjoy full freedom 
  to conduct their political activities, which include the right to peaceful 
  demonstrations. The authorities should immediately abstain from any 
  interference and administrative and judicial harassment in this regard. </span>
  </p>
  <p align="justify">The fundamental freedoms of expression 
  and assembly must be respected and any restrictions must be in line with the 
  European Convention on Human Rights.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">This being said, the opposition shares 
  the responsibility for ensuring that protests are not marred by violence. The 
  parliament should be the main forum for political arguments. They should not 
  try to circumvent the political institutions in the country with a hope to 
  reverse the results of last year&#146;s elections which were, in spite of 
  criticism, validated both at the domestic level and by the international 
  community.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">The Assembly should not be drawn into 
  accepting artificial analogies between the situations in Georgia and in 
  Armenia. </span></p>
  <p align="justify">The Assembly should focus its efforts on 
  ensuring full compliance with Armenia&#146;s commitments and obligations. Its 
  January Resolution contains all the necessary steps to bring about a 
  qualitative change in the democratic and human rights situation in the 
  country. </span></p>
  <p align="justify">The Armenian authorities must speedily 
  implement the remaining commitments. This would not only reduce the present 
  political tensions (through a full respect of democratic procedures, human 
  rights and fundamental freedoms) but also ensure that future elections in the 
  country are carried out in full compliance with international standards, and 
  thus bring an end to the endemic political instability in Armenia.</span></p>
  <p align="justify">Both the authorities and the opposition 
  should abstain from violence and do their utmost to prevent further incidents. 
  They should engage in a meaningful political dialogue aimed at resolving the 
  tensions and the Assembly is ready to offer its good offices to this effect.</span></p>
  <hr color="#000000" size="1" width="50%">
  <p align="justify"><i>Reporting committee: </span></i>
  Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments 
  by Member States of the Council of Europe (Monitoring Committee)</span></p>
  <p align="justify"><i>Reference to Committee: </span></i>
  Reference No. 2944 of 26 April 2004</span></p>
  <p align="justify"><i>Draft resolution</span></i> 
  unanimously adopted by the Committee on 27 April 2004</span></p>
  <p align="justify"><i>Members of the committee: Mrs Durrieu 
  (Chairperson),</span></i> <i>Mr Frunda, Mrs Tevdoradze, </i>
  Mrs Severinsen(Vice-Chairpersons), <i>Mrs Aguiar</i>, Mr Ak�am, Mr Akhvlediani,
  <i>Mr B. Aliyev</i>, Mr Andr�, Mr Arzilli, <i>Mr Atkinson,</i> <i>Mr Ba&#154;ka</i>,
  <i>Mrs Bauer,</i> Mr Bernik, <i>Mrs Bilgehan</i>, Mr Bindig, Mrs Bousakla, <i>
  Mr van den Brande, Mr Budin, Mrs Burbiene, Mr Cabrnoch</i>, <i>Mr M. Cavusoglu, 
  Mr Cekuolis</i>, Mr Christodoulides<i>, Mr Cilevics, </i>Mr Colombier, Mr 
  Debono Grech, <i>Mrs Delvaux-Stehres</i>, Mr Einarsson, Mr Elo,<i> Mr E�rsi</i>, 
  Mr Glesener, Mr Gross, Mr Grusenbauer, <i>Mr Hancock, </i>Mr Hedrich, Mr Hegyi,
  <i>Mr Herkel, Mr Holovaty</i>, Mrs J��tteenm�ki, Mr Jakic, Mr Jaskiernia, <i>
  Mr Jurgens,</i> Lord Kilclooney<i>, Mr Kirilov</i>, Mrs Konglevoll, <i>Mr 
  Kvakkestad</i>, Mrs Leutheusser-Schnarrenberger, Mr van der Linden, Mr Lintner, 
  Mr Mart�nez Casa�, Mr Marty, Mr Medeiros Ferreira<i>, Mr Melc�k, Mr Mikkelsen</i>,
  <i>Mr Mollazade, </i>Mr O&#146;Keeffe, Mr Olteanu, Mr Pangalos, Mrs 
  Petrova-Mitevska, Mrs Petursdottir, <i>Mr Prijmireanu</i>, <i>Mr Rakhansky</i>,
  <i>Mrs Ringstad,</i> Mr Rivolta, <i>Mr Rustamyan, Mr Sasi, Mrs 
  Shakhtakhtinskaya, Mr Shybko, Mr Slutsky, </i>Mr Smorawinski<i>, Mr 
  Soendergaard</i>, Mr Spindelegger, Mrs Stoyanova, Mr Surjan, <i>Mr Tepshi</i>, 
  Mr Tk�c, Mr Vis, Mrs Wohlwend, Mr Y��ez Barnuevo, Mr Zacchera. </span></p>
  <p align="justify"><i>N.B. The names of those members who 
  were present at the meeting are printed in italics.</span></i></p>
  <p align="justify"><i>Head of the secretariat:</span></i>Mrs 
  Ravaud</span></p>
  <p align="justify"><i>Secretaries to the committee:</span></i> 
  Mr Gruden, Mrs Odrats, Mr Cupina</span></p>
  <hr color="#000000" size="1">
  <p align="justify"><a href="#_ftnref1" name="_ftn1" title>
  [1]</span></a> This chronology is mostly based on 
  information found in the international press.</span></p>
  <p>&nbsp;</p>
</blockquote>
</body>
</html>