<html>
<head>
<meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=iso-8859-1">
<title>Unidroit Convention on stolen or illegally exported cultural objects</title>
<meta name="GENERATOR" content="HTML Transit 7.0 by Stellent (tm), Inc. www.stellent.com">
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="/PortailStyle.css">
</head>
<body bgcolor="#ffffff"><a name="TopOfPage"> </a>
<!-- TRANSIT - INFOBEFORE -->
<table width="100%" border="0" cellpadding="4" cellspacing="0">
  <tr>
    <td><div align="left"><img src="/Documents/LogoText.jpg" width="218" height="48"></div>
    </td>
    <td><div align="right"><img border="0" SRC="/images/logos/Logo130X120.jpg" width="130" height="120"></div>
    </td>
  </tr>
</table>
<hr size="1">

<p align="justify"><b>Doc. 8095</b></p>

<p align="justify">28 April 1998</p>

<p align="justify"><b>Unidroit Convention on stolen or illegally exported cultural objects</b></p>

<p align="justify">Opinion<sup><a href="#P14_106" name="P14_107">1</a></sup></p>

<p align="justify">Committee on Legal Affairs and Human Rights</p>

<p align="justify">Rapporteurs: Mr Vasyl Kostytsky, Ukraine, Group of the European People's Party, and Mr Walter Schwimmer, Austria, Group of the European People's Party </p>

<p><b>I. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Introduction</b></p>

<p align="justify">1.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Unidroit Convention on Stolen or Illegally Exported Cultural objects was concluded in 1995. The Convention was signed by 22 states, ratified by three and acceded to by two states. In accordance with Article 12, paragraph 1 of the Convention, it will enter into force on 1 July 1998 between China, Ecuador, Lithuania, Paraguay and Romania. </p>

<p align="justify">2.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Of course it is primarily the art-&#8220;exporting&#8221; rather than the &#8220;importing&#8221; states that are interested in creating the legal framework for a better protection of the World&#8217;s cultural heritage. The main reason for this lies in the increasing number of illegally exported or stolen cultural goods. In Europe alone 60.000 pieces of art are said to be stolen and exported every year<sup><a href="#P25_1068" name="P25_1069">2</a></sup>. It is therefore of the highest importance to protect the cultural heritage and to avoid further irreparable damage caused by illicit trade.</p>

<p align="justify">3.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Convention intends to facilitate the restitution and return of cultural objects by setting minimal legal rules in this area. It clearly affirms the need for a worldwide co-operation to ensure relevant progress in impeding the continuing pillage of cultural property from developing countries or areas of conflict.</p>

<p align="justify">4.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; A most undesirable aspect of the illegal art trade is the fact that it is increasingly used for money laundering. This certainly is a phenomenon that every state should be willing to fight effectively.</p>

<p align="justify">5.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In spite of a large number of conventions and resolutions concerned with cultural property such as the Hague Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict (May 1954), the UNESCO Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property (1970) or numerous resolutions and recommendations of the Council of Europe, no considerable progress has been made to implement a comprehensive world-wide agreement.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>II.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Scope of the Convention</b></p>

<p align="justify">6.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; First of all it is important to stress that notwithstanding the concerns expressed by a number of developing countries, the Convention does not have any retroactive effect. It therefore does neither affect goods stolen before the entry into force of the Convention nor does it confer any approval or legitimacy upon illegal transactions committed before.</p>

<p align="justify">7.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; According to Article 2 cultural objects for the purposes of the Convention are those which are of importance for archaeology, prehistory, history, literature, art or science. Moreover, they have to belong to one of the categories listed in the Annex to the Convention. This list simply contains a long list of the most diverse kinds of objects imaginable from areas as different as rare collections and specimens of fauna, flora, minerals and anatomy or even revenue or similar stamps or postage. It has to be noted that in contrast to the European Council Directive 93/7 on the Return of Cultural Objects Unlawfully Removed from the Territory of a Member State, the Unidroit Convention does not set any financial threshold.</p>

<p align="justify">8.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The scope of the convention has been subject to criticism. As it is very wide it might lead to uncertainty concerning the precise definition of cultural property for the purposes of the Convention. On the other hand the Convention intends to give a protection to the cultural heritage that is as comprehensive as possible. For that reason it would not be helpful to limit the list of objects more than absolutely necessary. The list provided in the Annex to the Convention does only contain items that are of value or importance for the World&#8217;s cultural heritage.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>III. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Further provisions of the Convention</b></p>

<p align="justify"><b>A. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The <i>bona fide </i>purchase </b></p>

<p align="justify">9.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; According to Article 4, paragraph 1 of the Convention the possessor of stolen property shall be entitled to receive a reasonable compensation for the restitution of the object. In order to be paid this compensation the Convention stipulates that, contrary to most legal systems in the world, it is the possessor who has to prove that he acted in due diligence. It is therefore up to the purchaser to consult any reasonably accessible register of stolen cultural objects and any further relevant information or agencies. What we have here is the reversal of the burden of proof and the end of the presumption of good faith. This is certainly the most significant feature of the Convention and undoubtedly one of the most heavily debated ones. </p>

<p align="justify">10.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The consequences of this provision are evaluated differently. Critics argue that the possessor will find it very difficult to consult registers, as they might sometimes be incomplete or not easily accessible. Worries also concern the willingness of states to institute complete registers. For them it might be of advantage not to make these registers easily accessible to prevent the purchaser from acting in good faith. There has been some concern about the length of the investigations and their costs which have to be borne by the possessor. Finally the existing legal provisions are considered to be sufficiently effective to fight against theft and pillages.</p>

<p align="justify">11.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It should be stressed, however, that in our member States one may count on reasonable court decisions giving equal consideration to both parties and that the reversal of the burden of proof may be considered to be the most important measure in the fight against illegal art trade. Talking about cultural property is not the same as talking about goods in general. Therefore emphasis should not be put on free market regulations but on the protection of outstanding and unique values of cultural heritage. There is an urgent need for international co-operation in particular because national measures have not been sufficiently successful to impede illicit art trade so far.</p>

<p align="justify">12.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In addition there has been some concern about the amount of compensation to be paid. The Convention provides «&nbsp;fair and reasonable compensation&nbsp;» (Article 4, paragraph 1), but the explanatory report of an earlier version of the Convention<sup><a href="#P52_6435" name="P52_6436">3</a></sup> seems to suggest that it is up to the judge to consider not only the market value of the object at issue and the price paid but also the financial capacity of the claimant. It cannot be the intention of the Convention to deter the owner from claiming his property simply because the amount to be paid as compensation exceeds his financial capacity. Taking into account that the «&nbsp;exporting&nbsp;» states are frequently developing states with a limited financial capacity, this provision can be regarded as justifiable if its application does not lead to a disparity between the parties.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>B.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Limitation periods</b></p>

<p align="justify">13.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Article 3, paragraph 3 of the Convention provides that claims for restitution shall be limited to a period of three years from the time  «&nbsp;when the claimant knew the location of the cultural object and the identity of its possessor&nbsp;». In any case claims cannot be brought after fifty years subject to the following exceptions:</p>

<p align="justify">&#8226; the object concerned is either forming an integral part of an identified monument or archaeological site, or is belonging to a public collection</p>

<p align="justify">&#8226; any Contracting State may declare a claim subject to a limitation period of 75 years </p>

<p align="justify">14.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It has been frequently argued that the limitation periods are too long and thereby lead to legal uncertainty. Furthermore they render it more difficult for the possessor to prove his good faith when acquiring the cultural object.</p>

<p align="justify">15.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; On the other hand one can also say that these long periods at the end of the day serve the protection of the owner from whom the object has been stolen. As this is the main incentive behind the Convention at issue one should not consider a limitation period of a maximum of 75 years as too long but as an adequate means to protect the cultural heritage.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>IV. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The position of the art trade</b></p>

<p align="justify">16.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The last two years have shown that one group in particular opposes the Convention, namely the art dealers. From their point of view the Convention does not promote the legal trade in art as it clearly prefers the countries of origin. Furthermore they deem the agreement to grant too limited possibilities for compensation through the heavy demands on the existence of due diligence. They fear that it will not be easy to obtain the required information about stolen goods in some countries of the World due to the huge number of potential cultural objects and to incomplete registers.</p>

<p align="justify">17.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; As far as these worries are concerned one can say that there are indeed some additional requirements to be fulfilled by the dealers, but there are also some advantages for them. Thus, for example, one can certainly expect more security for those interested in purchasing art and a better co-operation in locating stolen goods. This must also be important for those trading in art as far as they are conscious of their responsibility for the World&#8217;s cultural heritage.</p>

<p><b>V. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Further comments</b></p>

<p align="justify">18.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Whereas states can always recover stolen objects from the purchaser, an illegally exported piece of art may only be reclaimed if it is protected by national export legislation. This might lead to the situation that states protect all cultural objects which fall within the scope of Article 2 of the Convention. Therefore the list of objects protected against theft is longer than the list of objects protected against illegal export. </p>

<p align="justify">19.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Convention demands changes of the domestic legislation in several countries especially in the field of export regulations. This might be one of the main reasons why a number of states did not yet accede to the agreement. Some countries see difficulties, as their export regulations are too liberal to be compatible with the wording of the Convention.</p>

<p align="justify">20.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It has also been criticised that no reservation can be made to the Convention and certain countries are reluctant to accede to the whole agreement. One might be inclined to say that a partial acceptance of the convention would serve its purpose better than no acceptance at all. But this is not necessarily true. In the interest of all the cultural property stolen and illegally exported every year a partial acceptance will not be of much help. As the attempts to fight illegal art trade have revealed so far there is a need for stricter rules to achieve a satisfying outcome. The wording of the Convention had to be strict and partial adoption does not support the intention of its authors.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>VI. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Conclusions and amendments</b></p>

<p align="justify">21.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Convention attempts to strike a balance between the efficient combat of crime and the smooth running of trade &#8211; which are not always compatible. Whenever one aspect is emphasised the other one will automatically suffer. It would therefore be difficult to find a solution that fully satisfies all parties involved. Yet, despite of the concerns and potential obstacles mentioned above, the Unidroit Convention might effectively contribute to the preservation of the World&#8217;s cultural heritage, especially in developing countries threatened by theft and illegal exports. Probably the positive effects of the Convention outweigh the fact that it is not regarded positively by the majority of art dealers. As said above, the Convention is not primarily aiming at providing for smoothly running commerce but at avoiding irreparable damage to the art and culture of the World. If we want the World&#8217;s cultural heritage to persist we should not be reluctant to take unusual measures as experience proves that the existing legal provisions, international and national, do not achieve their aim to the satisfaction of those trying to protect items of outstanding importance for the cultural heritage of humanity.</p>

<p align="justify">22.  &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Commission on Legal Affairs and Human Rights supports the Report of the Committee on Culture and Education but wishes to propose the following amendments to the draft recommendation&nbsp;:</p>

<p align="justify"><b>Amendment a)</b></p>

<p align="justify">In sub-paragraph 8.i, replace the word &quot;adopt&quot; by the word &quot;ratify&quot; and after the word &quot;member&quot; add the words &quot;and observer&quot;.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>Amendment b)</b></p>

<p align="justify">At the end of sub-paragraph 8.iv, add the words &quot;and extend, if necessary, the mandate of the North-South Centre to this effect.&quot;.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>Amendment c)</b></p>

<p align="justify">In sub-paragraph 8.viii, replace &quot;and prepare the way for setting up special international police units&quot; by</p>

  <ul><p align="justify">&quot;, ensure that there are sufficient police officers specialised in criminality concerning art objects and step up international police cooperation in this field.&quot;</p>

  <p align="justify"><u>Explanation of this amendment</u>:</p>

  <p align="justify">Until now no special international police units on a permanent basis have been set up. It is unlikely that this will be done in the field of art objects. Especially since international police cooperation with <u>non</u>-member States is to be stepped up the amendment will be more realistic than the existing text.</p>

</ul><p align="justify"><i>Reporting committee:</i> Committee on Culture and Education (<a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc=Doc. 8001">Doc. 8001</a>)</p>

<p align="justify"><i>Committee for opinion:</i> Committee on Legal Affairs and Human Rights</p>

<p align="justify"><i>Reference to committee:</i> <a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc=Doc 7252">Doc 7252</a> and Reference No. 2034 of 25 September 1995</p>

<p align="justify"><i>Opinion</i> approved by the committee on 21 April 1998 </p>

<p align="justify"><i>Secretaries to the committee:</i> Mr Plate, Ms Coin and Ms Kleinsorge </p>
<hr align="left" size="1" width="200" noshade>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P14_106" href="#P14_107">1</a> </sup> See <a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc=Doc 8001">Doc 8001</a>.</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P25_1068" href="#P25_1069">2</a> </sup> According to other sources Italy alone suffers from the loss of 20.000 cultural objects per year</p>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P52_6435" href="#P52_6436">3</a> </sup> Explanatory Report on the draft text dated 20 December 1994 (Unidroit 1994, Conf. 8/3), no. 60, 20.</p><!-- TRANSIT - INFOAFTER -->
</body>
</html>
