<html>
<head>
<meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=iso-8859-1">
<title>Nature and scope of the contractually acquired rights of Council of Europe staff</title>
<meta name="GENERATOR" content="HTML Transit 7.0 by Stellent (tm), Inc. www.stellent.com">
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="/PortailStyle.css">
</head>
<body bgcolor="#ffffff"><a name="TopOfPage"> </a>
<!-- TRANSIT - INFOBEFORE -->
<table width="100%" border="0" cellpadding="4" cellspacing="0">
  <tr>
    <td><div align="left"><img src="/Documents/LogoText.jpg" width="218" height="48"></div>
    </td>
    <td><div align="right"><img border="0" SRC="/images/logos/Logo130X120.jpg" width="130" height="120"></div>
    </td>
  </tr>
</table>
<hr size="1">

<p align="justify"><b>For debate in the Standing Committee see Rule 15 of the Rules of Procedure</b></p>

<p align="justify"><b>Pour débat à la Commission permanente &#8211; Voir article 15 du Règlement</b></p>

<p align="justify"><b>Doc. 8868</b></p>

<p align="justify">11 October 2000</p>

<p><b>Nature and scope of the contractually acquired rights of Council of Europe staff</b></p>

<p align="justify">Report</p>

<p align="justify">Committee on the Budget</p>

<p align="justify">Rapporteur: Mr Giuseppe Aleffi, Italy, Group of the European People&#8217;s Party</p>

<p align="justify"><i>Summary</i></p>

<p align="justify">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;The concepts of &#8220;contractual relationship&#8221; and &#8220;acquired rights&#8221; are characteristic of international civil service law in the Council of Europe and virtually all international organisations.  Contractual relationship refers to the relationship between a staff member and the Organisation as evidenced in the first and final analysis in a contract.  Acquired rights refer to the inviolability of the conditions of employment stipulated in the contract provided that such conditions could have been regarded as fundamental by the member of staff concerned when he or she decided to join the Organisation.</p>

<p align="justify">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;The case-law of international administrative tribunals, including that of the Council of Europe, has clarified and refined the concept of acquired rights, which represent a genuine check on the power of international organisations to modify administrative regulations to the detriment of serving staff.</p>

<p align="justify">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;At present, the concerns of Council of Europe staff with regard to the honouring of acquired rights relate to two fundamental areas: pensions and remuneration.</p>

<p align="justify">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;As far as pensions are concerned, the co-ordinated scheme in force does not allow for financial balance to be achieved by reducing benefits.  A study of the <i>travaux préparatoires</i> of the 94<sup>th</sup> Report of the Co-ordinating Committee of Government Budget Experts (CCG), which set up the scheme, shows that the authors deliberately ruled out this possibility.  Furthermore, governments have displayed a deplorable lack of foresight with regard to the rising actuarial cost of the scheme; this rise was foreseen with astonishing accuracy back in 1974 and it would be wrong for governments to make staff members suffer the consequences of this improvidence.</p>

<p align="justify">As far as remuneration is concerned, only objective and mathematical salary adjustment methods can satisfy the requirement for transparency upheld by the Council of Europe&#8217;s Administrative Tribunal in 1994.  Moreover, the Council of Europe must ensure it is in a position to recruit and retain a competent and independent staff.  It is also reasonable for adjustment methods to take account of budgetary policies and, therefore, of any restrictive policies adopted by governments at national level.</p>

<p align="justify"><b>I.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Draft recommendation</b></p>

<p align="justify">1.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; By virtue of the contract binding them to the Organisation, Council of Europe staff enjoy a series of inalienable rights in accordance with the case-law of international administrative tribunals.</p>

<p align="justify">2.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Acquired rights concern the contractual provisions which may have played a fundamental part in the individual&#8217;s decision to join the staff of the Organisation.</p>

<p align="justify">3.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Accordingly, there are limitations on the power of the Organisation to amend administrative rules applicable to serving staff.  In particular, such amendments:</p>

<p align="justify">i.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; must not be retroactive;</p>

<p align="justify">ii.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; must not be alien to the proper functioning of the Organisation and to its duty to attract the most highly qualified staff;</p>

<p align="justify">iii.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; must be based on a precise assessment of the situation in issue;</p>

<p align="justify">iv.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; must be made in good faith;</p>

<p align="justify">v.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; must be introduced in a reasonable manner so as to avoid any excessive or unnecessary harm to staff.</p>

<p align="justify">4.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Council of Europe, by its very nature and the values it defends, has a duty to be an &#8220;organisation upholding the rule of law&#8221;, that is to say, it must fully honour staff rights in the context of legal relations between the administration and staff.</p>

<p align="justify">5.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; At present, pressure exerted by certain governments on the majority of international organisations pose a challenge to the fundamental rights acquired by staff, particularly in the field of pensions and remuneration.</p>

<p align="justify">6.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Assembly, conscious of the intentions of numerous delegations represented on the Co-ordinating Committee on Remuneration (CCR) to cut back the pension scheme with adverse consequences for both serving and retired staff, believes it has a duty to draw the attention of the Committee of Ministers to the potentially serious consequences of any disregard for staff&#8217;s contractually acquired rights.</p>

<p align="justify">7.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Assembly accordingly recommends that the Committee of Ministers:</p>

<p align="justify">i.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; inform the CCR that it is legally not feasible to reform the co-ordinated pension scheme by reducing the benefits provided for staff, since the possibility of modifying benefits was intentionally ruled out by the authors of the Pension Scheme Rules, as is confirmed by a study of the <i>travaux préparatoires</i> of the 94<sup>th</sup> Report of the Co-ordinating Committee of Government Budget Experts (CCG) which set up the Pension Scheme;</p>

<p align="justify">ii.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; also inform the CCR that its intention to introduce these amendments is based exclusively on the improvidence of governments in the face of the predictable and predicted costs of the scheme, and that this basis has nothing to do with the smooth functioning of the organisations;</p>

<p align="justify">iii.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; engage with the staff, who remain deprived of a genuine right of negotiation in the co-ordinated context, in a dialogue to identify the few anomalies and imperfections of the pension scheme which could be rectified in agreement with staff representatives;</p>

<p align="justify">iv.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; bear in mind the negative consequences for social peace in the Organisation which could result from a reduction in benefits promised to staff;</p>

<p align="justify">v.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; with regard to pay, comply with the rule formulated by the Council of Europe&#8217;s Administrative Tribunal in 1994 according to which &#8220;methods adopted in this important matter [adjustment of Council of Europe staff remuneration] require to be highly transparent so as to avert suspicion or mistrust, which cannot but damage the climate of mutual understanding and full co-operation necessary in an international organisation like the Council of Europe&#8221;;</p>

<p align="justify">vi.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; recommend to the CCR, to this end, that it propose for all the 5 coordinated organisations salary adjustment methods which are objective and mathematical and take full account, as is the case with the so-called &#8220;parallelism&#8221; rule, of budgetary policies adopted at national level;</p>

<p align="justify">vii.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; observe the principles of equal opportunities and fair geographical distribution in its recruitment policy;</p>

<p align="justify">viii.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; ensure that the Organisation can rely at all times on a competent and independent staff, which implies being able both to recruit and to retain staff; to this end, Council of Europe staff remuneration must remain competitive with regard to the three recruitment markets named in the method currently in force (private sector; national civil services, including expatriated civil servants; the international civil service, including the European Union).</p>

<p align="justify"><b>II. Explanatory memorandum by the rapporteur</b></p>

<p align="justify"><b>I.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Concepts of &#8220;contractual relationship&#8221; and &#8216;acquired rights&#8221; in international civil service law</b></p>

<p align="justify">1.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The life of any international organisation is constantly prey to two opposing forces.  On the one hand, the international organisation must adapt its administrative rules to developments both in the international community and in societies in member states.  Accordingly, it is required to amend the rules governing its employment law, ie the law governing its own  public service.  On the other hand, when international civil servants sign their contracts, they acquire rights which the Organisation cannot amend above and beyond what may be considered reasonable and fair.  At the outset, therefore, two concepts must be stated: the first concerns the contractual situation in which international organisation staff are placed; the second the concept of &#8220;acquired rights&#8221; in international civil service law.</p>

<p align="justify">2.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The contractual situation or &#8220;contractual relationship&#8221; contrasts with the statutory &#8220;situation&#8221; or &#8220;relationship&#8221;, ie which is based on status.  A contractual relationship refers to the relationship between the staff member and the international organisation as evidenced in the first and final analysis in a contract.  The statutory relationship on the other hand refers to the appointment of civil servants by acts of authority.  Obviously, in the practice of contemporary states, an individual who agrees to enter the public service gives full consent.  Consensus &#8211; in the case of statutory relationship &#8211; is therefore a de facto precondition of appointment, which nevertheless is formally based on an act of authority.</p>

<p align="justify">3.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; By contrast, in the contractual situation, appointment is based on a contract, ie a bilateral act.</p>

<p align="justify">4.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The appointment of a civil servant by an act of authority is common to all modern states, whereas among international organisations only the European Communities have a public service based on a relationship of this type.</p>

<p align="justify">5.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Council of Europe staff are in a &#8220;contractual situation&#8221;.  The contractual relationship derives from the particular situation of the first international organisations: there were no rules applicable to all civil servants, of whom, incidentally, there were very few.  Conditions of employment were specified only in individual contracts.  In such cases, it was held that the organisation concluded a contract, or indeed an agreement, with each civil servant considered in isolation.  For some authors such as Akehurst (<i>The Law Governing Employment in International Organisations</i>, Cambridge University Press, 1967) it was indeed an agreement in the international sense, ie a bilateral legal act to which the rule <i>pacta sunt servanda</i> applied.  A statutory relationship implies that if the contract concluded individually between the organisation and the civil servant contains provisions contrary to the regulations and the statute, it is the contract which has predominance over the regulations or statute.</p>

<p align="justify">6.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; For example, an appellant claimed before the Administrative Tribunal of the Council of Europe that the Administration had wrongly refused to grant her the expatriation allowance.  This was not included in her employment contract but she claimed she was entitled to it in accordance with one interpretation of the relevant rule.  The Administrative Tribunal looked at the complaint and circumstances of the case in detail and concluded that the decision taken by the Secretary General of the Council of Europe was based on a correct interpretation of the rule.  However, the Tribunal did not merely verify whether the situation complied with the Staff Regulations; it looked at whether there was any agreement &#8211; written or verbal &#8211; which, contrary to the provisions in force, would have meant that the appellant was entitled to the expatriation allowance.</p>

<p align="justify">7.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Following its research, the Tribunal noted that the offer of employment did not grant an expatriation allowance, but a residence allowance. &#8220;<i>In full knowledge of the facts</i>&#8221;, the Tribunal states, &#8220;<i>the appellant accepted the offer in a letter dated 14 December 1993</i>.&#8221;  The Tribunal further stated &#8220;<i>Nothing in the interviews which preceded her recruitment created an entitlement to the expatriation allowance which she is now claiming &#8230;&#8221;</i>  In other terms, the Tribunal found that there had been no verbal commitments.</p>

<p align="justify">8.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; As was to be expected, the Tribunal explained the basis of its research:</p>

<p align="justify"><i>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&#8220;Under general legal principles recognised in international case-law, in particular the principle of good faith, the Organisation is required to honour any undertakings it has given &#8230;&#8221;9.</i></p>

<p align="justify">9.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; This statement makes no distinction between the undertakings entered into in contravention of the rules in force and those entered into in compliance with the same rules.  The Decision (Appeal no 188/1994, <i>Keller v. Secretary General</i>) therefore provides a very high level of protection against the unilateral amendment by the Organisation of conditions of service.</p>

<p align="justify">10.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Other decisions, including those of other administrative tribunals or appeals boards could be quoted, such as <i>Decision no. 1</i> of the OECD Administrative Tribunal delivered on 6 July 1992.  In this case, contrary to the applicable regulations, an expatriation allowance had been granted by the OECD administration.  The Tribunal noted that &#8220;<i>the expatriation allowance was awarded to the applicant on the basis of an express agreement between the parties and not simply by reference to the Staff Regulations&#8221;</i>.</p>

<p align="justify">11.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; These two decisions suffice to show the primacy of the contractual relationship in international civil service law.  Commitments entered into in the initial contract must be honoured.</p>

<p align="justify">12.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The case-law concerning acquired rights is a genuine barrier which the international administrative tribunals have erected to contain the power of the legislative bodies of the international organisations to amend unilaterally rules relating to the status of their civil servants.  A distinction must be made between those international organisations where respect for acquired rights is contained in the staff regulations and the rest.  &#8220;Acquired rights&#8221; are explicitly protected in the staff regulations of the following organisations: the World Health Organisation (WHO), the International Labour Organisation (ILO), UNESCO, the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), the International Maritime Organisation (IMO) and the FAO.  Among the co-ordinated organisations, the staff regulations of OECD and the European Space Agency contain rules of this type.  The NATO Civilian Personnel Regulations establish the concept of &#8220;contractual rights&#8221;.  This relates to all the provisions contained in or referred to by the contract.  These provisions are excluded from those which may be unilaterally amended by the organisation.  In other words, if there is any detrimental amendment to the staff regulations, serving staff continue to benefit from the more favourable rules which are for them &#8220;contractual rights&#8221; proper.</p>

<p align="justify">13.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Nevertheless, it would be wrong to think that these concepts cannot be applied in international organisations which do not explicitly recognise acquired rights.  The concepts of acquired rights and contractual rights have become part of the legal patrimony of the international organisations including the Council of Europe via the decisions of the international administrative tribunals.  In this connection, it should not be forgotten that the internal law of international organisations has a number of gaps.  International administrative tribunals &#8211; of which there are at present 23 for a total of 100,000 international civil servants &#8211; are in practice faced with cases which cannot be resolved simply by reference to the internal law of the organisation.  Accordingly, in order to fill the gaps, these international tribunals have to turn to &#8220;international principles of law&#8221; or &#8220;international principles of the international civil service&#8221;.</p>

<p align="justify">14.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; These international principles of law are nowhere codified.  The international tribunals, in order to fill certain gaps, attempt to formulate a number of basic principles bearing in mind the guidelines specific to certain legal systems.  In the majority of cases this is the law of continental Europe for the simple reason that the operating rules of the administrative tribunals and appeals procedures in general in the international civil service are based on the law of continental Europe and France in particular rather than the law of the English-speaking world.  References to legal solutions adopted in these systems form a sort of legal &#8220;resource&#8221; which the international tribunals use in order to formulate concepts applicable to the international organisations.</p>

<p align="justify">15.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It is not an exact science but an empirical technique.  The repetition of this technique by different international tribunals required to interpret the provisions applicable in a large number of international organisations has led to the establishment &#8211; on the basis of general principles of law &#8211; of general principles of the international civil service.  In other words, the general principles of the international civil service are merely general principles of law adapted to the specific situation of international organisations and restated with some frequency by administrative tribunals in their case-law.</p>

<p align="justify">16.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Coming back to acquired rights, to quote ambassador Plantey (<i>Droit et pratiques de la fonction publique internationale</i> &#8211; Paris, Editions du CNRS &#8211; 1977) &#8220;<i>clearly, the concept of acquired rights is one of the most complex in the law of the civil service and the disputes to which this concept gives rise are generally extremely delicate.&#8221;</i></p>

<p align="justify">17.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; With regard to the definitions in case-law of acquired rights, there are four main trends:</p>

<p align="justify">a)&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The trend shown by the UN administrative tribunal (hereinafter referred to as UNAT) with jurisdiction for hearing disputes between the members of staff of the UN and the organisation, and the staff of a limited number of specialist institutions and their respective administrations.</p>

<p align="justify">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;This is the most restrictive case-law in the matter.  As far as the UNAT is concerned only the clauses incorporated into the contract are inviolate.  In other words, if a contract is signed subject to the provisions of the staff regulations, all regulatory acts are excluded from acquired rights and can therefore be amended in the future.  Nevertheless, any amendments must satisfy three criteria: they must be &#8220;reasonable&#8221;, must not be &#8220;arbitrary&#8221; and must not entail &#8220;confiscation or spoliation&#8221; (<i>cf Judgment no 338/1986 Bohn and others)</i>.</p>

<p align="justify">b.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The case-law of the Administrative Tribunal of the International Labour Organisation (ILOAT): this is the competent court to hear disputes between ILO staff members and the administration, and the majority of the UN specialist institutions and their staff, as well as a large number of other international organisations such as the European Patent Organisation.</p>

<p align="justify">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;The ILOAT case-law (cf, for example, <i>Judgment no. 61/1962 Lindsey)</i> makes a fundamental distinction between three categories of provisions:</p>

  <ul><p align="justify">i&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; the rules appertaining to the structure and functioning of the international civil service and benefits of an impersonal nature.  These may be amended at any time subject to the legality of the acts and general principles of law (eg non-retroactivity).  They are regulatory provisions both in form and in substance;</p>

  <p align="justify">i&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; provisions which lay down the individual terms and conditions of service of staff in consideration of which they accepted appointment.  These are contractual provisions both in form and in substance.  They may be amended only with the consent of staff or provided they do not adversely affect the balance of the contract.  The Tribunal requires that they do not infringe the essential terms in consideration of which the staff member agreed to sign the contract;</p>

  <p align="justify">i&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; provisions included expressly or by implication in the contract.  These are regulatory in form and contractual in substance.</p>

</ul><p align="justify">c)&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The case-law of the NATO Appeals Board reiterates and enlarges the case-law of the ILOAT.  Changes to provisions which are &#8220;regulatory in substance&#8221; are also of a nature, if the balance of the contract is adversely affected, to allow the staff member to terminate the contract or seek compensation.  This case-law (see, for example, Decision no. 57 of the NATO Appeals Board) applies the concept of the balance of the contract to all regulatory provisions governing the status of staff.  In this way, the Appeals Board seeks to ensure that the balance of the contract is not upset not only with regard to regulatory provisions laying down individual conditions &#8211; which the ILOAT regarded virtually as contractual stipulations &#8211; but also with regard to a series of regulatory provisions governing the structure and functioning of the international civil service, to which, however, the ILOAT did not apply the concept of the balance of the contract.  <i>Decisions nos. 106, 107, 108 </i>of 30 and 31 October 1979 and <i>111</i> of 14 January 1981 are of particular relevance, for the Board states that even an unlawful act can give rise to an acquired right.  This concept accordingly is an obstacle to the withdrawal of the unlawful act by the administrative authority.  The principle of honouring acquired rights has primacy over the rule applicable to national civil services that there can be no right <i>contra legem</i>.</p>

<p align="justify">d)&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The case-law of the World Bank Administrative Tribunal.  In the <i>de Merode case (Decision no. 1</i> &#8211; 1981), the Tribunal maintained that the Bank had an inherent power to amend the general and impersonal rules establishing the rights and duties of staff.  The Tribunal considered that the power to create rules implied in principle the power to change them.  This was a well established legal principle.  The Tribunal then looked at whether changes made by the Bank could apply to staff members employed before their adoption.  The Tribunal concluded that the Bank had the power unilaterally to amend conditions of service, but that there were &#8220;<i>significant limitations&#8221;</i> upon the exercise of such power.  The Tribunal added that no-one would wish to be employed in an organisation in which there were no limits at all to the power of the employer.  In an attempt at defining the limits of the power of amendment, the Tribunal drew a major distinction between elements in the conditions of employment: some were fundamental and essential in the balance of staff rights; others were less so.  Consequently, the former could not changed without the consent of the staff member affected, whereas the latter could be unilaterally changed, subject to certain limits and conditions.  To sum up, in the view of the Tribunal, only non-fundamental and non-essential elements can be unilaterally amended by the employer.  Moreover, these amendments have to satisfy the following criteria:</p>

  <ul><p align="justify">i&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; they must not be retroactive,</p>

  <p align="justify">i&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; they must not be alien to the proper functioning of the organisation and to its duty to ensure that it has a staff possessing the highest standards of efficiency and technical competence,</p>

  <p align="justify">i&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; they must be based on a precise assessment of the situation in issue (changes must be reasonably related to the objective which they are intended to achieve),</p>

  <p align="justify">i&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; they must be made in good faith,</p>

  <p align="justify">i&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; they must not be discriminatory,</p>

  <p align="justify">i&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; they must be introduced in a reasonable manner seeking to avoid excessive and unnecessary harm to staff.</p>

</ul><p align="justify">18.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; To sum up, in the view of the World Bank Administrative Tribunal, justification for the inviolability of certain conditions of employment is to be found in their fundamental and essential nature.</p>

<p align="justify">19.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; A general conclusion can be drawn from this overview of case-law.  The concept of acquired rights assumes in the law of international organisations a richer and deeper significance than in the law of national civil services.  In the latter, it expresses &#8211; in contrast to the idea of innateness &#8211; a situation or quality not present initially which has developed over time.  In the international civil service, the concept of acquired rights refers in particular to inviolable situations or qualities, ie which are not affected by the passing of time.</p>

<p align="justify">20.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The problem of acquired rights may occur in theory for any right provided for in the staff regulations.  Part IV of the Council of Europe&#8217;s Staff Regulations deals specifically with the following &#8220;<i>rights of staff members&#8221;</i>: protection of staff members in their official capacity, remuneration, payment of expenses by the Council, social security, indemnity for loss of job, leave, personal administrative files, freedom of association, certificate of employment.</p>

<p align="justify">21.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In practice, two sensitive areas of concern to Council of Europe staff are currently under threat: pensions and remuneration (covering both pay and allowances).</p>

<p align="justify"><b>II.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Current problems: pensions and remuneration</b></p>

  <ul><p align="justify">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;a)<u>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Acquired rights and pensions</u></p>

</ul><p align="justify">22.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It is commonly accepted that pensions are deferred salary.  International civil service law coincides on this point with administrative law in continental Europe.  This fact indicates the relationship between the problem of pensions and that of salary adjustment.  Pensions, together with salaries, are a factor which can induce the most competent candidates to join an international organisation.</p>

<p align="justify">23.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In addition, providence &#8211; and consequently the introduction of an appropriate pension scheme &#8211; must be considered as one means of guaranteeing the independence of international civil servants, in other words their loyalty and exclusive allegiance to the international organisation employing them.</p>

<p align="justify">24.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It should not be forgotten that the Staff Regulations state that the obligations of discretion and loyalty do not cease upon the termination of duties but continue beyond this and are part of, and thus condition, the retired staff member&#8217;s life.</p>

<p align="justify">25.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The pension scheme common to the Co-ordinated Organisations was set up following the adoption by the Councils of the 94<sup>th</sup> Report of the Co-ordinating Committee of Government Budget Experts (CCG).</p>

<p align="justify">26.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; This report came down heavily in favour of a pension scheme common to the Co-ordinated Organisation.  In particular, the wish was to set up a co-ordinated system similar to that of the European Communities, especially with regard to benefits.  It should be noted that at the time &#8220;co-ordination&#8221; was considered a value in itself.  Accordingly, the setting up of a common pension scheme was both logical and appropriate.  Once this principle had been established, it was necessary to choose between the different possible financing systems: capitalisation (funding), affiliation of the Co-ordinated Organisations staff to the ordinary-law regime of the country in which they were in post, pay-as-you-go, budgetisation.</p>

<p align="justify">27.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; For several reasons, which it would take too too long to analyse here, the Co-ordinating Committee recommended a budgetised system which made it easier to introduce a single pension scheme for all staff of the Co-ordinated Organisations.  Furthermore, it was a scheme very similar to that of the European Communities and the majority of member states.</p>

<p align="justify">28.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In order to apply the Pension Scheme Rules uniformly, the heads of administration decided in September 1974 to set up the Administrative Committee on Pensions of the Co-ordinated Organisations (CAPOC).  Four years later, on 1 May 1978, the Joint Pensions Administration Section (JAPS) was set up tasked with the overall management of the co-ordinated application of the pension scheme under the supervision of the CAPOC chair, and at the same time acting as the CAPOC secretariat.</p>

<p align="justify">29.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Co-ordinating Committee on Remuneration (CCR) has just sent the Councils of the Co-ordinated Organisations a report outlining two different options (the first being a fully funded scheme, the second a mixed scheme) to be applied from 1 January 2000 to new staff.  The two proposed options do not appear to guarantee competitive pay and could therefore have serious consequences on the recruitment of future staff.</p>

<p align="justify">30.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; At the same time the report shows a desire to interfere with the benefits enjoyed by serving staff.  The staff have shown their profound discontent at threats which they consider to be extremely unjust through strike action and demonstrations in all the Co-ordinated Organisations.</p>

<p align="justify">31.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe should ensure that there is no interference with the acquired rights of the organisation&#8217;s staff in order to ensure staff relations remain conflict-free and to avoid legal wrangles requiring a great deal of energy which could be used to better effect elsewhere.</p>

<p align="justify">32.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; To put the problem fully in context, it must first of all be realised that for serving staff it is not only the concept of acquired rights which is an issue; there are also other concepts such as legitimate expectation, legal security and proportionality.  Even the most restrictive international case-law, that of the UNAT, demands &#8211; as seen above &#8211; that modifications to the pension scheme rules which have an adverse effect must satisfy the following three criteria:</p>

<p align="justify">i&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; they must be reasonable,</p>

<p align="justify">i&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; they must not be &#8220;arbitrary&#8221;,</p>

<p align="justify">i&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; they must not entail &#8220;confiscation or spoliation&#8221;.</p>

<p align="justify">33.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; For its part, the ILOAT stated that a <i>reduction in pension rights affects acquired rights, as pension rights are of crucial importance in the staff member&#8217;s decision to accept appointment</i>.  Furthermore, the reasons whereby modifications are possible must be considered in detail.  For some twenty years, the scheme has been financed almost exclusively by staff contributions.  Contrary to what happened in the UN Joint Staff Pension Fund &#8211; where the employer consistently pays its contributions &#8211; member states of the Co-ordinated Organisations not only have not contributed (or only to a very limited extent) to the scheme, but in addition, they have set up no reserve fund which could lessen the financial burden on them when &#8211; as could be and was foreseen in the CCR&#8217;s 94<sup>th</sup> report &#8211; they would have to increase their contributions to the scheme.  Reasons for any changes to conditions of employment are, in fact, a major element of appreciation for administrative tribunals.  A desire to escape the clearly foreseen consequences of choices made in the past should not be considered a valid reason for reducing benefits due to serving and retired staff.</p>

<p align="justify">34.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In addition, the Pension Scheme Rules applicable to all the Co-ordinated Organisations provide in Chapter IX (&#8220;<i>Financing the pension scheme&#8221;</i>) only for one possibility of re-balancing the system in the event of an excessive increase in cost, namely increasing staff contributions.  A lowering of benefits is quite simply not provided for by Governments.  Is this an oversight?  Should it be considered that the organisations retain the implicit power to modify benefits for serving staff?  Reference to the <i>travaux préparatoires</i> of the CCG&#8217;s 94<sup>th</sup> Report shows that the authors deliberately ruled out the possibility of modifying benefits.  The Pension Scheme Rules were modelled for the reasons given above on those in force in the European Communities.  The EC rules do provide for re-balancing by means of lowering benefits.  It is easy to conclude therefore that the Pension Scheme Rules exclude this possibility and that this exclusion is part of the balance of the contract.</p>

<p align="justify">35.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It is in this spirit that the Chairman of the Committee of Staff Representatives (CSR), in a letter sent to the CCR Chairman following the adoption of the &#8220;Noordwijk compromise&#8221;<sup><a href="#P187_30562" name="P187_30563">1</a></sup>, stressed that the maintenance of the benefits stipulated was the precondition on which CRP negotiation and agreement were based.  These words by the CRP Chairman have never been refuted orally or in writing by the CCR Chairman or any other authority in the Co-ordinated Organisations.</p>

<p align="justify">36.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The acquired rights of the Co-ordinated Organisations&#8217; staffs, and consequently the staff of the Council of Europe, in the field of pensions therefore appear sound for all the reasons set out above.  Accordingly, it is difficult to accept the legality of changes to benefits for serving staff.</p>

<p align="justify">37.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; As far as pensions are concerned, it is worthwhile pointing out that in accordance with the fundamental principles of the international civil service as conceived since the founding of the League of Nations, budgetary concerns should have no bearing on the establishment of the rights and obligations of international civil servants.  It would be wrong, in the interests of making budgetary savings, to limit the independence of international civil servants for fear of undermining the bases of the international civil service.  This consideration is a particularly apposite one with which to introduce the subject of remuneration.</p>

  <ul><p align="justify">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;b)<u>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Remuneration (salaries and allowances)</u></p>

</ul><p align="justify">38.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The international tribunals have delivered a significant number of decisions on acquired rights and remuneration, such as UNAT&#8217;s <i>Judgment No. 19/1953</i> in the <i>Kaplan</i> case, which included salary among the contractual clauses and thus outside the scope of unilateral modification by the employer.  In so doing, tribunals have followed the 1932 report by the Committee of Jurists to the Chair of the 1<sup>st</sup> Committee of the Assembly of the League of Nations.  This report stated that the maintenance of staff salaries was an acquired right in that it was stipulated in contracts.  Accordingly, the League of Nations Assembly, even in the exercise of its budgetary authority, had no right to reduce staff salaries.  The organisation had a duty to make provision in its budget for adequate resources to pay the salaries in relation to which staff could legitimately assert their acquired rights.  The report stipulated that a reduction could only be made in accordance with an agreement concluded individually with each member of staff.</p>

<p align="justify">39.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; An analysis of international case-law also shows that the tribunals are competent to verify whether an organisation&#8217;s legislative body has honoured its commitments with regard to salaries.  In the Co-ordinated Organisations salary adjustment methods have a validity period.  The directing bodies of the Co-ordinated Organisations are bound to comply with the rules during this period.  Accordingly, staff have a genuine individual right that this method be meticulously followed during the period in question.  The tribunals have confirmed their power to overturn acts of the Council (the Committee of Ministers in the Council of Europe&#8217;s case).  This derives from an interpretation based on general principles of law.  Recently, the Administrative Tribunal of the Council of Europe in its decision on <i>Appeals nos. 182-185/1994 (Auer and others)</i> asserted that it was &#8220;<i>competent to rule on a decision or measure taken by the Secretary General where, as here, he was bound to implement a Committee of Ministers decision which he had no means of challenging&#8221;</i>.</p>

<p align="justify">40.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The same decision contains a particularly significant passage:</p>

<p align="justify">&#8220;methods adopted in this important matter [adjustment of Council of Europe staff remuneration] require to be highly transparent so as to avert suspicion or mistrust, which cannot but damage the climate of mutual understanding and full co-operation necessary in an international organisation like the Council of Europe.&#8221;</p>

<p align="justify">41.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It is questionable whether the CCR&#8217;s 80<sup>th</sup> Report which currently governs the &#8220;salary adjustment method&#8221; for the staff of the Co-ordinated Organisations satisfies these criteria.  This is because for the years 1998 and 2001, the results of the method are merely indicative adjustment indices which may be modified and even rejected if, by a subjective appreciation, the Councils (Committee of Ministers in the case of the Council of Europe) decide that there are &#8220;exceptional budgetary circumstances&#8221;.  The question to be asked is whether Council of Europe staff have a right to a method for calculating their remuneration which is objective and mathematical and not simply indicative.  Of course, this need not be a method carved in stone once and for all, but a method which would have &#8211; as has always been the case since 1958 &#8211; a period of validity, and which would be applied to the letter during that period.</p>

<p align="justify">42.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The staff claim that they have acquired by custom the right to a method of this type.  This is an interesting argument.  In fact, in the legal systems of the international organisations, administrative practice is a source of law.  In addition, custom does indeed operate in the internal legal systems of international organisations.</p>

<p align="justify">43.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Furthermore, it should not be forgotten that any misuse of power could affect the legality of the Council&#8217;s decisions and cause them to be null and void.  To put it clearly, if a decision which declared that a salary increase was unaffordable in budgetary terms was made solely on the grounds of expediency or political &#8220;affordability&#8221;, such a decision could be construed as a misuse of power.</p>

<p align="justify">44.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Secondly, the general rule of international civil service law has to be applied whereby organisations must seek to recruit and retain highly skilled staff.  It should be noted in this connection that in the 80<sup>th</sup> Report, the Councils of the Co-ordinated Organisations set out the principle of a constant comparison between the salaries paid by the Co-ordinated Organisations and the three recruitment markets (national civil services including expatriate civil servants; international civil service; private sector).  It is implicit that the adjustment method must be designed in such a way as to prevent the co-ordinated salaries from losing their competitiveness even in relation to just one of the markets concerned.</p>

<p align="justify">45.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The above criteria, in particular the absence of abuse of power and compliance with the rule concerning the recruitment of competent international civil servants, must be monitored not only with regard to any application by the Councils of affordability clauses specific to the organisation, but also with regard to any decision relating to salaries taken by the Councils.  The effects of the application of budgetary affordability methods on salary levels and consequently on the quality and competence of staff must, as far as possible, be examined over the long-term, and in any event with reference to the method&#8217;s validity period.</p>

<p align="justify">46.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In this connection, reference must be made not only to acquired rights &#8211; including the right to an economic and social level which is consistent over time &#8211; but also to the concept of legal security.  The general principle of law relating to legal security militates against the replacement of an objective and reliable method by a reference to the discretionary power of the Councils.  The replacement of methods proper - ie which yield binding results &#8211; by an &#8220;indicative&#8221; method, ie subject to the good will of the directing bodies, could infringe the principle of legal security which is meant to govern relations between staff and administrations.  This principle represents a heritage which should not be destroyed at a stroke by giving the Councils too wide a discretion.  Upholding the principle of security is closely linked to that of the legitimate expectations which international civil servants are entitled to have of the directing bodies of the organisations and their administrations.</p>

<p align="justify">Reporting committee: Committee on the Budget</p>

<p align="justify">Reference to committee: <a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc=Doc. 8413">Doc. 8413</a> and Reference No. 2395 of 26 May 1999</p>

<p align="justify">Draft recommendation unanimously adopted by the committee on 25 September 2000 </p>

<p align="justify">Members of the committee: Mr<i> Lotz (</i>Chairman), MM Koulouris, <i>Aleffi</i>&nbsp;, Soendergaard (Vice-Chairmen), <i>Mrs Angelovicova</i>, MM Annemans, <i>Anusz</i>, D&#8217;Aron, Begaj, Bojars, Bordas, Buwitt, Debono Grech, Duivesteijn, Dukic, von der Esch, Frey, Graas, Gregory (Alternate: <i>Kiely</i>), Ivanov, Mrs <i>Jäger</i>, MM Kittis, Lento, Mrs <i>Luhtanen</i>, MM Luis, Matvienko, Naydenov, Oorzhak, Mrs Pisonero, <i>Lord Ponsonby</i>, Mrs Ragnarsdottir, MM Rise, Rupar, <i>Schreiner</i>, Mrs Stanoiu (Alternate: Mr <i>Badulescu</i>), MM Svoboda, Telek, Zhirinovsky, N&#8230; (United Kingdom) (Alternate: Ms <i>Jones</i>).</p>

<p align="justify"><i>N.B. The names of those members present at the meeting are printed in italics</i></p>

<p align="justify">Secretary to the committee: Stefano Bertozzi</p>
<hr align="left" size="1" width="200" noshade>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P187_30562" href="#P187_30563">1</a> </sup> &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The &#8220;Noordwijk compromise&#8221; is an agreement between the CCR and the CRP concerning an increase in staff contributions to the pension scheme from 7 to 8% in exchange for the withdrawal of appeals lodged by staff before several Administrative Tribunals in the Co-ordinated Organisations against a deduction which they considered arbitrary.</p><!-- TRANSIT - INFOAFTER -->
</body>
</html>
