<html>
<head>
<meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=iso-8859-1">
<title>Draft protocol to the European Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine, concerning transplantation of organs and tissues of human origin</title>
<meta name="GENERATOR" content="HTML Transit 7.0 by Stellent (tm), Inc. www.stellent.com">
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="/PortailStyle.css">
</head>
<body bgcolor="#ffffff"><a name="TopOfPage"> </a>
<!-- TRANSIT - INFOBEFORE -->
<table width="100%" border="0" cellpadding="4" cellspacing="0">
  <tr>
    <td><div align="left"><img src="/Documents/LogoText.jpg" width="218" height="48"></div>
    </td>
    <td><div align="right"><img border="0" SRC="/images/logos/Logo130X120.jpg" width="130" height="120"></div>
    </td>
  </tr>
</table>
<hr size="1">

<p align="justify"><b>Doc. 9059</b></p>

<p align="justify">24 April 2001</p>

<p><b>Draft protocol to the European Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine, concerning transplantation of organs and tissues of human origin</b></p>

<p align="justify">Opinion<sup><a href="#P14_177" name="P14_178">1</a></sup> </p>

<p align="justify">Committee on Culture, Science and Education</p>

<p align="justify">Rapporteur: Mr Wolfgang Wodarg, Germany, Socialist Group</p>

<p align="justify"><b>I.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Conclusions of the committee</b></p>

<p align="justify">The Committee on Culture, Science and Education supports the draft opinion of the Social, Health and Family Affairs Committee, but proposes the following amendments:</p>

<p align="justify"><b>Amendment A</b></p>

<p align="justify">In the draft opinion, after paragraph 5, add the following new paragraph:</p>

    <ul><ul><p align="justify">&quot;In the Preamble to the draft protocol, after the second paragraph, add the following new paragraph: </p>

        <ul><ul><p align="justify">&#8220;Given that the inalienability of human dignity and fundamental human rights may in no circumstances be challenged, all actions connected with the transplantation of organs (including the fostering of organ donation) must be subject to the primacy of the inviolability of the dignity of all persons directly or indirectly concerned by the transplantation of organs and tissues of human origin (donors, relatives, recipients). Human dignity and fundamental rights are applicable for each individual, regardless. Any weighing up of dignity and fundamental rights between a donor and a recipient is inadmissible&#8221;.&quot;</p>

</ul></ul></ul></ul><p align="justify"><b>Amendment B</b></p>

<p align="justify">In the draft opinion, after paragraph 5, add the following new paragraph:</p>

    <ul><ul><p align="justify">&quot;In Article 3 of the draft protocol, after the third paragraph, add the following new paragraph:</p>

        <ul><ul><p align="justify">&#8220;The provision of organs even in shortage situations must be based exclusively on individual health benefits for the patients in question.&#8221;.</p>

</ul></ul></ul></ul><p align="justify"><b>Amendment C</b></p>

<p align="justify">In the draft opinion, after paragraph 5, add the following new paragraph:</p>

    <ul><ul><p align="justify">&quot;In Article 7 of the draft protocol, at the end of the paragraph, add the following new sentence:</p>

        <ul><ul><p align="justify">&#8220;The problems of evaluation and interpretation of brain death shall be presented in a generally comprehensible manner.&#8221;.</p>

</ul></ul></ul></ul><p align="justify"><b>Amendment D</b></p>

<p align="justify">In the draft opinion, after paragraph 5, add the following new paragraph:</p>

    <ul><ul><p align="justify">&quot;In Article 7 of the draft protocol, after the existing paragraph, add the following new paragraph:</p>

        <ul><ul><p align="justify">&#8220;The institutions and persons responsible in the transplantation system must at all times uphold the protection and the rights of donors as well as of their families. Institutional interests must be relegated to a position of secondary importance in connection with obtaining and distributing organs.&#8221;.</p>

</ul></ul></ul></ul><p align="justify"><b>Amendment E</b></p>

<p align="justify">In the draft opinion, after paragraph 7, add the following new paragraph:</p>

    <ul><ul><p align="justify">&quot;In Article 13 of the draft protocol reformulate paragraph 2 as follows:</p>

        <ul><ul><p align="justify">&#8220;Exceptionally, and under the protective conditions prescribed by law and in accordance with Articles 10 and 11, the removal of regenerative tissue from a person who does not have the capacity to consent may be authorised provided all the following conditions are met:&#8221;.</p>

</ul></ul></ul></ul><p align="justify"><b>Amendment F</b></p>

<p align="justify">In the draft opinion, after paragraph 7, add the following new paragraph:</p>

    <ul><ul><p align="justify">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&quot;In Article 15 of the draft protocol, in the second paragraph, after the words &#8220;&#8230; the same doctors who&#8221; add the followings words:</p>

        <ul><ul><p align="justify">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&#8220;, nor be involved in organisations which,&#8221;. &quot;Am</p>

</ul></ul></ul></ul><p align="justify"><b>Amendment G</b></p>

<p align="justify">In the draft opinion, after paragraph 7, add the following new paragraph:</p>

<p align="justify"> &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; &quot;Delete Article 18 of the draft protocol.&quot;</p>

<p align="justify"><b>Amendment H</b></p>

<p align="justify">In the draft opinion, after paragraph 7, add the following new paragraph:</p>

      <ul><ul><ul><p align="justify">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&quot;In Article 20 of the draft protocol, in paragraph 1, after the words &#8220;&#8230;comparable advantage.&#8221;, add the following sentences:</p>

        <ul><p align="justify">&#8220;This shall also apply when the human body or parts thereof have been altered by means of medical, biological, or technical processes. The parties hereby undertake to prosecute any form of trade or any attempt to engage therein.&#8221;.</p>

</ul></ul></ul></ul><p align="justify"><b>*****</b></p>

<p align="justify"><b>II.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Explanatory memorandum by Mr Wodarg</b></p>

<p align="justify">1.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;  The acceptance of organ donation is dependent on clear rules and on the trust of the public. It is important for scientists and doctors to rely on clear regulations accepted by the population. The limits to science and research should be well known and agreed to by all those concerned. </p>

<p align="justify">2.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In view of the ethical questions connected with transplantation of organs and tissues of human origin it is of key importance that all provisions of the draft protocol be formulated as specifically as possible.</p>

<p align="justify">3.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;  The rapporteur of the Social, Health and Family Affairs Committee, Mr Jean-François Mattei, deserves our thanks for the thorough and responsible job he did. I agree with all the amendments he proposed to the draft protocol.</p>

<p align="justify">4.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;  The amendments to Chapter III (Organ and tissue removal from living persons) proposed in the report as well as the addition to Article 20 (Prohibition of financial gain) will help bring about key improvements of the draft protocol and, as such, are very welcome. </p>

<p align="justify">5.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Mr Mattei&#8217;s report emphasises that there is an urgent need for stricter rules in two areas in particular. With regard to organ removal from living persons four amendments are proposed which are intended to bring about better protection of living donors. The report proposes an amendment with regard to prevention and repression of illegal trafficking in organs and tissues. </p>

<p align="justify">6.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The report proposes also a new version of Article 8 (General rule) which, instead of stating a possible exception, first notes that the removal of organs from living donors is to be prohibited. The possible exception to this general rule is to be described in more detail in Article 9 (Potential organ donors).</p>

<p align="justify">7.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In addition, the demand that an appropriate independent body should decide whether or not an organ may be removed from a living donor for the benefit of a recipient has been made more specific by saying that this authority should <i>preferably be a judicial one</i>.</p>

<p align="justify">8.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The report also calls for the insertion of a further article that would offer donors systematic follow-up examinations.</p>

<p align="justify">9.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In a paragraph to be added to Article 22 (Confidentiality) it is to be stipulated that donors will also be able to claim appropriate compensation for prejudice and/or damage resulting from the organ removal even when not the result of a fault.</p>

<p align="justify">10.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The report recommends adding a third paragraph to Article 20 (Prohibition of financial gain) stipulating that the contracting parties must take appropriate precautions against the misuse of adoption as a means of illegal transplantation. </p>

<p align="justify">11.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; However, in the explanatory memorandum, Mr Mattei criticizes the draft protocol for not attributing enough importance to the problem constituted by a shortage of organs (point 31). He regrets that a) the principle of tacit agreement has not been retained and b) the article on promoting donations has now been placed at the end of Chapter IV rather than at the beginning. I can not agree with this view and prefer the text of the draft protocol as it stands.</p>

<p align="justify">12. &nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Human dignity and integrity apply autonomously for every individual human being. This should be laid down specifically in the preamble of the draft protocol. It is true that human rights and fundamental freedoms are mentioned in the second paragraph but the primacy of human dignity is not expressly emphasized. To make clear that the inviolability of human dignity must apply for all persons directly and indirectly concerned by the transplantation of organs and tissues of human origin (donors, relatives, recipients) and that the noble aim of possibly saving lives may not compete with it or be placed on the same level, a new paragraph should be inserted after the second paragraph of the draft protocol, as proposed in <u>Amendment A</u>.</p>

<p align="justify">13.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The draft protocol should emphasize that the provisions of organs even in shortage situations must be based exclusively on individual health benefits for the patients in question. This is what <u>Amendment B</u> proposes.</p>

<p align="justify">14.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; For the very reason of its key significance to the discussion as a whole, the word &quot;brain death&quot; must also be given key significance in information for health professionals. Public information in the sense of the greatest possible awareness of all potential donors is a requirement for qualified decision on the part of every individual. The informed consent of the donor in person to the organ removal should be available wherever possible. This is why <u>Amendment C</u> is proposed.</p>

<p align="justify">15.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The institutions and persons responsible in the transplantation system should be required to uphold the protection and the rights of donors as well as of their families at all times. The draft protocol should underline that institutional interests must be relegated to a position of secondary importance in connection with obtaining and distributing organs. This is the goal of <u>Amendment D</u>.</p>

<p align="justify">16.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Even in States where arrangements for refusal exist, information should seek to ensure that as many people as possible consider the question of organ donation and make a declaration as to their own individual choice. Organ donation by children requires particularly sensitive regulation, taking account of the increasing self-determination of children as they grow older. In order to improve the protection of persons not able to consent to organ or tissue removal, <u>Amendment E</u> is proposed.</p>

<p align="justify">17.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In order to ensure that institutional interests do not play a role in connection with organ removal, <u>Amendment F</u> is proposed.</p>

<p align="justify">18.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The process of making donated organs available for transplant cannot be a task for the State. The transplantation of organs concerns donors and recipients, and conflicts of interest are therefore likely to arise in many cases. The role of the State can only be to provide comprehensive information concerning the possibilities and limits of organ transplantation and the protection of the dignity of all those concerned. Since these two factors are already covered in other articles,  Article 18 of the draft protocol (Promotion of donation) should be deleted, as proposed by <u>Amendment G</u>.</p>

<p align="justify">19.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Any form of trade in human organs, tissues or cells violates human dignity, and this also applies to any such attempt. Any form of &quot;reward&quot; to doctors, hospitals etc. encouraging their involvement in the system of organ removal is to be considered in the same way. The threat of prosecution provides direct protection for human dignity and must be enshrined in the draft protocol. Article 20 (Prohibition of financial gain) of the draft protocol should therefore be completed as proposed by <u>Amendment H</u>.</p>

<p align="justify">******</p>

<p align="justify">Committee for report: Social, Health and Family Affairs Committee (<a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc=Doc. 8997">Doc. 8997</a>)</p>

<p align="justify">Committee for opinion: Committee on Culture, Science and Education</p>

<p align="justify">Reference to the committee: <a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc=Doc. 8898">Doc. 8898</a>, Reference No. 2573 of 26 January 2001</p>

<p align="justify">Secretariat of the committee: Mr Grayson, Mr Ary, Mrs Theophilova-Permaul, Mr Torc&#462;toriu</p>
<hr align="left" size="1" width="200" noshade>

<p align="justify"><sup><a name="P14_177" href="#P14_178">1</a> </sup> See <a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc=Doc. 8898">Doc. 8898</a> and <a href="/ASP/Doc/RefRedirectEN.asp?Doc=Doc. 8997">Doc. 8997</a></p><!-- TRANSIT - INFOAFTER -->
</body>
</html>
